Very disappointing

I had high hopes for this 'ghost' story as I love Helen Dunmore's early novels and have recently listened to Susan Hill's brilliant 'Woman in Black'. This novella starts off well and conjures up a real feeling of isolation of the new GPs wife in a Yorkshire town in the 1950s. This creates a spooky, anticipatory, dreamlike atmosphere. However by halfway through I had tired of the story and found nothing original or vaguely spooky in it. I did persevere to the end as it was well written and narrated and I wanted to find out what happened! Disappointing.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

Great story by a masterful author.

This left me feeling a bit unsettled. A bit of other-wordlyness haunts the characters who seem to exist in a different place where things work in a different way, but they make sense there. The narrator increases the tension imperceptibly, and believably too, to end the book with a satisfying but inexplicable solution. One to read again.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

The Greatcoat

I enjoyed this book but I was not as gripped by the story as much as I had hoped I would be. I am left with a few unanswered questions, I'm not sure if I drifted off during the story or if there are indeed some holes in the plot.



Even so, I don't regret listening to the story; the author brings post war Britain to life in an amazing way and my historical knowledge feels very much enriched. Isabel's daily life highlights the struggles of coping with postwar shortages and rationing while illustrating the role of woman as mothers and home-makers of the time. Through Isabel's childhood memories we are offered the view of war time Britain from a child’s perspective and through her 'dreams' or 'possessions' from an adult viewpoint.



Although the story was well written and I like the easy flow of the narrator I feel that I spend most of the book waiting for it to start. Instead of being classified as a Horror I think it's true description would be that of a historical romance, if that was the case I suspect my expectations would have been met as I wouldn't have been left anticipating something scary to happen.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

10 people found this helpful

another superb story from Dunmore

I was not convinced by this ay first but soon got drawn in. a powerful but understated meditation on grief, loss and the futility of war

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A little disappointing.

This book was just a little disappointing. I like books where I can't tell where it is going next. Sadly with this, I could. Predictable.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

More a supernatural romance than a ghost story

I read the blurb on this download, and gave it a try with the expectation of something more sinister, a wartime ghost story along the same lines as some of Susan Hill's work, or MR James maybe. Unfortunately for me, this is more of a romance novel with a ghost in it, and not really my thing.

However, if you like romance with a historical or supernatural element, this may be for you.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

7 people found this helpful

A bit of a disappointment.

A bit of a disappointment.

This book was recommended to me by a few people as a good ghost story. I didn't find it at all scary and a lot of it didn't make sense. I didn't engage with, or even like, any of the characters. I didn't really feel like it went anywhere and the plot didn't grip me. I listened to the end, but I do feel as though I wasted my time waiting for something exciting to happen. The setting and description of the post war years was very good, but not enough to rescue the book from being disappointing.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!