On a quiet Halloween night in one of America’s wealthiest neighborhoods, 15-year-old Martha Moxley was brutally murdered just steps from her own front door. For years, the case remained shrouded in rumors, privilege, and unanswered questions. Investigators faced dead ends, public scrutiny, and a suspect whose powerful family connections fueled endless controversy. It would take decades before anyone was held accountable for Martha’s murder, and even then, the legal battle was far from over.

For years, Steven Cunningham evaded responsibility for a brutal murder while an innocent teenager sat behind bars. After the murder of Angela Correa, Jeffrey Deskovic was wrongfully convicted and spent 16 years in prison. It wasn't until DNA testing years later that Cunningham was identified as the true killer, but by then he had already claimed the life of Patricia Morrison as well. In this episode, we examine the crimes, the investigation, and the wrongful conviction that changed countless lives forever.

When 15 year old Angela Correa was murdered in Peekskill, New York, investigators believed they had their suspect, teenager Jeffrey Deskovic. But after spending 16 years behind bars, DNA evidence proved he was innocent, revealing one of Westchester County’s most devastating wrongful conviction cases.

On July 26, 2009, a devastating wrong way crash on the Taconic State Parkway in the town of Mount Pleasant, NY left eight people dead and shocked all of New York. Behind the wheel was Diane Schuler, described by many as “put together” and responsible. But as investigators uncovered toxicology reports, frantic phone calls, and unanswered questions, the story became far more disturbing than anyone could’ve imagined.

A love triangle. A brutal murder. And a case so disturbing it feels ripped from a psychological thriller.

This week on Crime Snob, we dive into the twisted story of Sheila Davalloo, a woman whose obsession, jealousy, and manipulation left one woman dead and another man fighting for his life across Connecticut and Westchester County.

In January 2016, the quiet, affluent village of Scarsdale was rocked by its first homicide in nearly 40 years when Julius Reich was accused of brutally murdering his wife, beloved pediatrician Dr. Robin Goldman, inside their multimillion-dollar home.

In the quiet, affluent village of Bronxville, the brutal murder of Anne Scripps Douglas shattered the illusion of safety behind closed doors. What first seemed unthinkable quickly turned into a chilling reminder that sometimes the most dangerous threats aren’t always strangers.

She told her mom she was scared, like someone was going to kill her.

Days later, 24 year old Valerie Reyes vanished without a trace from her New Rochelle, New York apartment, only to be found stuffed inside a suitcase & dumped on the side of a quiet Greenwich, Connecticut road.

What happened in between is a story of manipulation, greed, and a shocking timeline that hits way too close to home.

Valerie’s story is heartbreaking but it is also powerful, it reminds us of the importance of listening to our instincts, setting boundaries, and never ignoring red flags.