Send us a text

Take a listen to Part 1 from last week if you want all the background info on this case!

Before Cindy died, she reported about 100 incidents of various kinds of harassment/stalking to police...but police could never find any evidence of it.

Cindy first reported instances of harassment/stalking in 1982. In the 7 years leading up to her death, Cindy reported about 100 incidents which consisted of harassment, stalking, vandalism, home invasions, and physical attacks. Cindy went missing on May 25, 1989. Two weeks later, on June 8, 1989, she was discovered deceased and in the yard of an abandoned house, with her hands and feet tied behind her back. She had been drugged and strangled. Cindy’s cause of death is heavily debated.

Spoiler: The Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) determined that Cindy had tormented herself and self orchestrated all of the incidents. She then elaborately committed suicide but staged it to look like a murder. Many strongly disagree with this theory, including her family, who believe she was murdered.

This week, we wrap up some stalking incidents and discuss Cindy's disappearance, as well as theories on what the heck happened to Cindy James.

Trigger warnings: stalking, abuse, and animal cruelty.

Sources:

1) https://unsolved.com/gallery/cindy-james/
2) https://evelazarus.com/the-bizarre-case-of-cindy-james/
3) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Cindy_James

Support the show

Send us a text

Before Cindy died, she reported about 100 incidents of various kinds of harassment/stalking to police...but police could never find any evidence of it.

Cindy first reported instances of harassment/stalking in 1982. In the 7 years leading up to her death, Cindy reported about 100 incidents which consisted of harassment, stalking, vandalism, home invasions, and physical attacks. Cindy went missing on May 25, 1989. Two weeks later, on June 8, 1989, she was discovered deceased and in the yard of an abandoned house, with her hands and feet tied behind her back. She had been drugged and strangled. Cindy’s cause of death is heavily debated.

Spoiler: The Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) determined that Cindy had tormented herself and self orchestrated all of the incidents. She then elaborately committed suicide but staged it to look like a murder. Many strongly disagree with this theory, including her family, who believe she was murdered.

For part 1, we are mostly covering the incidents leading up to her death. Tune in next week to part 2 to hear about her disappearance and theories on what the heck happened to Cindy James.

Trigger warnings: stalking, abuse, and animal cruelty.

Sources:

1) https://unsolved.com/gallery/cindy-james/
2) https://evelazarus.com/the-bizarre-case-of-cindy-james/
3) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Death_of_Cindy_James

Support the show

Send us a text

When Bobby Jo Manley arrived at her sister’s home on April 22, 2016 in Sunfish Township, Ohio, she expected to go in, feed the pets, give them some love, and then leave – probably see her sister, as well. Socialize a bit.

What Bobby Jo found would change the trajectory of her life forever – and the lives of dozens of others. Bobby Jo first found two bodies inside the home, immediately calling 9-1-1. She then found two additional bodies in a separate trailer on the property – and after calling her brother, panicked, her brother James arrived and tried to find their sister. What he found instead was a THIRD crime scene, with three more bodies. A fourth crime scene was identified 5 hours later, in a home in nearby Pikeville.

There were 8 victims in total – and one glaring connection between them. All 8 victims were either born into or married into the Rhoden family. And all 8 of them were dead.

Sources:

1)https://web.archive.org/web/20161028144512/http://www.kfvs12.com/story/33446144/pike-county-drug-cartel-speculation-were-wearing-that-label-now
2) https://www.cincinnati.com/story/news/2016/04/25/exclusive-we-aint-no-revenge-our-hearts-pike-co-family-says/83517330/?gnt-cfr=1&gca-cat=p&gca-uir=false&gca-epti=z118036u115936d00----v118036&gca-ft=249&gca-ds=sophi
3) https://www.wishtv.com/news/family-tree-released-of-8-ohio-shooting-victims/
4) https://www.wlwt.com/article/no-arrests-made-in-pike-county-slayings/3564698
5) https://www.newsweek.com/ohio-shooting-eight-family-members-killed-451348
6) https://abcnews.go.com/US/ohio-family-killings-evidence-consistent-cockfighting-found-scenes/story?id=38674426
7) https://www.wcpo.com/news/local-news/jake-wagner-back-in-pike-county-court-for-sudden-hearing
8) https://www.cincinnati.com/story/news/2024/04/15/what-happened-in-pike-county-in-2016/73293649007/?gnt-cfr=1&gca-cat=p&gca-uir=true&gca-epti=z119036d00----v119036d--xx--b--xx--&gca-ft=195&gca-ds=sophi
9) https://www.dispatch.com/story/news/state/2021/04/22/jake-wagner-rhoden-family-homicides-pike-county-ohio-pleads-guilty/7333052002/
10) https://www.cincinnati.com/story/news/2021/09/10/legal-analyst-30-year-sentence-conspirator-pike-county-slayings-fair/8281747002/?gnt-cfr=1&gca-cat=p&gca-uir=true&gca-epti=z119036d00----v119036d--xx--b--xx--&gca-ft=202&gca-ds=sophi
11) https://www.ohioattorneygeneral.gov/Media/News-Releases/April-2016/Pike-County-Multiple-Homicide-Investigation
12) https://www.foxnews.com/us/autopsies-completed-in-shooting-massacre-that-killed-8-ohio-relatives

Support the show

Send us a text

When a 92-year-old with dementia disappears, all clues point to her granddaughter and her granddaughter's husband. Without a body though, the case grows cold. Until, that is, an unlikely detective waddles by...

Sources:

1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Candler,_North_Carolina
2) https://disability-memorial.org/nellie-sullivan
3) https://people.com/crime/pet-duck-helps-police-find-body-woman-vanished-two-charged/
4) https://katv.com/news/nation-world/pet-duck-leads-to-discovery-of-womans-body-under-home-suspects-charged-with-murder-north-carolina-investigation-disappearance
5) https://wlos.com/news/local/pet-duck-leads-to-discovery-of-womans-body-under-home-suspects-charged-with-murder-candler-nellie-sullivan-angela-wamsley-mark-barnes-concealing-death-
6) https://www.facebook.com/buncombesheriff/posts/358810132957797?ref=embed_post
7) https://abc7ny.com/post/cold-case-solved-duck-as-a-pet-nellie-sullivan-dead-body-found/11809214/
8) https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2022/04/28/duck-locates-missing-grandmother-north-carolina/9568080002/
9) https://wlos.com/news/local/i-just-hope-this-is-her-woman-hopeful-human-remains-confirmed-to-be-her-missing-friend-neighbor-nellie-sullivan-mark-barnes-angela-wamsley-candler-concealing-death

Support the show

Send us a text

When one man bullies an entire town into turning a blind eye to his numerous crimes over several decades, what else can a town do but finally enact some good old vigilante justice?

Sources:

1) https://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/16/us/16bully.html
2) https://www.nwmissourinews.com/news/article_ff2ddc1c-b317-11ef-ac2c-d706c09832af.html
3) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ken_McElroy
4) https://www.shortform.com/podcast/episode/stuff-you-should-know-2024-01-24-episode-summary-the-strange-unsolved-murder-of-ken-mcelroy-stuff-you-should-know
5) https://medium.com/@darkvibestruecrime/the-ultimate-who-dun-it-who-killed-ken-mcelroy-83c1b78f8f68
6) https://allthatsinteresting.com/ken-mcelroy

Support the show

Send us a text

Today we are traveling to Tennessee, specifically to the unincorporated community of Drummonds, Tennessee. Here, the brutal murder of 36-year-old Starr Harris shook the small, tight-knit community.

Sources:

1) https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/spr-crt-ten-at-jac/1748758.html
2) https://www.actionnews5.com/story/17296068/jury-deliberating-in-starr-harris-murder-trial/
3) https://scotblog.org/2015/11/in-controversial-3-2-decision-tennessee-supreme-court-affirms-death-penalty-conviction-that-is-virtually-certain-to-be-subsequently-overturned/
Nightmare Next Door, Season 8, Episode 10: Fallen Starr
4) https://www.point2homes.com/US/Neighborhood/TN/Delta/Drummonds-Demographics.html#:~:text=FAQs%20about%20Drummonds%20demographics,Drummonds%20are%20U.S.%2Dborn%20citizens?
5) https://www.actionnews5.com/story/13720983/frinds-of-starr-harris-remember-her-as-christmas-approaches/

Support the show

Send us a text

Today we're going to be talking about the murder of Shirley Ann Duguay, who went missing in 1994 and was later found dead in a shallow grave.
Shirley Ann Duguay was from Canada and a 32-year-old mother of five. Most reports don’t go into any sort of detail about who she was as a person or really anything about her personal life, mostly due to the nature of her death and the fact that her case marked a “first” in a legal trial.

Sources:

1) https://www.findagrave.com/memorial/183574170/shirley_ann-duguay
2) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Shirley_Duguay
3) https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/prince-edward-island/doug-beamish-released-2025-halfway-house-1.7591226
4) https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/prince-edward-island/pei-doug-beamish-parole-1.7344995

Support the show

Send us a text

On the morning of November 15, 2004, Peter Porco woke up as usual and carried out his typical morning routine: he packed a lunch, he filled the dishwasher, and he wrote and signed a check to his son Christopher. He even locked himself out of the house, found his spare key, and let himself back in.
And then, Peter Porco fell over and died. It would seem so random – he had a completely normal morning, after all – except for the fact that Peter had been struck in the head 16 times with an axe prior to getting out of bed and somehow carried on with his day despite the horrific blood trail he left throughout his home.

Sources: 1)https://web.archive.org/web/20090606011130/http://www.timesunion.com/specialreports/porco/
2) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Pc8B9PQ0To
3) https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/an-unfamiliar-face-in-a-distant-courtroom-578517.php
4) https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/porco-trial-prosecutors-point-to-unusual-alarm-580228.php
5) https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/porcos-son-indicted-578542.php
6) https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/peter-porco-s-death-detailed-580264.php
7) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Peter_Porco
8) https://spotlightnews.com/news/2006/07/20/jurors-see-video-of-yellow-jeep-leaving-campus/
9) https://spotlightnews.com/news/2006/08/03/former-neighbor-who-saw-jeep-testifies/
10) https://allthatsinteresting.com/christopher-porco
11) https://www.timesunion.com/news/article/E-mails-reveal-Porco-family-rift-578537.php

Support the show