Send us Fan Mail

What would you do if, on the day you buried your mother, you discovered a hidden bundle of records labeled with one clear instruction: Please destroy these?

In this gripping first part of Corey and Kendall’s conversation with retired journalist and author Paul O’Connor, a lifetime of hidden family history begins to unravel through DNA testing, courthouse archives, old birth records, and one relentless search for the truth.

Paul shares how a mystery surrounding his mother’s identity turned into a years-long investigation that ultimately became his new book, The Missing Child: The Life She Lost and the Life She Led, releasing May 26. Pre-orders are available now.

What begins as curiosity about his mother’s background evolves into something much deeper: an emotional exploration of shame, secrecy, adoption-era stigma, and the devastating weight family secrets can carry across generations.

Using AncestryDNA, 23andMe, historical records, and help from newly discovered cousins, Paul uncovers shocking truths about infidelity, hidden relatives, and the biological grandfather his family never knew existed. Along the way, he and Kendall discuss the emotional complexity of adoption, identity, DNA surprises, and one question that lingers throughout the episode:

Is knowing the truth always better?

In this episode:

• Paul discovers hidden family records after his mother’s death
• A DNA test reveals unexpected biological connections
• The emotional fallout of long-buried family secrets
• Adoption stigma and shame in the early 1900s
• How genealogy research helped uncover the truth
• Why Paul wrote The Missing Child
• The complicated emotional legacy of secrecy
• Kendall reflects on growing up adopted without secrecy

If you’ve ever searched for biological family, uncovered a DNA surprise, wrestled with identity, or wondered how hidden truths shape generations, this conversation will stay with you long after it ends.

Pre-order Paul O’Connor’s new book, The Missing Child: The Life She Lost and the Life She Led, ahead of its May 26 release, and subscribe to Family Twist for more stories about DNA surprises, adoption, NPE discoveries, donor conception, and the secrets families keep.

Send us Fan Mail

What happens when a sperm donor from the 1990s suddenly discovers he has children decades later?

This is one of those stories that could only happen right now.

A decision made in the early ’90s, when anonymity was expected and protected, collides with modern DNA testing, where secrets don’t stay buried.

In Part 1 of this conversation around the documentary Dad Genes, we sit down with Aaron and Jess to unpack how their lives became connected in a way neither of them could have predicted.

Aaron donated sperm in 1994, thinking it was a closed chapter. Jess built her family years later, carefully choosing a donor based on what felt right at the time.

Neither of them expected that decades later, a simple DNA test would connect them, and open the door to a network of biological children, siblings, and relationships that were never supposed to exist.

This episode focuses on the moment everything changes. The discovery. The realization. The first steps into something completely unknown.

If you’ve taken a DNA test, are thinking about it, or are navigating a family discovery of your own, this episode will hit home.

Because this isn’t just about donor conception.

It’s about how technology is reshaping identity, how past decisions don’t stay in the past, and how people are left to figure it out in real time without a roadmap.

Stories like this are becoming more common, and the questions they raise don’t have easy answers.

What You’ll Take Away

• A clear look at how donor conception worked before DNA testing changed everything
• Insight into how families made decisions without knowing what the future would bring
• A grounded, human perspective on what it feels like when identity and biology suddenly collide

Listen now to hear how one decision in 1994 turned into a life-changing discovery decades later.

Send us Fan Mail

What happens when a sperm donor from the 1990s suddenly discovers he has children decades later?

This is one of those stories that could only happen right now.

A decision made in the early ’90s, when anonymity was expected and protected, collides with modern DNA testing, where secrets don’t stay buried.

In Part 1 of this conversation around the documentary Dad Genes, we sit down with Aaron and Jess to unpack how their lives became connected in a way neither of them could have predicted.

Aaron donated sperm in 1994, thinking it was a closed chapter. Jess built her family years later, carefully choosing a donor based on what felt right at the time.

Neither of them expected that decades later, a simple DNA test would connect them, and open the door to a network of biological children, siblings, and relationships that were never supposed to exist.

This episode focuses on the moment everything changes. The discovery. The realization. The first steps into something completely unknown.

Why This Episode Matters

If you’ve taken a DNA test, are thinking about it, or are navigating a family discovery of your own, this episode will hit home.

Because this isn’t just about donor conception.

It’s about how technology is reshaping identity, how past decisions don’t stay in the past, and how people are left to figure it out in real time without a roadmap.

Stories like this are becoming more common, and the questions they raise don’t have easy answers.

What You’ll Take Away

A clear look at how donor conception worked before DNA testing changed everything

Insight into how families made decisions without knowing what the future would bring

A grounded, human perspective on what it feels like when identity and biology suddenly collide.

Listen now to hear how one decision in 1994 turned into a life-changing discovery decades later.