The Comanagers continue their deep dive into the NFL’s chaotic coaching hiring cycle by answering one deceptively simple question: which head coaching jobs are actually good?

John and Justin rank every open head coach position from this cycle, breaking down roster talent, quarterback outlooks, cap flexibility, ownership patience, and realistic expectations. Buffalo sits at the top for both hosts, but after that, the lists diverge quickly. Is New York quietly set up for success? Is Miami trying to build a house using two completely different LEGO sets? And is Pittsburgh secretly the hardest job in football now?

After ranking the jobs, the guys react to the new hires already on the board, including Kevin Stefanski landing in Atlanta, Jeff Hafley inheriting a messy Miami situation, John Harbaugh’s massive deal with the Giants, and Robert Saleh taking on a Titans rebuild that may hinge entirely on Cam Ward.

If you’re wondering which teams are primed for a turnaround—and which ones are walking into a buzzsaw—this episode breaks it all down.

Text a question or just say hi!

Support the show

The Comanagers officially enter the coaching chaos season.

In Episode 89, John kicks off a multi-episode deep dive into the NFL’s firing and hiring cycle with one of the most mind-melting stats imaginable: only two head coaches in the entire AFC have held the same head-coaching job since 2022—Zac Taylor and Andy Reid. Everyone else? Toast.

We break down every major coaching exit, from shocking firings to “mutual partings” that absolutely were not mutual. Sean McDermott is out after nine years in Buffalo. Kevin Stefanski is gone despite two Coach of the Year awards. Miami pulls the plug on Mike McDaniel. Pete Carroll lasts one season in Vegas. And yes… even legends like John Harbaugh and Mike Tomlin are suddenly no longer on the sidelines.

We talk playoff droughts, impossible expectations, owners paying coaches to not coach, and what it actually takes to survive more than five minutes as an NFL head coach. This is the first chapter of the Comanagers Coaching Cycle saga—and it only gets messier from here.

Text a question or just say hi!

Support the show

Conference Championship Week is here, and the Comanagers are locked in. Episode 88 breaks down the final two matchups standing between the Super Bowl and us, starting with New England traveling to Denver with Jarrett Stidham under center and Bo Nix sidelined. Is this the easiest playoff path ever, or is a trap game brewing?

On the NFC side, we dive into Rams vs Seahawks, two teams trending in opposite directions. Seattle looks dominant, the Rams keep surviving by the skin of their teeth, and nobody is quite sure how this ends.

We run it back with the Comanagers Clash, where Justin narrowly squeaks out a 3–2 win, then roll into Fantasy Feast, picking the players we think will absolutely cook in the toughest week of the season.

We close by teasing next week’s episode on the NFL coaching carousel—highlighted by an all-time angry Baker Mayfield tweet—because even when the games slow down, the chaos never does.

Text a question or just say hi!

Support the show

The Comanagers are back after a week off, and we waste no time getting right back into playoff madness. Episode 87 opens with Justin discovering the rare joy of actually needing a jacket on vacation, before we dive headfirst into a full NFL Playoff Recap.

We break down every game from Wildcard Weekend through the Divisional Round. From the Rams and Bears surviving late-game insanity, to Buffalo riding Josh Allen until the wheels nearly came off, to the Eagles officially being put out of their misery, nothing is off limits.

We debate Chicago’s run of miracles (and whether divine intervention is officially in play), marvel at Jauan Jennings throwing a better deep ball than half the league, and react to historic meltdowns—including CJ Stroud’s five-pick, five-fumble nightmare and Bo Nix’s ankle injury changing everything in Denver.

If you like cold-weather football, playoff overreactions, quarterback chaos, and the Comanagers doing what they do best—this one’s for you.

Text a question or just say hi!

Support the show

Episode 86 kicks off with John calling out one of the most painful truths of the 2025 fantasy season: the sophomore slump absolutely wrecked the 2024 wide receiver class. From overhyped breakouts to weekly lineup landmines, we break down how expectations crashed into reality.

From there, it’s full Playoff Week Preview mode as we dive into Fantasy Feast, highlighting the players we think will carry teams when it matters most. The Comanagers Clash returns, where John and Justin go head-to-head in Feast vs. Famine picks—ending with John pulling out a decisive 5–4 victory.

We wrap things up with Playoff Picks across the wild-card weekend. If you’re celebrating your recent title or just here to listen to us argue with confidence, this episode sets the table for playoff glory.

Text a question or just say hi!

Support the show

In this episode, John opens with one of the cruelest truths of fantasy football: dominating the regular season meant absolutely nothing in 2025. We break down the wild stats showing just how unlikely it was for top regular-season teams to actually win a fantasy championship—and why the playoffs remain a beautiful, unpredictable mess.

From there, we hand out the highly anticipated 2025 Comanagers Fantasy Awards, celebrating the biggest heroes, villains, comebacks, and nuclear performances of the year. Christian McCaffrey takes home MVP honors after a full return to dominance, while Bijan Robinson delivers a legendary playoff run worthy of league-winner status. We also recognize massive value picks like JSN and Matthew Stafford, who shattered expectations.

We shine a spotlight on the League Sinners who broke hearts in the playoffs, the Back From the Dead stars who resurrected their careers, and the rookies who made an immediate impact. Finally, we unleash the Nuclear Awards, honoring the single most devastating fantasy performances at every position—weeks that ended matchups before Sunday night.

If you want closure on the fantasy season, validation for your draft takes, or reminders of how unfair this game truly is, this episode delivers.

Text a question or just say hi!

Support the show

Episode 84 opens with immediate chaos as Justin unloads on one of the softest ejections of the season—Alec Pierce getting tossed for barely brushing a referee. It’s a rant fueled by disbelief, slow-motion replays, and the age-old question: what are we even doing here?

From there, we take a victory lap through a week full of NFL history, including Myles Garrett breaking the single-season sack record, Caleb Williams rewriting the Bears’ passing record book (while still somehow not reaching 4,000 yards), Trevor Lawrence setting a new Jaguars scoring mark, and Cam Little casually kicking field goals from another zip code.

We roll into This Just In with Justin to cover a wild coaching carousel, highlighted by the Raiders firing Pete Carroll after one season—and the organization now paying $50+ million to coaches who no longer work there. The Falcons, Cardinals, Browns, and Giants also make moves.

If you like football news, fantasy reflection, and yelling at referees, Episode 84 has you covered.

Text a question or just say hi!

Support the show

Episode 83 starts exactly where it should: with completely unhinged NFL stats that make absolutely no sense. The Packers are somehow 0–3 when they don’t punt, the Eagles are 3–0 when they forget how to throw the ball for an entire half, and that pretty much sets the tone for the rest of the episode.

From there, we dive into another round of Fantasy Feast + Famine, including a tightly contested Comanagers Clash where Justin barely squeaks out a win thanks to just enough correct chaos. Trey McBride continues his reign of terror at tight end, while Derrick Henry somehow ends up on the Famine list as RB1.

We break down the best matchups of the week in Fantasy Feast, fade the landmines in Fantasy Famine, and detour into one of the strangest NFL side plots of the season: DK Metcalf getting suspended for fighting a fan… who then held a press conference wearing a suit and a backwards Lions hat to defend himself.

If you like your fantasy analysis mixed with bad beats, broken logic, and the feeling that none of us truly understand this sport—Episode 83 is for you.

Text a question or just say hi!

Support the show