Magnificent Delusions

Great book overall.

Although I personally don't like the author but this is a well-researched book and lays out history of delusions from both sides in a very interesting manner, explaining the basis of many conspiracy theories rampant in Pakistan.
It is well-written and well-narrated.

2 of 2 people found this review helpful

Engaging but biased

Would you listen to Magnificent Delusions again? Why?

Provides a brief overview of the relationship between India and Pakistan over the years.

What was the most compelling aspect of this narrative?

The story gets more engaging when the author becomes a first hand witness to events.

What about Ralph Lister’s performance did you like?

Overall good with some minor issues with pronouncing Pakistani names correctly

Any additional comments?

The book has a lot of substance and devotes adequate amount time to each phase in the history. It would've been better if the author laid emphasis on the dates a tad more.

The author however clearly has an American bias. He portrays them as innocent and sometimes even naive in dealing with the Pakistani deception. One can't give clean chit to the US for its involvement in the affairs of other countries.

1 of 1 people found this review helpful

PAKISTAN AND U.S. RELATIONS

Husain Haqqani, in “Magnificent Delusions”, recounts the history of Pakistan and its troubled relationship with the United States and India. Haqqani explains how nations act with delusion and misunderstanding. Ethnic diversity within nations makes speaking with one voice impossible. Consequent delusions and misunderstandings between nations foment arms escalation and international conflict.

Diplomatic policy and action are a reflection of what leaders can do within the framework of their respective governments and cultures. Haqqani infers that delusion and misunderstanding correlate with cultural ignorance; an ignorance that is endemic in nation-to-nation communication.

Haqqani was imprisoned for his efforts to remove the veil of obfuscation between the United States and Pakistan. He was eventually released by the Pakistani court system and allowed to leave Pakistan. “Magnificent Delusions” is a sad tale of a hard road Pakistan travels. It is a frightening explanation of growing terrorist potential of a country riven by social, economic, and ethnic conflict.

An ambassador that understands the culture of a country he/she is sent to is the greatest protection from delusion and misunderstanding between host and sponsor countries. “Magnificent Delusions” is an excellent primer for aspiring ambassadors.

1 of 1 people found this review helpful

good overview of a troubled history/unsure future

it was definitely a fun listen with information dating back to the founding of Pakistan, the wars it created with India, and an aspiration to be the equal of India that will never come to fruition, much to their frustrations.

it seems like Pakistan's closeness with China and ability to reach out to China today helps defer the pain of paying back loans so much like America China seems to need to learn a lesson, although the probably desire a weakened India.

Most ungrateful ally?

This book does such an excellent job of explaining the incredibly dysfunctional relationship between America and Pakistan. That America would be so foolish to continue to support a country that has only once supported Americas interests, and in that one instance used American arms and money to put the Taliban in control of Afghanistan and foster al Qaeda and other radical Islamist terrorists groups, is a great indictment of American foreign policy in the near east, south and Central America, Africa, well all over the world I guess. A history of unprovoked aggression against India support and control of terrorist groups in Kashmir. They insisted on the partition of India into Pakistan and India. Then committed genocide against the already repressed newly independent Bangladesh, formerly east Pakistan. All the time getting f16s, cruisers, tanks, and billions of dollars from the USA? They traded nuclear secrets with Iran and North Korea, developed nuclear weapons while consistently lying about it the us and each year the us president had to attest to Pakistan not developing nukes in order to keep giving them economic, humanitarian, and military assistance. Absolutely fucking ridiculous! What a sad tale for the people of the world and especially the central Asian countries continuing to suffer from foreign imperialism and despotic little men.

Hussein Haqqani's personal biases

The book is well written and reiterates previous writings by Haqqani. Among other issues with this book, the sources Haqqani uses are limited in scope which do not take all aspects of the context into consideration. With the benefit of hindsight it's easy to make judgements. However, in the real world it isn't as simple as Haqqani presents it in that Pakistani generals were making a fool out of American leaders. Haqqani needs to look beyond his liberal blinders and appropriate blame to all actors that have made South Asia less secure and less prosperous than its potential. India is the regional power and thus make concessions to bring stability to the region. Haqqani failed to mention that Pakistan had proposed a Kashmir settlement along the lines of current boundaries with more autonomy for Kashmiris. It was Indian military that vetoed any deal with Pakistan on Kashmir.

Informative but perhaps a bit biased

Pakistan is made the villain in this book. Interpretation is quite biased. Book tells a story of US being naive and constantly being fooled by the Pakistanis. Writer's biases come out given his personal experiences with the Pakistani government and military.

1 of 2 people found this review helpful

Book review

A very objective description of relationship between two countries which tried to use each other.

must read (or listen)

this book is stunning for its honesty and insight. provides amazing access into the Diplomatic history of the fraught us-pakistani relationship from consummate Pakistani Insider

amazingly eye opening

yes, the author is biased but who isn't. It's really sad to read about how a country was debilitated by it's politicians and military. If there was soem sensible leadership, India and pakistan would be more like korea and japan now.