Read with conviction

I found George read this with conviction his passion for this work is well noticed I have the naxo copy on another tablet but for strong socialist comment and the fire of this novel I can go with George all the way I hope he does another work say love on the dole by Walter Greenwood

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

The production of this book is terrible.

A great story which many in today's society should listen to. Completely let down by Galloway's reading and a disastrous production.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

narrator chapter introduction

why did the narrator feel the need to bark out the name of the book his name and the chapter number.?
it was very off-putting to be shouted at. also why did he need to reminders at the beginning of a new chapter of his name as the narrator.
surely you just need to say at the beginning of the book the title and the narrators name.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A triumph of political and social 'noire'.

What a superb rendering of the 'state of man' let alone the state of the nation or the world.
Truly a masterpiece of ingenuity and a brilliant and lucid depiction of the struggles and (self inflicted) ignorance of the working man.
I think this book should be on the reading list of every 1st year university student.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Highly recommended reading

Despite a few recording errors which are to be expected from the age it is a fantastic read. Humerous, emotional and entertaining, as well as thought provoking and educational. Even more than a century on there are innumerable parrallels that can still be drawn, especially in our current political climate.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Topical in today's economic disarray

A relevant commentary on today's societal issues. quite sad that there are so many likenesses to today's issues, evidently we have regressed in many areas.
The narration is repetitive in parts where it hasn't been edited properly, but a decent listen.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Galloway spoils an otherwise great book.

If you've found this book, out is likely you have a good idea about its subject. The book delivers an easily relatable story of hardship and prosperity, based in Victorian times but it's equally applicable today, to discuss socialism. Reading this in October 2019, even at the end of the first chapter, I found many issues raised that I see and have seen happening over the last 9 years in startling severity.

I really can't get on with George Galloway's narration though - and it's nothing to do with his event! He delivers this without punctuation, blending one sentence into the next without even a breath. There's no clarity as to when someone starts or ends talking, or when he's reading narration, and by chapter 5 I can't continue due to this, and the constant mistakes, which in places make what he's saying incomprehensible. This version is going back for a refund, but I'm going to get the other unabridged version which is read by someone else completely. By the way, don't even think of an abridged version of this book. I believe you'll miss far too much to take in all that Tressell had to say.

There is one good thing about Galloway (in this recording at least, anything else I'll leave for your own judgement) which is his preface. He gives a nice bit of background to the boom and the author, and explains how it shaped his political ideas from an early age.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A prescient reminder of what was and may be again

A well delivered telling of the classic story. Galloway honest in his interpretation. A good version not without a couple of recording blips but believable and delivered with honesty and a passion obviously derived from a love of the subject matter.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Great story but terrible editing and a bad narrator

The story is wonderful and pulls you in despite the terrible narration and rubbish editing (what appears to have been corrections are left in alongside the original narration) .

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

The Rag Trou Planf

Fantastic even better if I could listen to the story and not get asked for a review after five minuets,don't think I will be a regular customer,it's back to Netflix for me bi...

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!