Listen free for 30 days
-
The Late Scholar
- Narrated by: Gordon Griffin
- Series: Lord Peter Wimsey/Harriet Vane, Book 4
- Length: 9 hrs and 49 mins
- Unabridged Audiobook
- Categories: Mystery, Thriller & Suspense, Mystery
Add to basket failed.
Add to wishlist failed.
Remove from wishlist failed.
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed
Listen with a free trial
Buy Now for £20.89
No valid payment method on file.
We are sorry. We are not allowed to sell this product with the selected payment method
Listeners also enjoyed...
-
The Wyndham Case
- Imogen Quy, Book 1
- By: Jill Paton Walsh
- Narrated by: Suzannah Hampton
- Length: 6 hrs and 54 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
The locked library of St Agatha's College, Cambridge, houses an unrivalled and, according to certain scholars, deeply uninteresting collection of 17th-century volumes. It also contains one dead student. Tragic and accidental, of course, even if malicious gossip hints that Philip Skellow had been engaged in stealing books rather than acquiring knowledge when he'd slipped, banged his head, and bled to death overnight.
-
-
long awaited
- By wellington on 30-08-19
-
A Series of Murders
- By: Simon Brett
- Narrated by: Simon Brett
- Length: 5 hrs and 10 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Charles Paris is in clover. He has been contracted for three whole months to play brainless bobby Sergeant Clump, foil to the charismatic amateur sleuth, Stanislas Braid, in a TV series of that name. Recourse to the whiskey bottle is still needed, however, to get him through a day’s filming - one made all the more arduous by the pompous posturings of the show’s star, and the constant outraged interruptions of the ancient author whose detective novels are being adapted. Indeed, there is plenty of friction about.
-
-
"A confusion of constables."
- By Norma Miles on 02-01-22
-
The China Governess
- By: Margery Allingham
- Narrated by: David Thorpe
- Length: 10 hrs and 6 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Timothy Kinnit needs Albert Campion's help. He is rich, handsome and successful but his past is a mystery to him and he needs Campion to find out how it connects him to the notorious Turk Street Mile slum. In addition, his own illustrious adopted family has a sinister secret of his own - involving a murderous nineteenth-century governess - that must also be brought to life by Campion's investigations. An Albert Campion mystery.
-
-
fantastic campion
- By Miss Julie E. Ellis on 31-05-17
-
Lord Peter Wimsey: BBC Radio Drama Collection Volume 1
- Three classic full-cast dramatisations
- By: Dorothy L. Sayers
- Narrated by: Ian Carmichael, Peter Jones
- Length: 8 hrs and 55 mins
- Original Recording
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Whose Body? first introduced Lord Peter to the world and begins with a corpse in the bath of a London flat. Clouds of Witness finds Wimsey investigating murder close to home, and in Unnatural Death he investigates the suspicious demise of an elderly woman. First broadcast on BBC radio in the 1970s and presented here in their entirety, these full-cast adaptations are admired by fans of the genre worldwide.
-
-
I got totally immersed!
- By Caroline Armstrong on 04-12-17
-
Eternity Ring
- By: Patricia Wentworth
- Narrated by: Diana Bishop
- Length: 8 hrs and 14 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Mary Stokes was walking through Dead Man's Copse one evening when she saw, in the beam of a torch, the corpse of a young woman dressed in a black coat, black gloves, no hat and an eternity ring set with diamonds in her ear. But when she and Detective Sergeant Frank Abbott went back to the wood the body had vanished.
-
-
First Patricia wentworth and I loved it
- By Jasemin on 07-08-19
-
Heirs and Assigns
- By: Marjorie Eccles
- Narrated by: Gordon Griffin
- Length: 8 hrs and 49 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
November 1928. Family and friends have gathered at the Shropshire country home of Penrose Llewellyn to celebrate the retired wealthy businessman's 60th birthday. But the morning after what should have been a convivial supper party, their host is found dead in his bed - and the circumstances look decidedly suspicious.
-
The Wyndham Case
- Imogen Quy, Book 1
- By: Jill Paton Walsh
- Narrated by: Suzannah Hampton
- Length: 6 hrs and 54 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
The locked library of St Agatha's College, Cambridge, houses an unrivalled and, according to certain scholars, deeply uninteresting collection of 17th-century volumes. It also contains one dead student. Tragic and accidental, of course, even if malicious gossip hints that Philip Skellow had been engaged in stealing books rather than acquiring knowledge when he'd slipped, banged his head, and bled to death overnight.
-
-
long awaited
- By wellington on 30-08-19
-
A Series of Murders
- By: Simon Brett
- Narrated by: Simon Brett
- Length: 5 hrs and 10 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Charles Paris is in clover. He has been contracted for three whole months to play brainless bobby Sergeant Clump, foil to the charismatic amateur sleuth, Stanislas Braid, in a TV series of that name. Recourse to the whiskey bottle is still needed, however, to get him through a day’s filming - one made all the more arduous by the pompous posturings of the show’s star, and the constant outraged interruptions of the ancient author whose detective novels are being adapted. Indeed, there is plenty of friction about.
-
-
"A confusion of constables."
- By Norma Miles on 02-01-22
-
The China Governess
- By: Margery Allingham
- Narrated by: David Thorpe
- Length: 10 hrs and 6 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Timothy Kinnit needs Albert Campion's help. He is rich, handsome and successful but his past is a mystery to him and he needs Campion to find out how it connects him to the notorious Turk Street Mile slum. In addition, his own illustrious adopted family has a sinister secret of his own - involving a murderous nineteenth-century governess - that must also be brought to life by Campion's investigations. An Albert Campion mystery.
-
-
fantastic campion
- By Miss Julie E. Ellis on 31-05-17
-
Lord Peter Wimsey: BBC Radio Drama Collection Volume 1
- Three classic full-cast dramatisations
- By: Dorothy L. Sayers
- Narrated by: Ian Carmichael, Peter Jones
- Length: 8 hrs and 55 mins
- Original Recording
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Whose Body? first introduced Lord Peter to the world and begins with a corpse in the bath of a London flat. Clouds of Witness finds Wimsey investigating murder close to home, and in Unnatural Death he investigates the suspicious demise of an elderly woman. First broadcast on BBC radio in the 1970s and presented here in their entirety, these full-cast adaptations are admired by fans of the genre worldwide.
-
-
I got totally immersed!
- By Caroline Armstrong on 04-12-17
-
Eternity Ring
- By: Patricia Wentworth
- Narrated by: Diana Bishop
- Length: 8 hrs and 14 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Mary Stokes was walking through Dead Man's Copse one evening when she saw, in the beam of a torch, the corpse of a young woman dressed in a black coat, black gloves, no hat and an eternity ring set with diamonds in her ear. But when she and Detective Sergeant Frank Abbott went back to the wood the body had vanished.
-
-
First Patricia wentworth and I loved it
- By Jasemin on 07-08-19
-
Heirs and Assigns
- By: Marjorie Eccles
- Narrated by: Gordon Griffin
- Length: 8 hrs and 49 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
November 1928. Family and friends have gathered at the Shropshire country home of Penrose Llewellyn to celebrate the retired wealthy businessman's 60th birthday. But the morning after what should have been a convivial supper party, their host is found dead in his bed - and the circumstances look decidedly suspicious.
-
The Affair of the Thirty Nine-Cufflinks
- By: James Anderson
- Narrated by: Cornelius Garrett
- Length: 9 hrs and 33 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Understandably, Lord Burford had some misgivings about hosting another house party at Alderley, his beautiful country mansion. After all, the previous two could at best be described as disastrous, since a couple of their guests were bumped off during their stay on each occasion. But with family members travelling down for the funeral of an elderly relative, the Earl really had no choice but to offer them accommodation.
-
-
If you're a fan of Ngaio Marsh's Alleyne, you'll LOVE this!
- By Carôle on 07-01-16
-
Tied Up in Tinsel
- By: Ngaio Marsh
- Narrated by: James Saxon
- Length: 7 hrs and 20 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Christmastime in an isolated country house and, following a flaming row in the kitchen, there’s murder inside. When a much disliked visiting servant disappears without trace after playing Santa Claus, foul play is at once suspected - and foul play it proves to be. Only suspicion falls not on the staff but on the guests, all so unimpeachably respectable that the very thought of murder in connection with any of them seems almost heresy.
-
-
Marsh is wonderful.
- By Tomboy on 30-12-20
-
The White Cottage Mystery
- By: Margery Allingham
- Narrated by: William Gaminara
- Length: 4 hrs and 14 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Seven people might have murdered Eric Crowther, the mysterious recluse who lived in the gaunt house whose shadow fell across the White Cottage. Seven people had good cause. It was not lack of evidence that sent Detective Chief Inspector Challenor and his son Jerry half across Europe to unravel a chaos of clues. The White Cottage Mystery was Margery Allingham's first detective story, published initially as a newspaper serial.
-
-
Odd, but good.
- By mrsc on 03-02-20
-
Black Plumes
- By: Margery Allingham
- Narrated by: Francis Matthews
- Length: 7 hrs and 37 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Slashed paintings and a mysterious death, an accused fiancé and the reappearance of a long-dead husband - Black Plumes is another classic crime drama from Margery Allingham. 'Margery Allingham stands out like a shining light.' - Agatha Christie.
-
-
Margery Allingham's best!
- By R on 16-09-16
-
The Affair of the Bloodstained Egg Cosy
- By: James Anderson
- Narrated by: Cornelius Garrett
- Length: 8 hrs and 13 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Welcome to Alderley, a magnificent mansion in the heart of the West Country where a grand house party is taking place. The preparations have been made, the guests have been invited, and the staff are on hand. What could possibly go wrong? Let the entertainment begin. The theft of the diamond necklace and the antique pistols might all be explained, but the body in the lake - that really was a puzzle. 'Don't expect me to solve anything,' Inspector Wilkens announced modestly when he arrived to sort out the unpleasantness.
-
-
What a treat!!
- By Hepwood Flutey on 13-02-16
-
Death in a White Tie
- By: Ngaio Marsh
- Narrated by: Benedict Cumberbatch
- Length: 3 hrs and 17 mins
- Abridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
The season had begun. Débutantes and chaperones were planning their luncheons, teas, dinners, balls. And the blackmailer was planning his strategies, stalking his next victim. But Chief Detective Inspector Roderick Alleyn knew that something was up. He had already planted his friend Lord Robert Gospell at the scene. But someone else got there first...
-
-
Great voice acting
- By R. Rehal on 07-04-13
-
The Adventures of Brother Cadfael
- A Collection of Chronicles
- By: Ellis Peters
- Narrated by: Sir Derek Jacobi
- Length: 17 hrs and 48 mins
- Abridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
This collection of recordings about Brother Cadfael—a Benedictine monk and amateur sleuth in the 12th century—are performed here by the ideal actor. Sir Derek Jacobi, who portrayed Cadfael in several television adaptations, captivates listeners with his renderings of Monk's Hood, Saint Peter's Fair, The Heretic's Apprentice, The Potter's Field, The Summer of the Danes, and Brother Cadfael's Penance.
-
-
Very entertaining
- By Gayle Harris on 20-05-22
-
The Affair of the Mutilated Mink
- By: James Anderson
- Narrated by: Cornelius Garrett
- Length: 9 hrs and 39 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
The Earl of Burford can't believe his luck. Rex Ransom, his favourite star from the 'talkies', and his hot-shot producer, Haggermeir, want to film their next feature at Alderley, the family's seventeenth-century country estate. Somewhat less enthusiastic is the Countess, who finds herself hosting an impromptu house party for the incoming Hollywood crowd.
-
-
Thoroughly enjoyable
- By S. J. MacDonald on 02-12-15
-
Magpie Murders
- Magpie Murders, Book 1
- By: Anthony Horowitz
- Narrated by: Allan Corduner, Samantha Bond
- Length: 15 hrs and 48 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
When editor Susan Ryeland is given the tattered manuscript of Alan Conway's latest novel, she has little idea it will change her life. She's worked with the revered crime writer for years, and his detective, Atticus Pund, is renowned for solving crimes in the sleepy English villages of the 1950s. As Susan knows only too well, vintage crime sells handsomely. It's just a shame that it means dealing with an author like Alan Conway.... But Conway's latest tale of murder at Pye Hall is not quite what it seems.
-
-
Who? How? Where & Why?
- By Mrs Q on 10-10-16
-
Jumping Jenny
- By: Anthony Berkeley
- Narrated by: Seán Barrett
- Length: 6 hrs and 51 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
At a costume party with the dubious theme of 'famous murderers and their victims', the know-it-all amateur criminologist Roger Sheringham is settled in for an evening of beer, small talk and analysing his companions. One guest in particular has caught his attention for her theatrics, and his theory that she might have several enemies among the partygoers proves true when she is found hanging from the 'decorative' gallows on the roof terrace. Noticing a key detail which could implicate a friend in the crime, Sheringham decides to meddle with the scene.
-
-
Well written, and equally well read.
- By Susan Drake on 11-04-22
-
Pietr the Latvian
- Inspector Maigret, Book 1
- By: Georges Simenon, David Bellos - translator
- Narrated by: Gareth Armstrong
- Length: 3 hrs and 57 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
The first audiobook which appeared in Georges Simenon's famous Maigret series, in a gripping new translation by David Bellos.Inevitably Maigret was a hostile presence in the Majestic. He constituted a kind of foreign body that the hotel's atmosphere could not assimilate. Not that he looked like a cartoon policeman. He didn't have a moustache and he didn't wear heavy boots. His clothes were well cut and made of fairly light worsted. He shaved every day and looked after his hands. But his frame was proletarian. He was a big, bony man.
-
-
Great start to a series
- By Anfisa on 11-02-17
-
Angels and Demons
- By: Dan Brown
- Narrated by: Richard Poe
- Length: 18 hrs and 28 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
World-renowned Harvard symbologist Robert Langdon is summoned to a Swiss research facility to analyze a cryptic symbol seared into the chest of a murdered physicist. What he discovers is unimaginable: a deadly vendetta against the Catholic Church by a centuries-old underground organization, the Illuminati. Desperate to save the Vatican from a powerful time bomb, Langdon joins forces in Rome with the beautiful and mysterious scientist Vittoria Vetra.
-
-
Better than the Da Vinci Code!
- By PinkMilk on 02-03-07
Summary
When the fellows at an Oxford college appeal to Peter Wimsey to resolve a dispute, he and Harriet are happy to oblige. The dispute between the two passionate parties is evenly balanced, that is, until several of the fellows unexpectedly die. And the causes of death bear an uncanny resemblance to the murder methods in Peter's past cases - methods that Harriet has used in her novels.…
Critic reviews
More from the same
What listeners say about The Late Scholar
Average customer ratingsReviews - Please select the tabs below to change the source of reviews.
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Claire
- 15-05-14
Not as good as a DL Sayers but better than nothing
Would you listen to The Late Scholar again? Why?
Yes, because I'm addicted to DL Sayers, Lord Peter Wimsey & Harriet Vane.
What was one of the most memorable moments of The Late Scholar?
There was no one moment that stands out.
What did you like about the performance? What did you dislike?
Sadly Edward Petherbridge has not lent his voice to this reading which is a great shame. While Gordon Griffin does a competent job, his quavering voice and mis-pronunciation of "Domina" amongst other things grated and in no way conjured the image of Peter Wimsey. Ian Carmichael and Edward Petherbridge have stamped my auditory memory so anyone else reading this book is doomed to failure.
Did you have an emotional reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?
The Late Scholar met my double passion for the Wimseys and Oxford, so on that score alone it has to be a winner.
Any additional comments?
Jill Paton Walsh is no Dorothy L Sayers, there is an element of dumbing down of the language and sentiment, perhaps she is trying too hard? Nonetheless, it's a competent work, not faultless but it feeds the insatiable desire to follow the central relationship of Harriet Vane and Lord Peter Wimsey. Quite what Miss Sayers would have made of this volume remains to be seen. Having said that, I still give it 7/10 as it is much better than a lot of historical whodunits on the market.
17 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Liz
- 04-06-14
Underwhelming
On the narrator, I was momentarily devasted when I realised that Edward Petherbridge would not be reading this book to me. (Or even Ian Charmichael, as I've also learnt to associate him with Lord Peter through years of audiobooks, but Petherbridge brings the ennui of a very clever man's sarcasm and wit and false whimsy to everything.)
I grew to tolerate him. There's nothing particularly bad about his narration, except for Not Being Petherbridge. His voices are consistent, I especially liked Bunter, but there isn't any variation I noticed among the secondary characters, victims and villains, and in a cast of dozens, I might have used the extra help keeping them straight in my head. His tone for the narrator was a little stilted, but I think that might have been the writing style rather than any narrative choice on his part.
With the story as a whole, I don't think this was Paton Walsh's best take on Lord Peter. It relied on the original Sayers books too much (I know, a bit hypocritical, as I'm listening to a continuation on Sayers universe; obviously I'm desperately searching for more of what I love). What I mean is that some aspects of the plot were deliberately echoing things from early Lord Peter books, which became a bit frustrating, especially as it equated Harriet Vane with Dorothy L. Sayers (which Sayers said she disliked) in a way which was occasionally entertainly meta, but mostly annoying. It even occasionally tainted my enjoyment of the original book (I love The Nine Tailors, don't poop on it with logic, Walsh, I don't need to hear that).
I also think the exposition relied on Harriet as Peter's intellectual foil far too often. Harriet would say 'but, we don't know that, Peter', and Peter would explain all the things she missed, Sherlock to her Watson. I know that Bunter had occasionally been used in this way in the original books, but in this book Bunter was also a Sherlock (to Peter and Harriet's Watson), and Harriet was reduced to an intellectual sidekick, even when surrounded by Oxford dons and going off to research her academic work on slow days.
As a snap-shot of the 50s as the Wimseys would have known it, it was a strong book. I loved the idea of thinking about the politics of council housing, with estates being established on appropriated land, sitting next to the state of the modern housing crisis. There wasn't a strong sense of rationing (unlike in A Presumption of Death), but the continuation of the decline of the aristocracy, the birth of opportunities for boys (and characters) that didn't go to Eton, and ended up at Oxford, or miss the Oxbridge train altogether. Bunter's eldest wants to be an economist, and go to London School of Economics, and there's discussion of the limitations and isolation of Oxbridge, all of which I liked when reading with an eye on contemporary politics about the same. (However, since we have the benefit of prophetic knowledge by BEING ALIVE NOW, some of Peter and Harriet's musing seemed extremely optimistic. We have hardly moved away from a society where old Etonians run the place.)
The mystery is a little befuddled, and for the most part I didn't learn to care for any of the victims (except a tangentially-related suicide). I'm still not sure on one of the motivations, actually, I think I may have missed a nuance somewhere. In contrast to Gaudy Night, which is such a delight for its restraint in providing unnecessary bodies, this is filled with unnecessary deaths which add to a pattern, but don't seem to have much significance in themselves. The victims are definitely the equivalent of Prostitute #2 at the start of a CSI episode, rather than interesting academics whose names I can remember. Most of the secondary characters blurred into each other, (and were sometimes absurdly coincidental, inexplicably having all the information Harriet or Peter needed) and I only liked a bare few of them. (And, since it was a well-populated Oxford college, there were too many to keep track of, even if I could rely on Sayers for a few like Eilund Price and Marjorie Phelps etc.)
If you're struggling, I felt all the emotional impact from victims (both killed and alive) came in the last hour (15%) of the novel. It wasn't the denouement, necessarily, that brought the impact, but the emotional revelations of a character who is the survivor left after (some of) the deaths. That is probably worth waiting for, if the mystery is sliding by you.
It's a nice listen if you like getting your fix of Lord Peter as an aging man, with mostly-grown children. As a mystery, I don't think it succeeds really, but I'm not a crime fiction afficinado so YMMV. If you haven't listened/read any others of Paton Walsh, I'd recommend The Attenbury Emeralds with a thousand praises, and then meander over to A Presumption of Death, and then the others if they catch your fancy.
19 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Robert Killington
- 22-01-17
Good story, poor narration
I liked the story. Jill Paton Walsh has done a good job of telling the story. I liked catching up with the characters. On the other hand I found the narrator made Bunter and Wimsey sound rather older - even older possibly than the Dowager Duchess!
6 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Richard Irwin
- 07-07-14
Nearly as good as Dorothy
Where does The Late Scholar rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?
I enjoyed listening and will no doubt listen to other Jill Paton Walsh.
What other book might you compare The Late Scholar to, and why?
Deliberately reminiscent of Gaudy Night.
Have you listened to any of Gordon Griffin’s other performances? How does this one compare?
Shame about the voice used for Charles, Wimsey's police inspector brother-in-law. Far too old.
Any additional comments?
The big let down was the relationship with the police. With a suspected serial killer on the loose, it is hard to imagine Wimsey being given the freedom he has. The police would have been all over the place.
5 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Valerie
- 18-11-14
Didn't disappoint
I was a bit wary that this would be major let down by both the author (not DL Sayers) and the narrator (not Ian Carmichael) but I was very pleasantly surprised. Great plot, major characters well written and true to their creator. Well done to Ms Walsh, she pulled it off,
4 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- NICOLA
- 15-09-18
a sad tale
This is a bad story if it's trying to follow Dorothy Sayers' Lord Peter style
The narrator was awful and if I hadn't been a Sayers fan I would have given up.
Sorry but it just didn't work.
3 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Mrs
- 16-01-17
Good
I've enjoyed listening to all Paton-Walsh's Wimsey books, she's followed the originals well and provided some excellent additional storylines. The only disappointment for me was the narrator this time, not a patch on Edward Petherbridge or the incomparable Ian Carmichael
3 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Katharine
- 07-08-14
Good enough but not Dorothy L Sayers
I enjoyed revisiting Peter Wimsey and Harriet Vane later on in life but the mystery plot was over-complicated and ultimately unsatisfying. The concept of using DLS's plots as Harriet's and then basing murders on them got tiring rather quickly. There was no sense of urgency in the detection which, with academics dropping like flies, there really should have been. What I did enjoy was the small details of Peter and Harriet's lives like the education of their children and the ageing of the Dowager Duchess.
The reading was better with some voices than others. The rendition of Peter and Harriet was OK but it was lucky there wasn't too much of Charles Parker as that sounded completely wrong to me.
3 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Seagull
- 19-11-14
Enjoyable, but not the best
I've enjoyed Jill Paton Walsh's previous recreations of the Wimsey detective stories and although this is a welcome addition, I must admit I don't think it's her best. SPOILER: The device of having a murderer using methods of murder inspired by Harriet's books (who, rather unbelievably, has apparently started to take her own inspiration from LPW's 'real-life' cases, as created by DL Sayers' books) must have seemed a fun idea in theory, but in practice it didn't work for me. It merely kept calling my attention to the fact I was reading fiction about other works of fiction. And sadly Gordon Griffin's narration did nothing to dispel the ghost of Ian Carmichael's wonderful readings of the other books. No light, quick witted tones here, but ponderous and slightly pompous speeches, which do tend to irritate. I know Peter Wimsey is meant to have aged since our last meeting with him, but in this reading he sounds like an elderly judge, while Bunter sounds so aged that I wondered if he was intended to expire before the end of the book. I'm sure Gordon Griffiths would be a great narrator for some books, but not this one.
I hope this review doesn't sound too negative. It's still an entertaining novel, and it's always good to catch up with Wimsey and Harriet. Although it's not the best, I have no regrets about buying it.
2 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- S
- 09-11-14
If you like Wimsey you should try Paton Walsh
If you could sum up The Late Scholar in three words, what would they be?
Heartwarming, inevitable, closure
Who was your favorite character and why?
As usual Harriet Vane stands forth here and her characterisation develops even further. Paton Walsh is a really good writer. She needs to be to follow DL Sayers and some of the early books when she picks up the story are a bit wooden. In this one, however, she is starting to relax and the story and the people flow better through the plot.The one thing I find challenging is that she continues to give the relationship between Wimsey / Vane and Bunter a dynamic that I rubs me up the wrong way. Yes it's now post war but it's a bit forced.
Did you have an emotional reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?
The Late Scholar is a bit like a pair of old slippers, warm, comfortable and good for sitting by the fire.
2 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story

- Duncan
- 29-09-16
A Reasonable Progression
I write this after reading some less than positive reviews from others. JPW has made a good effort to keep the Wimsey canon going, and has done quite well. The stories have progressed the timeline reasonably although there seems an undue concentration on the domestic arrangements rather than the 'plot'.
Generally JPW books are longer, slower and more ponderous than those of Dorothy Sayers herself. The originals were much tighter, even if Sayers had a predilection for literary quotations, a predilection that JPW overuses.
I think The Late Scholar is one of JPWs better efforts, along the lines of The Attenbury Diamonds (athough in that book the fire a Dukes Denver and ducal accession were unecessary distractions). I enjoyed its sense of time and style and a good evocation of Oxford, certainly as good as the Gaudy Night sense of the University.
The narration was not good and did not add to the experience nor help the book, but this is compared to Ian Carmichael who was made for the part, as a narrator or actor.
Yes there were mispronunciations, yes the was confusion over character voices (Parker was the wrong voice altogether), but overall the sense of the place and time and people was reasonable. I do not agree with the reviewer who could not finish the audiobook. I have listened to it three times this year (in full) and probably will do again in the next few months.
Just a few other points, in my subjective view:
- Contrary to the Publishers Note, Gaudy Night was not one of Sayers's best, it also was too slow and ponderous.
- The Wimsey canon is just that, about Lord Peter Wimsey, and should not be just a vehicle for Harriet Vane.
- I hope JPW does continue the canon, about and of Wimsey, preferably set in the pre-WWII years, because that is his real period.
- I hope Ian Carmichael can be convinced to revive from his eternal rest too give us the best narration, or if not then a IC clone.
1 person found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story

- Rev. Kate
- 18-04-21
Not a Wimsey book at all... sadly
As a detective story or a story in general it is good.
As a Wimsey story it is so far away from the real characters and so dislike Wimsey in all his behaviours, that it is incredibly disappointing.
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story

- Judith
- 04-10-14
Underwhelming
What was most disappointing about Jill Paton Walsh’s story?
The story is contrived. Too many bits brought in from earlier Sayers books in a very contrived way and lacking the development of relationship between Peter and Harriet. Lovely descriptions of Oxford but really not as good as Jill Paton walsh's earlier Sayers books.
How did the narrator detract from the book?
Like the other reviewers I love Edward Petherbridge and Ian Carmichael. Gordon Griffiths was a shock. You become used to it after a while but it lacks Peter's tone of irony and bunter's voice didn't seem to match at all.
Any additional comments?
I did listen all the way through but it was never gripping. If you have read all of the Sayers books then walsh's thrones and dominions! and the Attenborough emeralds are really good. Read them.