Excellent Course- Needs Battle Maps

I found this course to be well taught and fascinating. The Professor was excellent. Although I may not agree with all of the battles selected by the Professor as being the most important in world history (especially some of the ancient ones)- I did enjoy the manner in which he described his methodology for choosing the battles and I learned a great deal about some historical events that I really knew nothing about. The biggest complaint that I have with this course is the lack of maps for each battle. You really cannot understand strategy, movement and terrain withoug some form of visual display. I really think that Audible should contract with the Great Corses to add a pdf file of the maps for each battle. Otherwise I would recommend that one purchase this course directly from the Teaching Company

62 people found this helpful

Very Interesting and Well Narrated

What did you love best about The Decisive Battles of World History?

The author, Prof. Aldrete, who is also the narrator, does a fantastic job of describing not only the occurrences on the battlefield, but also of the history behind and beside. This way, this course actually offers a bit of an overview of the last 3000 years of human history, in light of decisive battles. I really liked that Prof. Aldrete offers this list of battles as his own view, debatable and open for discussion. I have to admit - every time I thought to myself "why did he not include this", or "here his biases do come into view", I would always get my answer later in the lesson for why a battle was not included, or the battle I thought of was included in a later lesson. All in all, a truly interesting, engaging course. One caveat: for ancient times, Prof. Aldrete does not struggle with ancient names. He simply makes no effort to pronounce them in anything but a very American accent. As a narrator, he cautions in the beginning of the course that the course may reflect his own biases - well, this is the only bias I have found.
By the way - one of the reviewers said battle-maps were missing. In the one or two instances I really felt the need to see a map - I found it on Wikipedia. Hence, I don't find the lack of maps to be a real shortcoming. Their addition would of course have been welcome.

27 people found this helpful

Like Reading a Movie

I originally gave this book 4 stars, but every book I've read after this seems so boring in comparison I had to reevaluate the rating: 5 stars. A really fun read, almost like reading an action movie.

16 people found this helpful

Outstanding content. Grating delivery.

This is a compelling lecture series. The instructor is very knowledgeable in the subject and manages to bring these battles to life in the relatively short time dedicated to each. Highly recommended to any student of military history.
My only complaint deals with the delivery. Prof. Aldrete pronounces every third word as though it comes as a complete surprise to him. It's exhausting to listen to. That said, the information is well worth the effort to consume it.

25 people found this helpful

Excellent!

Any additional comments?

This is a very good overview of major battles in world history. The professor's delivery is excellent. He does a good job in the first lecture at explaining his rationale for choosing the battles that he did. The lectures on the battles themselves are a perfect blend of background information, the battle, and the aftermath. I am a military history buff, so this course is right up my alley! That said, I think that anyone interested in world history would benefit from listening to it. Do it today. You won't be sorry.

10 people found this helpful

Enjoyable and interesting, but not great.

While I enjoyed this book, I found it to be my least favorite of the Great Courses books that I have listened to. This one covers a lot of ground but the content tended to be less like a history book and more like one of those “strange facts” books. A large portion of the book is essentially conjecture that comes across as fact. It also seemed like there was an effort on the part of the Author to be politically correct in his selection of the battles he determined were decisive. The battles covered, while numerous, are described at the highest of levels – the content is broad just not very deep. Professor Aldrete seemed a little uncomfortable narrating the book which made some parts difficult to listen to. In the end the Professor says his goal in writing the book was to stimulate thought on behalf of the listeners and in that sense he accomplished his goal. It’s a good book, but not Great.

9 people found this helpful

Pleasant surprise

I thought it would only be about battle and tactics, but it was a pleasant combination of those and historical background and influences of the different battles.

5 people found this helpful

Excellent survey of decisive battles in history

This is an excellent survey of some of the most important/decisive battles in world history.

This is an overview of battles that made a difference, whether that means they were a turning point in the history of empires, or the introduction of a game-changing technology, or whether they were the most important/indicative of a series of battles that changed the fate of the world.

You could argue that some battles not included might have been more important, but this is a survey, not a compete history of all important battles.

Professor Aldrete does a good job of explaining both the battles, and why they were on his list as key decisive battles in history.

Folks, let me be concise in this review. Spend a credit on this if the topic interests you. It's worth your credit.

11 people found this helpful

Good first step, easy to understand

The lecturer clearly enjoys and is passionate about his subject. He makes it simple enough that there is no need to go into this series with a doctorate is history. He is honest about his shortcomings and personal preferences and he invites readers (listeners) to disagree with him. This is a great way to pick up some military history as each lecture is self contained and allows you to listen for 30 minutes at a pop and return without having to back up to figure out where you are in history.

4 people found this helpful

Well worth it

This is an engaging and well-performed overview of the decisive battles in world history, informative yet colorful and packed with fun tidbits. Highly recommended for casual readers of military history like me.

3 people found this helpful