Episodes

  • Gypsy Rose Continued
    Jun 16 2026

    Investigator and host Nancy Simpson sits down for an exclusive with Greene County Sheriff Jim Arnott before he takes his role as a US Marshall to discuss his current perspective on Gypsy Rose Blanchard and the 2015 murder of her mother, Clauddine "Dee Dee" Blanchard.

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 1 min
  • BONUS TEASER: Gypsy Rose Continued
    Jun 16 2026

    Investigator and host Nancy Simpson and Producer Pamela Shelby discuss launch of The Toll Podcast's latest episode in the Gypsy Rose saga, Gypsy Rose Continued, along with the reactions and build-up.

    Show More Show Less
    6 mins
  • Main Character: A Gypsy Rose Blanchard Story
    Jan 31 2026

    Host Nancy Simpson, a trusted journalist in Springfield, sits down with a neighbor of the Blanchard family who shares her experience of the mother/daughter duo years, months and days leading up to the murder.

    Show More Show Less
    51 mins
  • Bonus Episode, Play the Part: Season 2, Poison Control
    Aug 27 2025

    Jeanette shares, in her own voice, the mental anguish and bouts with self doubt she had leading up to and after the discovery that maybe her mom, Jeanne, was hurting family members.

    Show More Show Less
    17 mins
  • Bonus Episode, Trust Issues: Season 2, Poison Control
    Jul 22 2025

    Nancy Simpson, with special guest Emily Wilson, dives into poison cases that ring a little too familiar.

    Show More Show Less
    28 mins
  • Bonus Ep 4, Thought Trees: Season 2, Poison Control
    May 25 2025

    Jeanette was well known for her "thought trees" in college. Later though, she'll use this same tool of reasoning in the fight for her life.

    Show More Show Less
    3 mins
  • Bonus Ep 3, Thanksgiving: Season 2, Poison Control
    May 25 2025

    Nancy goes through every detail with Jeanette about what she saw in the salt shaker at Thanksgiving.

    Show More Show Less
    9 mins
  • Bonus Ep 2, Extended Family: Season 2, Poison Control
    May 25 2025

    More stories from our shocking second season. This bonus content highlights the accounts of two additional family members who were suspiciously ill in Jeanne's circle.

    Show More Show Less
    11 mins