Disappointed

This is my first book by this author. I had read some good reviews but was disappointed.

I felt the story was cliched and the protagonists massive caricatures. The story had some promise but ultimately didn’t deliver for me.

Also I didn’t particularly enjoy the reader.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Just about ok

Very good performance by the narrator.
I must admit that I struggled with this book.
The main character is SO annoying. Going on about Jane Austen and literature through (what were supposed to be) some very dramatic and traumatic events. The whole plot was totally unrealistic.
Having said that, I finished it (but only because it was a book club choice and I want to be able to talk about it with my group!)

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Feel a bit force fed.

Bit spoilt by the author shoehorning politics and issues (and this comes from someone who agrees with much of the politics in the book). Personally, I prefer subtlety of author voice hidden within a great story and characters I’m invested in. It’s pretty relentless and sometimes cliched and this made me feel like the author doubted my intelligence and assumed I needed spoon feeding.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Not my cup of tea

More of a romance than a thriller

I’m new to the writer, and I was expecting a thriller, not a romance. I admire the writer’s attempts to subvert the genre and her attempts at making a strong female character, but it didn’t work; came across forced and unbelievable. (Rather than having the protagonist say strong words, get them to be and act strong?)
I wanted to slap the main character by the end.
I also felt it a bit patronising to working class families and jobs.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

Excellent from start to finish

Amanda Craig has again written an intelligent, witty and relevant novel that straddles genres and delights in the richness of its prose

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Lucy Price-Lewis really brings Cornwall to life

I now want to read everything Amanda Craig has written

A gorgeous novel for our time set in Cornwall containing love loss and everything in between but ultimately it is a story about everything human nature has to offer. It is really one of the best novels I have read in a while. In that it gives both style and substance equal billing and does both wonderfully well.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Not sure

I really wanted to like this - the "back cover blurb" appealed, it sounded a good premise for a gripping story; unfortunately on the whole it wasn't. It's likely that it will probably offend people with rural backgrounds or lives and people who voted to Leave the EU, or Conservative voters - unfortunately the author wears her political colours very clearly on her sleeve and denegrates anyone who doesn't love London or the EU as ignorant bigots and Tory voters as misguided at best! If you can get past that, it's a benign enough book.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Rings a bell!

Most enjoyable book, read it in three days as couldn't put it down
good credible characters and the plot was a modern day slant on .........

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Loved the narration

The Cornish voices were perfect easy on the ear for those of us lucky enough to live here. Well done.

Complex contemporary content that rose and fell with some really exciting episodes.

Beauty and the beast, Arthurian fables, a modern fairy tale to completely absorb and entertain.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A Marmite book

You will either love this or hate it, I think - hence the reference to Marmite. It is hard to see there being much middle ground here.I had heard good things about the author and the quality of her work, so I was looking forward to a good listening experience.

What I was treated to was a real mish-mash of cliched opinion, a portrait of Cornwall as an impoverished backwater, the portrayal of the Cornish as rich degenerates/rich outsiders/ignorant, poorly educated, anti-EU locals and the woes of divorcing women. As a representation of Cornwall and the Cornish the author has been very unkind and unfair in my opinion. But the worst thing, for me, was the preposterous central plot device the author used - two strangers meet on a train, discover a common grievance (rich men who are bastards) and agree to carry out the murder of each other's husbands. I just found the whole thing so hard to connect with. On the one hand, the author wants us to believe that the central character is an intelligent woman who has been wronged by her husband and who is struggling to make a life for herself and her young daughter. But on the other hand she wants us to believe that this same intelligent woman would agree to murder a complete stranger after a few glasses of wine on a train and, by doing so, put her daughter's welfare and future in jeopardy. Utter tosh.

The author clearly has strong political and feminist views. There is nothing wrong with either of those things but she did lay some of it on thickly; some subtlety and finesse would have helped. The characters themselves were well drawn and some of them were likeable. But overall, the silly central device plot ruined the whole thing for me.

The narration was very good.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful