The Last Jedi: Addressing the Criticisms That Still Divide Star Wars Fans

Failed to add items

Sorry, we are unable to add the item because your shopping cart is already at capacity.

Add to basket failed.

Please try again later

Add to wishlist failed.

Please try again later

Remove from wishlist failed.

Please try again later

Adding to library failed

Please try again

Follow podcast failed

Unfollow podcast failed

The Last Jedi: Addressing the Criticisms That Still Divide Star Wars Fans

Listen for free

View show details

The Last Jedi remains the most polarizing Star Wars movie ever made. Love it or hate it, Rian Johnson’s Episode VIII triggered one of the biggest fan backlashes in franchise history — and the arguments haven’t slowed down nearly a decade later.

In this episode we directly address the criticisms that refuse to die:
• Luke Skywalker’s shocking portrayal as a broken hermit who failed his students
• The decision to make Rey’s parents “nobodies” instead of tying her to existing legacy characters
• The casino planet subplot on Canto Bight and whether it was a waste of runtime
• Vice Admiral Holdo’s command style and the infamous hyperspace ram
• Killing Supreme Leader Snoke far too early in the trilogy
• Finn and Rose’s arc and the larger themes of failure, hope, and subversion

We examine which criticisms hold weight, which ones miss the point, and how The Last Jedi fits (or clashes) with George Lucas’s original six-film saga and the themes Dave Filoni and others have carried forward. This isn’t about declaring a winner in the fandom war — it’s about understanding why the movie hit so many people so hard and whether it was bold storytelling or a miscalculation.

Whether you walked out of the theater in 2017 loving it, hating it, or feeling confused, this conversation is for you.

Which criticism of The Last Jedi do you think is the weakest? Which one still bothers you the most? Let us know in the comments or on X @TatooineSons — we actually read and engage with them.

Subscribe to the podcast, leave a review if this episode resonated, and keep the conversation going. New episodes every week.

Available on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and wherever you get your podcasts.

Prefer video? Check out our YouTube channel!

No reviews yet