Deng Xiaoping

Thought-provoking

Deng Xiaoping was a devoted member of the communist party. Unlike Mao Zedong, Deng Xiaoping left almost no paper trail which has made it difficult for historians. He was noted to be crafty, and an obsessive bridge player. Deng Xiaoping was educated in France.

Pantsov, a professor of history at Capital University in Ohio, has done extensive research into the life of Deng Xiaoping. Steven I. Levine is a research faculty associate in the Department of History at the University of Montana. They spent years combing Russian achieves, obtaining access to Chinese documents and interviews with people. Obtaining as much information as the Chinese would allow.

The book is divided into three parts. The first part covers Deng’s life from birth in 1904 to meeting Mao in 1927. The second part covers his life with Mao up to 1950. The third part covers 1951 to his death and includes his denouncement during the Cultural Revolution. He gained control of the Communist party after the death of Mao. Deng Xiaoping was the one who ordered the Army into Tiananmen Square. Pantsov states that Deng Xiaoping was responsible for reducing poverty in China by over 50%.

The biography is well balanced and primarily well researched. The book also covers some of the history of China during this timeframe. The book is somewhat long at 22 hours. George Backman narrated the book.

5 of 7 people found this review helpful

Question on credibility

Overall it's a good book. I picked up some information previously unaware. The biggest question that I have is how the author could possibly gain access to a lot of private conversations. Much of that would not be in written form anywhere. I have serious doubt that the Russian archive could have such private conversation between the most senior and secretive leaders of China. That's a huge issue for me because it deals with the credibility of the entire book.

2 of 3 people found this review helpful

Amazing story, excellent performance

As a Chinese speaker, I was very pleased that the narrator was able to accurately pronounce the various names and other words in Chinese--well done!

One drawback, the audio begins with the list of characters in the book--Super boring way to start the book, just skip it. The rest moves along pretty well.

A well-balanced portrait of an important figure

This was a long book, but it could have been even longer and I would have kept listening. This is a good portrait of Deng that neither deifies nor demonizes him, but rather uses a wealth of sources to paint a complete picture of the man, warts and all (probably as Deng would have wanted it). This book does focus on Deng, recommend that potential readers/listeners go into this book with some knowledge of modern Chinese historical events like The Great Leap Forward and The Cultural Revolution so that they have an idea of the bigger picture.

Narration was very good., smooth and enjoyable

TRUTH FROM FACTS

Mao Zedong is said to have written–one must find truth from facts. The authors of “Deng Xiaoping” infer that Mao’s aphorism is institutionalized by his thrice demoted follower, Deng Xiaoping. Deng becomes the eventual supreme leader of the Chinese communist party. As shown in this biography, Deng’s truth is drawn from Deng’s selected facts. Deng’s pragmatism leads to the meteoric rise of China’s economy after the Cultural Revolution.

Alexander Patsov’s and Steven Levine’s research and writing supports an argument that Deng Xiaoping changed the course of the Chinese revolution by pragmatically applying the aphorism of “truth from facts”. Deng Xiaoping’s leadership quadruples the gross national product of China in a twenty year period from 1980 to 2000.

Though the authors offer great insight to Deng’s role in China, the deaths consequent to Communism’s rise to power, and Deng’s participation in those deaths, are glossed over. With the exception of Tiananmen Square and the brutalization of Deng’s family, the horror of the Communist Revolution is treated clinically rather than literally. Aside from the brutal part of China’s twentieth century history, this biography is a revelation to the uninformed.

“Deng Xiaoping” is a worthy listen. It is long but needs length to offer its nuanced view of Deng Xiaoping and where China is heading. In a world of capitalist countries, China’s capitalism is, in some respects, a distinction without a difference. China suffers from the same greed and corruption that all capitalist countries succumb to when freedom of the individual takes precedence over freedom of the public. The fundamental difference among capitalist countries lies in democracy; and the question of who gets to decide on a nation’s direction.

1 of 2 people found this review helpful

SuziQ

If you believe that Chairman Mao is NOT responsible for the murder of MILLIONS of his people, that he is innocent of starving, persecuting, enslaving the people of China, then this book is for you.
If you are THAT DELUSIONAL than Deng is your scapegoat, along with others that Mao didn't brainwashed, terrorized, and secluded the Chinese from the rest of the world.

How the author's can claim this is an in-depth researched book is beyond me!

For the TRUE story read Jung Chang's book on Mao! A woman who LIVED while many of her family & friends didn't because of the psychotic megalomania of ONE man that was insidious enough to enslave a population.

1 of 5 people found this review helpful