Young and Damned and Fair

Short Lived Queen Consort

Always interested in the complex and colourful history of King Henry VIII's
court, I was drawn to this biography of Henry's fifth wife, Catherine Howard
as it was a work focusing on one of the perhaps less well known wives. So
much has been written about Anne Boleyn, Henry's most notorious wife that it
was a refreshing change to find a book like this

This is my first experience of Gareth Russell as an author and on the whole
it is a very good impression I am left with after reading this work. Russell
has skilfully and in often painstaking detail described the events, people
and places surrounding Catherine Howard. It is a rich and often complex
history that tells of the rise and fall of one of the lesser understood
wives. For anyone interested in the reign of Henry VIII, this work is an
enthralling and informative read.

This book is also my first experience of Jenny Funnell as narrator and I am
pleased to say that she is both highly competent in her reading as well as
having the perfect voice to render such a story. I noticed a couple of minor
editing errors in the book. One was a tiny glitch and I am not even certain
if this was a stutter in the streaming method of listening I use. The other
was where a sentence was begun, then started again. Neither of these I
hasten to add detracted from the overall quality of this book.

The key reason I have given this book just 4 stars overall is that this book
is really much broader a story than the title might suggest. Perhaps it has
been expanded because there is simply not enough historical material to
warrant an entire biography of its own for this short lived queen consort.
The author did preface this biography by stating that he wanted to include
the closest people to Catherine in order to understand the immediate world
in which she lived but I felt that the scope of this went far beyond her
inner circle at times which can often leave one somewhat confused when a
long and sprawling group of people are discussed in detail. Many of which
have no direct relationship or bearing on Catherine herself. Having said
that, the added scope does paint a more general history of the period but it
tends to feel as if Catherine and her place in it was a relatively small
part of the telling of her story as a whole.

This work is both comprehensive and well researched and credit must go to
the author for his diligent work not only in the gathering of available
evidence but also not to interpret inconclusive evidence in any definitive
view. best guesses or most likely scenarios are postulated but it is made
clear that these are just that and not hard conclusions which is the mark of
a good historian / biographer I feel.

This book was a fascinating insight into Tudor England at the time of Henry
VIII's reign and will provide the reader with a fuller picture of the brief
life of Catherine Howard. I look forward to more from this author in the
future.

20 of 22 people found this review helpful

Engaging and well reasoned

Would highly recommend- well structured and personally I feel the female narration has a really positive impact.

3 of 3 people found this review helpful

Young and Damned and Fair

Did Jenny Funnell do a good job differentiating each of the characters? How?

She does an okay job, although she loses her way sometimes with the punctuation and pronunciation, but not really enough to be off-putting.

Any additional comments?

I enjoyed this book very much, but at the end of the day, we hardly know anything about Catherine Howard (nice to have a Tudor we don't know everything about!) and so if you're reading/listening to this to learn more about Catherine, then I think you'd be disappointed. But what is interesting are the politics around her and the machinations of the families, which is always interesting, and vaguely horrific when you realise how people were moved around like pawns on a chess board to help their families improve their political clout. Henry VIII remains an odious beast (and odorous by this point of course) with vaguely perverted tastes when it comes to a fresh young thing like Catherine, and I still believe that his reaction to her (possible) adultery and (possible) pre-contract was that of an old man who can't believe that anybody could ever prefer anybody over him. He, who was the young god of the courts, in effect usurped by other, younger men in positions of much less power. Interesting for the questions it brings up more than for its supposed subject, perhaps.

5 of 6 people found this review helpful

Very disappointed

I found this book very disappointing and frustrating. So many other characters that I didn't think warranted chapter after chapter. It was only the last four chapters that really brought Catherine to the fore.

jenny funnell's performance needed a director

Would you try another book written by Gareth Russell or narrated by Jenny Funnell?

Might do and NO

What will your next listen be?

Not sure

Would you be willing to try another one of Jenny Funnell’s performances?

No, she irritates.

What character would you cut from Young and Damned and Fair?

Didn't get far enough into the story to say

Any additional comments?

Jenny Funnell has a good voice but she needs a director to help her with this.

Gripping story and meticulous research

I wasn't sure about whether to buy this book as I sometimes feel too much focus is placed on Tudor history but I'm so pleased I did. I knew the basic story of Catherine Howard but this book really brought it to life and explained a lot about court life and how she ended up being beheaded. I really liked the author's assessment of the various myths and theories which seemed very fair and where there isn't enough evidence to reach a view, he says so.

I don't agree with previous reviewers who said that there is too much information about other people in and around Henry VIII's court as I think it's crucial to see the whole picture to understand how that society worked.

Scholarly but enthralling

Intelligent thoughtful and thorough. A fascinating look at a less well known player in the Tudor saga. Highly recommended

A little disappointing

There is a great deal of fact in this story which needs deliberation and definition. The narrator has a pleasant voice, but insufficient range of intonation, and tends to join paragraphs and sections as if they were sentences - so that different subjects sound like they are the same one. Although I suspect this could be largely down to the editing and a couple of edits can in fact be heard. So overall this spoiled a very interesting piece of work, which I think I might now read hard copy.

Great

Not exactly what I expected but still very enjoyable. Would happily recommend to anyone. R

A brilliant book

Would you listen to Young and Damned and Fair again? Why?

Yes, it is so well written and informative

What did you like best about this story?

The thorough research gave a sense of being there

Which character – as performed by Jenny Funnell – was your favourite?

no favourite

Did you have an emotional reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

It was dislurbing and thought provoking to get such a realistic understanding of what it was to be alive then