The Great Degeneration
Failed to add items
Add to basket failed.
Add to wishlist failed.
Remove from wishlist failed.
Adding to library failed
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed
Get 3 months for £0.99/mo
Buy Now for £7.99
-
Narrated by:
-
Paul Slack
-
By:
-
Niall Ferguson
About this listen
Symptoms of decline are all around us today, it seems: slowing growth, crushing debts, aging populations, anti-social behaviour. But what exactly is amiss with Western civilization? The answer, Niall Ferguson argues, is that our institutions - the intricate frameworks within which a society can flourish or fail - are degenerating. To arrest the degeneration of the West's civilization, Ferguson warns, will take heroic leadership and radical reform.
The Great Degeneration is the latest, provocative work from Niall Ferguson, best-selling author of The Ascent of Money.
©2012 Niall Ferguson (P)2013 W F Howes LtdCritic reviews
Worth a listen
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
Maybe the worst thing was the tone of the narration. Paul Slack reads in a 'Jeremy Clarkson sarcasm' voice throughout, which made me feel that the degeneration of the legal system and collapse of civil society was my own, personal, fault.
Buy the hard copy
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
Do not Buy!!
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.
The premise is not a bad one - that there are deep structural issues with Western institutions. So far, so good. And some of the exploration of why institutions fail - overbearing government intervention, or overly restrictive legislation, are spot on.
But rapidly, this book turns into a rallying call for unregulated capitalism. The endless stream of non-sequiturs, and conflating correlation with causation, is utterly baffling. For example, when a poorly regulated financial system caused untold misery to millions in 2008, what was the problem, according to Ferguson? That the regulation existed at all - with less regulation, we would all have been better off. Apparently. Eh?
A whole chapter is dedicated to why Western culture is so vastly superior to everywhere else - the chapter on law is vomit-inducing. The premise is 'what can everywhere else (e.g. China) learn from our legal systems?', which is immediately a dodgy start, when the idea of transplanting one legal system from one place to another is laughable, as if it's something the Chinese would come to and ask for. But it gets worse, with paragraph after paragraph implicitly stating that everything in the West is automatically the best.
The chapter on education is phenomenally elitist. Apparently the answer to poor public schooling is not to invest in better infrastructure, pay teachers properly or to try and raise standards - it is to create a market. This market would work fine for Ferguson and those who share his beliefs, as wealthy and privileged elites, but for the rest of us 90%, it makes no sense whatsoever. Free schools in the UK have been a disaster - for every success, there are a dozen that have stagnated and several which have got worse.
Perhaps the institution in which Ferguson's degeneration has been greatest is his own - where historians become advocates of elitist, patronising and culturally 'superior' interests on behalf of the wealthy.
Do not read.
Misses the mark entirely - a book that has been disproved in less than a decade
Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.