Good Girls cover art

Good Girls

Good Girls

By: SJ and Kay
Listen for free

About this listen

Welcome to the Good Girls podcast with SJ and Kay, where two self-described MILFs in our thirties talk sex, relationships, and books. We roast societal expectations of women’s sexuality, riff on praise and age-gap kinks, and give highly questionable sex advice. We also talk romance reads, from the massively popular to the quirky gems hiding in the smuttier corners of the internet. Laugh and cringe a little with us! New episodes every Tuesday.SJ and Kay
Episodes
  • Cave-Dwelling QBs & Comeback Kings: NFL Narratives, Fanfic Fire, and Celeb Side-Eyes
    Jan 27 2026

    Join us on the Good Girls Podcast as we gear up for Super Bowl Sunday with zero shame, starting off with a dip into NFL FanFic - KissMyTightEnd, we see you there on AAO3! We match up NFL quarterbacks with pop culture characters...ranging from Gandalf to Mulan to Gollum (we will go ahead and give away, that's Aaron Rodgers). We then pivot to peak pop culture chaos in our new "Am I the Asshole?" segment: Is Brooklyn Beckham the ultimate nepo baby for nuking the Beckham brand over a wedding dance drama? Plus, unsealed texts spotlight Taylor Swift's wildcard role in the endless Justin Baldoni-Blake Lively saga. It's football flirting, fictional fantasies, and family feuds—because who needs stats when you've got spice...the poshest spice. Tune in for laughs, shade, and sleuthing and a fanfic read-aloud that's truly, truly unforgettable.

    Show More Show Less
    39 mins
  • Toxic Celebrity Mom Group? ...We Don't Think So
    Jan 20 2026

    In this week's episode of Good Girls, we talk about the conversations sparked by Ashley Tisdale's viral essay on The Cut about craving a "mom village" only to feel sidelined by a mom celeb group - think Hilary Duff, Mandy Moore, and Megan Trainor. We get it, that'd be our #1 mom group choice, too. But, we aren't too into the idea of letting yourself feel excluded by one, single closed mom group when there are so many different ways to meet other parents. We talk on accidental exclusion, the energy limits of parenting, and how we all have that experience of our husband sticking up for us at the wrong moment. We call out a bit of pettiness (shade thrown, but kindly), and talk on skipping the toxicity and building your own community. There's a sea of awesome moms out there waiting who have that same experience of taking a Zoom call with a baby on the hip (or elsewhere).

    Show More Show Less
    39 mins
  • Heated Rivalry and Hockey Smut: Puck Yeah
    Jan 13 2026

    SJ and Kay kick off 2026 by diving headfirst into the steamy world of hockey romance, fresh off SJ's binge of HBO's Heated Rivalry - the Critics' Choice-nominated adaptation of Rachel Reid's queer M/M powerhouse. Honorary Hockey Mom Kay gives a hockey crash course (complete with a brutal quiz on shifts, sticks, and glove-dropping consent), SJ talks beautifully cast leads like Connor Sherry and Hudson Williams, and both do real-talk on why the show's rosy romance clashes with hockey's zero-out NHL reality. From heart-melting on-ice proposals to critiques of locker-room homophobia (shoutout to trailblazer Brock McGillis), the gals talk why straight women love gay sports smut, recommend must-reads like Mile High by Liz Tomforde and The Deal by Elle Kennedy, and ponder hotter adaptations for curvy heroines, throuples, and beyond-hockey vibes (hello, pickleball and rowing?). Plus, a nod to why all sports are low-key homoerotic. Grab your "I Hope Both Teams Have Fun" sweatshirt for 45 minutes of cognitively offloading in a terrible world.

    Show More Show Less
    45 mins
No reviews yet