Mussolini's War
Fascist Italy from Triumph to Collapse, 1935-1943
Ürünler eklenemedi
Sepete ekleme başarısız oldu.
İstek Listesine ekleme başarısız oldu.
İstek listesinden kaldırma başarısız oldu.
Kütüphaneye ekleme başarısız oldu
Podcast takip edilemedi
Podcast takibi bırakma başarısız oldu.
3 ay boyunca aylık £0,99
15,24£ karşılığında satın al
-
Seslendiren:
-
Mark Elstob
-
Yazan:
-
John Gooch
Brought to you by Penguin.
While staying closely aligned with Hitler, Mussolini remained carefully neutral until the summer of 1940. Then, with the wholly unexpected and sudden collapse of the French and British armies, Mussolini declared war on the Allies in the hope of making territorial gains in southern France and Africa. This decision proved a horrifying miscalculation, dooming Italy to its own prolonged and unwinnable war, immense casualties and an Allied invasion in 1943 which ushered in a terrible new era for the country.
John Gooch's new book is the definitive account of Italy's war experience. Beginning with the invasion of Abyssinia and ending with Mussolini's arrest, Gooch brilliantly portrays the nightmare of a country with too small an industrial sector, too incompetent a leadership and too many fronts on which to fight.
Everywhere - whether in the USSR, the Western Desert or the Balkans - Italian troops found themselves against either better-equipped or more motivated enemies. The result was a war entirely at odds with the dreams of pre-war Italian planners - a series of desperate improvizations against Allies who could draw on global resources and against whom Italy proved helpless.
This remarkable book rightly shows the centrality of Italy to the war, outlining the brief rise and disastrous fall of the Italian military campaign.
© John Gooch 2020 (P) Penguin Audio 2020
Eleştirmen yorumları
If you enjoy a book with a lot of details about military manoeuvres and logistics, then this is definitely for you, but personally it wasn't my cup of tea.
Detailed summary of Italian Military in WW2
Bir sorun oluştu. Lütfen birkaç dakika sonra tekrar deneyin.
Detailed account of the Italian war effort
Bir sorun oluştu. Lütfen birkaç dakika sonra tekrar deneyin.
However there are a few week points:
- The narrator sounds quite sarcastic throughout which gives the overall feeling somewhat one sided despite certain aknowledgements of Italian successes, bravery, etc. This may just be my opinion but I'm including it.
- Sometimes the book lacks detail; for example It does a fantastic view of covering the supply situation over its course but does not consistently delve deeply into specific battles and strategies, which you would expect more in a book explicitly focusing on the war ("Mussolini's War"). It also touches on political development within Italy (as that's unavoidable). But this covering is fragmented, sometimes skipping or skimming past important events, and sometimes delving in a bit deeper (such as the final chapter of the book).
This switching around between areas covered and between depth of coverage can leave the reader a little bit confused if he/she does not have a good idea of the events of history at the time. Arguably most people reading this are likely to have a decent comprehension of the second world war in general as it's a quite specific topic, but I felt the author assumed it too much.
Interesting Book
Bir sorun oluştu. Lütfen birkaç dakika sonra tekrar deneyin.
However for a general reader, I would not recommend this audiobook. The focus on stats, such as the amount of munitions and supplies in excruciating detail, comes at the expense of context. The author does give the reader an idea of the bigger picture, or of the motivations and strategic aims of Italy and it's leaders. There is very little at all on Mussolini and he is barely characterised - anyone looking for something that focuses on him (as would be expected from the title) will be disappointed.
The same is true of any of the military leaders involved - they all blend into one and are hard to remember without any characterisation.
Plenty of detail, little context (or mussolini)
Bir sorun oluştu. Lütfen birkaç dakika sonra tekrar deneyin.
jumps back and forward a bit too much
well researched and presented.
Good, just good.
Bir sorun oluştu. Lütfen birkaç dakika sonra tekrar deneyin.