Interesting book

This took a little while to get into, but I really enjoyed it. Not my usual choice, but glad I stuck with it. Dilemmas facing modern parents interspersed with the history of the rebuilding of Coventry Cathedral, and hippy America in the '60's.
The narrator had a lovely soothing voice, and I've now bought the book in hard copy too, to share around.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Exquisite Prose

The Tidal Zone did not disappoint. Essentially the story is about a family’s behaviour after the near-fatal collapse of the elder daughter. The characters, in particular the resentful house husband and his workaholic wife were entirely believable. How the author got into the heads of a 15 year old and ten year old is a mystery to me! The prose was exquisite, not a word wasted.
As with the Sarah Moss books I have read, there is a parallel historical substory, in this case the rebuilding of Coventry Cathedral. This device throws the main story into sharp relief.
Toby Longworth’s narration was flawless.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Not one word misplaced or wasted.

I haven't read anything by Sarah Moss before - but I will certainly be seeking out her other novels now that I have read this one. This book is beautifully written, the story never loses pace or interest, and we are asked to consider the journey the human body makes from the moment of conception to that of death - or in this case, near death.
This is the story of a fairly ordinary family, Dad stays home and looks after 15 year old Miriam and her younger sister Rose while their mum works as a GP. Their daily life is described in minute but never boring detail, and we learn about the relationships that exist between these four likeable people. They are very normal and happy, intelligent and loving. Then one day Miriam collapses at school due to respiratory and then cardiac arrest needing CPR. None of the doctors are able to say why this incident has happened or whether it might recur and then there's the possibility that Rose might be affected too.
The story is compelling, we really feel for this family as the rug is pulled out from under their happy life and it seems as though they will never feel safe again. There is no conventional happy ending, rather the characters learn to live with their new situation as the unusual and frightening starts to become normal for them.
I can't recommend this book highly enough.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

8 people found this helpful

Thought provoking

Love Sarah Moss- and this was a fabulous and thought provoking read/listen. Well narrated - and as a stay at home Mum- I thought Sarah captured lots of my previous angst and niggles beautifully- whilst making it interesting by it being a stay at home Dad that was having those thoughts and anxieties. Recommended.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Beautiful but….

This is a beautifully written book but whilst being very insightful, is also very depressing. I think it is just a bit different from my typical choice of books which maybe why I really wanted to finish it….I didn’t really engage with the characters and about half way through, wanted it all to end.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Beautiful

I loved this. Beautifully narrated. Slice of life but tackling big themes of love and death, fear and how to live in spite of it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

What happens to trauma?

Filled with the cadences of the sea's movement, and the traumas of our shifting lives, this book spoke to the significance of the mundane and everyday sufferings which we endure and inherit. I loved it. As soon as it was over, I wanted to begin again and rehear the narrative's phrases and patterns.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

The narrator ruined it

Droning on in a totally flat voice devoid of emotion. And he's talking about his daughter's cardiac arrest!!! Didn't finish it. I got to the point where I just couldn't stand his voice for one more minute!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

In a league of its own for excellence!

The Tidal Zone is quite a difficult title to write about because no other novelist at present is writing in this unique way to produce such a (almost literally) stunning impact on the listener. It richly deserves its 5+ stars.

Sarah Moss the author is an academic and The Tidal Zone is a highly sophisticated and multi-layered portrait of both a family and British culture, packed tightly with challenging and stimulating ideas and analysis. But don't be put off if this sounds a bit heavy - it is also utterly and beguilingly ordinary, presenting with stunning reality a family with all the stresses and strains of just about every family we know.

Adam looks after 15 year-old Mimi and 8 year-old Rose at home, putting his own academic work on hold as his GP wife Emma earns the money, returning home late each day drained by working for a struggling NHS, too exhausted to eat. All's well if stressful in a different way for Adam juggling household chores, children's needs, a preoccupied wife and his own attempts to keep up some vestige of academic research - until the call from school that Mimi has stopped breathing and has been rushed to hospital where she stays for the next fortnight before being returned home with the life-saving Epipen she must always carry with her in case the same happens again.

The power of the writing is in the portrayal of the effect of this shattering experience on each member of the family, the strain on the tenuous 'cobweb' which was holding Adam and Emma together even before the shock, and the painful lessons Adam has to learn in allowing Mimi to live again without strangling her with his overwhelming anxiety. All this is described against the everyday backdrop of Adam emptying the dishwasher, buying Rose's new school shoes, making the packed lunches and doing the thousand other domestic tasks as his world seems to have crumbled around him.

It's also about a great deal more than this - the NHS comes in for a great deal of beautifully made swingeing swipes - the night nurses in Mimi's High Dependency unit are paid less per hour than was paid to Father Christmas's elves in a superstore is just one example. University education with sultry students and Faculty meetings reduced to media speak is another target. These themes which are super-articulate - and when they come from Mimi (who reads The New Internationalist) arguing against doing her homework because it's 'a technique for social control' - they can all get too much, too clever.

But the other themes are wonderful and deftly interwoven, such as Adam's work on the rebuilding of Canterbury Cathedral which contributes to the novel's final resolution where life is rebuilt and does go on. And there's the tidal imagery and the real coastal tides, in which Adam's mother drowned when he was young, and where Mimi and Rose look for sea anemones and starfish at the end; tides that ebb and flow like Mimi's breathing in and out which her parents must now always reassure themselves is happening.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

13 people found this helpful

Depressing, repetitive, dull and drove me mad!!

Beautifully read BUT where to start with Adam the main protagonist - stay at home dad through his own choice yet moans and moans. Then he also moans about the size of his house (small), position (estate), cost of everything yet simultaneously despises those where both parents work, earn money, do things differently, live in huge houses, have cats, don’t have cats, go on expensive holidays and so on and so forth. Spent my time listening to this and composing pithy, spiteful reviews but all I can really say is “you made your bed, lie on it”!!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful