Enjoyed this coming out story ALOT

If you could sum up Keeping You a Secret in three words, what would they be?

Inspirational, Motivating, Factual.

What was one of the most memorable moments of Keeping You a Secret?

When Cece finally told Holland the real reason she did not want her to meet her friends or come out of the closet. The fact that she was afraid to lose Holland is the real reason she lied to her. Though lying to your partner is still wrong. I absolutely love how Cece stuck with Holland through her being kicked out of the house as well. True love.

Have you listened to any of Rebekah Levin’s other performances before? How does this one compare?

No, I have not, but I will definitely be checking some more out.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

Yes, there were parts that made me tear up. And there were parts that made me mad. Like the part where Hollands mom was hitting her for being inlove and being who she is.

Any additional comments?

This book is great for LGBT's who are going through the coming out phase. It'll be a great listen so they will know how to approach accepting who they are, and making the world know they are proud of who they are as an individual, a person and as a group.

8 people found this helpful

Dialogue Done With Odd Voice Acting

What disappointed you about Keeping You a Secret?

Ugh. The voiceover artist has a fantastic voice. I love it. But during parts of dialogue, she begins using these very over-acted, almost bumbling voices for the other characters. This performance made it difficult for me to finish. Even the love interest's "voice" is so annoying, I couldn't get into the relationship. Reading the book was superior because these silly voices did not exist in my head (praise the Lordt).

How did the narrator detract from the book?

The annoying voices she used during dialogue. She was speaking in such a way that it seems like she is making fun of the person talking (teachers, mom, Cece, Seth, friends, etc.)... which, in my opinion, changes the author's intent.

6 people found this helpful

A story of how not to love

Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?

Yes for the perspective of what love isn't. The relationship between the two girls is abusive. Cece is abusive of Holland and when you love someone you just aren't. As an attorney who has helped many women in such relationships with men the fact the other person is a woman doesn't change the situation.

Would you recommend Keeping You a Secret to your friends? Why or why not?

Obsessive love is not love. It is possession and selfish. As an example of this yes.

What do you think the narrator could have done better?

Yes.

Did Keeping You a Secret inspire you to do anything?

Yes to write this review. I had not written any before reading this book. It took me six months to get around to it and I even wrote other reviews prior to this one but reading this boom left me with a desire to say what happened in the book was not true love.

20 people found this helpful

Struggled with the narrator but a good story

Would you recommend this book to a friend? Why or why not?

The story itself is a pretty good one. It's not stellar or complicated and the characters aren't totally developed but it is a good LGBT young adult book (and with the absence of any descriptive sex scenes beyond kissing and some suggestive hand placements, it isn't necessarily a "mature young adult" novel) and there aren't tons of really good ones available, especially with a lesbian protagonist.

The story got a little narrow at times--like the setting and side stories that the author had spent lots of time in early chapters developing suddenly disappeared and it felt a bit out of place almost. I kept wondering about the things that were created early in the book but there were little to no mentions of them.

The story of realizing one's sexuality and then coming out read as having moments of true authenticity and moments of, "well, that probably wouldn't have happened" or "wouldn't someone notice this and asked or done something?". The emotions were often on the mark and the potential for total disaster was all too true, but other aspects were just felt a little off.

I really wished the book had been a bit longer and had a bit more meat. Some better character development for the supporting cast, maybe a little more into potential teacher relationship (it bugged me that a student like Holland could suddenly have grades plummet without at least one teacher checking in... and a few other strange moments that just didn't seem plausible) and even a little bit more to the ending. Although I have hankering for some resolution, this is not a book that has me desperate for finding out more or wanting a sequel or sad that the story is over.

It was good, but not so amazing that I'm hooked to the story or the characters (though this may be in part due to the narration that I struggled to deal with). In the immediate aftermath, I am curious, but I suspect that by tomorrow I will have moved on. But, that isn't to say the book isn't worth the read... it tells an important story and is better than some on this topic.

I'd probably recommend the book over the audio book, but that's just me.

How could the performance have been better?

I really struggled with handling the narrator's voices that she used. I nearly quit listening a few times because of how she read the story but I was invested enough in the story (and my local library didn't have the book copy that I could just go and read) that I wanted to know what happened.

You don't really hear it on the audio sample, but she voices one of the characters with this obnoxiously annoying nasely voice, there is valley-girl twang in there at times, and the male voices were over-exaggerated and just pleasant to me.

I'm sure to some people it was lovely, for me the voices really detracted from the book and it gave me a really hard time.

Was Keeping You a Secret worth the listening time?

For the story, yes, absolutely. It was a pretty quick listen (finished in a few days because I got invested in the story and wanted to know what would happen).

For the narration, no! It felt like forever until I could finally stop listening (i finished in a few days because I wanted to be done listening to the narration asap).

4 people found this helpful

Great Book

Where does Keeping You a Secret rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

I haven’t read much experience with audiobooks, but this was the first one that I truly enjoyed. It was a lot easier to focus on than the previous audiobooks that I’ve read, which could be because I’m better at focusing on them but it probably is because it’s a contemporary. The writing style feels more conversational, like Holland is just your friend telling you her story, which a type of style that I enjoy because I can fly through easily and it keeps me entertained and happy.

What other book might you compare Keeping You a Secret to and why?

I don't really have any comparisons.

This book is so important for LGBTQ teenagers, but also enjoyable if you’re not. I’m guilty of not reading a lot of books with gay main characters, but I wonder why not. A lot of the same subjects of romance, personal life struggles, finding love and acceptance - anyone can relate to that. I have to say, though, for someone struggling to come out, this book would be specially important. Coming out is a tough choice and a tough journey for most people, and it is so for Holland. I think someone could identify with this and thus find the strength to face their own struggle. This branch of literature needs to exist so that gay teens are able to see themselves, realize that they are okay, that there’s nothing wrong with them, that other people are experiencing this same thing. It is also important for heterosexuals, so they can see that being gay isn’t so completely off the norm.

Would you listen to another book narrated by Rebekah Levin?

Maybe. Some of the narrators acting choices just felt a little off for me. Yes, this was the audiobook I’ve enjoyed the most so far, but I have to mention this. Some of the voices she used for the secondary characters were just so weird. It really annoyed me. The story was enjoyable enough that I could get past it though.

Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

Some things hurt. There were some tough parts in this book, some bad things that happened with our main character that really made me physically hurt and rage. I consider this a good point in favor of the book, because it was capable of making me feel strong emotions.

Any additional comments?

I related to the main character so much. Holland is going through more than just coming out and accepting that she is a lesbian. The way she feels about planning for her future, the pressure from her mum and her teachers, her opinion on other people’s behaviors - I really related to that. When I was a teen, I completely had some of the reactions that she has to things, and even now as I face some difficult “planning for the future” times this struggle resonated with me. I don’t always have to identify with a character to enjoy them or a book, but what I’m trying to say is that Holland felt especially real to me because of all that.

Not so good things:

Insta love. Yes, the romance is sweet, but I just couldn’t help but feel it was rushed. Holland and Cece have literally just met, and they go from being weird acquaintances to friends, but not really friends to “oh, my god you are completely the love of my life” in a spam of what feels like days. I might be wrong with the timeline, because I’m not sure how much time has actually passed from when they met to when they get together, but to me it felt rushed. Sometimes they would gush about how much they loved each other and I would roll my eyes. I just feel like their relationship could have taken more time to develop, that’s all.

Who is Cece? I don’t feel like we really got to truly know aspects of her life other than being a lesbian and dealing and being proud. I wished we could have seen more about her - which also would have helped with the rushed aspect of the romance. I understand why the author made these choices though. This book wasn’t about the romance, it was about coming out and discovering yourself. Cede and the romantic aspects worked as a vehicle for this story to work.

To Sum Up:

I really liked this book, I was entertained all the way through and I enjoyed and related to the main character. It was an important book to read, it had a strong message and it made me feel things. It wasn’t an all time favorite or a perfect book, but it was really well worth the read.

3 people found this helpful

Good coming out story for teenagers

Story was good, it touched on the real life issues of coming out in high school, and the pain that accompanies it.
The romance was weak, no passion or build up, then once the girls kissed, let went from attraction straight to love.
So it was a poor romance story, but a great story about the issues with finding out your gay..... in high school

2 people found this helpful

meeeh... could use an ending

Would you try another book from Julie Anne Peters and/or Rebekah Levin?

not really...

What was most disappointing about Julie Anne Peters’s story?

too outdated and lost so much time on the beginning...

Did the narration match the pace of the story?

kinda

You didn’t love this book... but did it have any redeeming qualities?

the narrator did a decent job

Any additional comments?

has no ending whatsoever... too naif for me

5 people found this helpful

An easy listen

So I’m 23 and the story itself is a little young for me but I recently came out so it resonated with me. The voices of the nasty characters were just how I would’ve read them in my head. If you’re looking for something relatable and you’ve come out in the LGBT+ community, I recommend.

1 person found this helpful

Enjoyed a lot

Some of the reviews had me a little scared to listen to this book but I thought the reader did an excellent job. I docked a star off just because the ending was a little abrupt. Happyish but kind of sudden. There was supposed to be an abusive relationship ship and sure it wasn't the best start for a relationship but they talked it out and everything was fine between them.

1 person found this helpful

Dated but excellent

4.5 STARS

Fifteen years ago, when KEEPING YOU A SECRET was first published, mainstream publishing house rarely distributed LGBT literature. Julie Ann Peters’s writing changed that with her stories that appealed to all YA readers, not just the LGBT community.

Because in the USA, progress toward not just accepting, but embracing sexual minorities as mainstream, KEEPING YOU A SECRET is dated. Teens like Holland are still kicked out of their homes for their sexual orientation and as a society we still have a long way to go but I have lived fifty years of change and growth and I am encouraged.

I enjoyed rereading KEEPING YOU A SECRET a second time, the first was when this book was initially published in the early 2000s. The ending was too abrupt for me, although I can see why Peters finished as she did.

The audiobook was well-narrated.