Trigger Warning: This episode contains discussion of murder, violence against women, arson, substance misuse, and graphic descriptions of injuries.
Three women. Four days. One of Birmingham’s most shocking killing sprees.This week, Dee takes Isla back to Birmingham in the year 2000 to examine the disturbing case of Philip John Smith, a man described by those who knew him as a "gentle giant" but whose actions would leave three families devastated and a city searching for answers.
What began as a seemingly ordinary night at a local pub quickly escalated into a series of brutal murders that stunned investigators. Smith had a long history of petty crime, but nothing in his record appeared to foreshadow the extraordinary violence that erupted over just a few days in November 2000.
Dee explores the lives of victims Jodi Hyde, Rosemary Corcoran, and Carol Jordan, the police investigation that rapidly closed in on Smith, and the extraordinary trail of evidence that ultimately led to his conviction. Along the way, the sisters discuss the difference between a serial killer and a spree killer, Birmingham's Irish pub scene, solvent abuse in the UK during the 1990s, and whether Smith may have had additional victims that were never proven.
Plus, because every horrifying case deserves a palate cleanser, Dee tests Isla's knowledge with a thoroughly unnecessary but highly entertaining Birmingham Quiz.
Victims Remembered
- Jodi Hyde (21) – recovering butane gas addict who had appeared in a BBC documentary about overcoming addiction
- Rosemary Corcoran (25) – mother of three
- Carol Jordan (39) – care worker and mother of six
Our thoughts are with their families and loved ones.
🎧 Listen wherever you get your podcasts, including Spotify, Apple Podcasts and YouTube.
📚 Follow Isla and browse thousands of true crime titles at Criminally Good Books💀
Follow us on social media: @switchbladesisterssocialclub
⭐ If you enjoy the show, please leave us a rating and review. It really helps other true crime fans find us.
Sources
Birmingham Post (19 July 2001) – “The Philip Smith Murders: A Man with Over Thirty Convictions; Killer's Record”
BBC News (3 July 2001) – “Man 'Killed and Mutilated' Women”
BBC News (17 July 2001) – “Man Rejects Blood-Stain Evidence”
BBC News (18 July 2001) – “Forensic Evidence Trapped Triple Killer”
BBC News (18 July 2001) – “Inquiry into Triple Killer's Past”
BBC News (29 October 2001) – “Police Probe Killer's Past”
Birmingham Evening Mail (24 November 2000) – “Murder Suspect in Court”
Sunday Mercury (2 January 2005) – “Murderers' Mars Bar Stand-Off”
Irish Independent (8 March 2001) – Tom Brady, “Serial Killer Link as Gardaí Exhume Woman's Body”
The Guardian (19 July 2001) – Helen Carterhttps://www.theguardian.com/uk/2001/jul/19/helencarter