It's long

Fred Pohl sets up a story the long way, with a lot of character development. It can drag, but it is worth it when all the disparate pieces of the story come together.

3 people found this helpful

A focus on personality interactions

We discover a place where time comes 'almost' to a standstill, relative to earth.
The focus on getting a female pregnant goes to interactions

3 people found this helpful

Disperate narrative

Would you try another book from Frederik Pohl and/or Oliver Wyman?

Of course. This is the only Pohl novel I read or listened to in audiobook form that I did not find extremely interesting. This novel is interesing, but it's not quite up to par with the others Heechee Saga novels.

If you’ve listened to books by Frederik Pohl before, how does this one compare?

This novel continues Pohl's narrative style of interspersing first person and sometimes third person narratives within the same structure. I have been on two minds on this style since I first read one of his novels. When he does it, it simply "works". I give him much credit for making a difficult narrative structure work, repeatedly. However, each time I wonder if this novel would only be that much better had he stuck with third person limited.

The other novels all featured a single main plot line, with a few interesting story arcs gravitating around that main plot line. This novel breaks that by putting together seemingly unrelated sections. This too could result in something interesting with a surprise ending that unifies what before seemed completely unrelated plots. But I don't think that can work here due to the length of the novel, and the only point where it became possible to start merging these plot lines.

What does Oliver Wyman bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

Oliver Wyman is an excellent narrator. I have purchased books because the publisher contracted his voice talent.

Did The Boy Who Would Live Forever inspire you to do anything?

Nope

Any additional comments?

It's a good novel. Not bad. But not great either. It's not on the order of Gateway, or any of the subsequent novels in that fictional world.

I often find the mischaracterization of religious folk a bit grating that occurs relatively frequently these days in the SF world. It bugs me when an author creates a character who is nothing more thana caricature cobbled together from slurs, epithets, and base accusations by people who don't like folk of one religious denomination or another. It cheapens the rest of the novel when the author puts so much more work into bring to life his other characters. Here he has a main character who is well-rounded and believable. Then we have a minister who is more or less a caricature. There was nothing real or believable about him.

1 person found this helpful

excellent performance, but the storyline was not

the performance was excellent but the story line was not as good as the previous books

Not what I was hoping for.

I was a bit disappointed by this final book in the Gateway series. However, it's still a good read and an excellent series. The performance throughout the series is excellent.

Boring

Would you try another book from Frederik Pohl and/or Oliver Wyman?

This novel jumps around way too much. Seems just like an anthology of heechee short stories strung together by a common thread. I found myself wanting it to be over.

I generally like Frederick Pohl, and I liked the other heechee novels, especially at the start, but this one seems disjointed and boring.

It is like a long soap opera with no action and no plot. More like a way for Pohl to preach his world views to his readers, disguised as a novel.

Did Oliver Wyman do a good job differentiating all the characters? How?

Wyman's narration was excellent.

Any additional comments?

Yawn.

1 person found this helpful

Dull, boring

What could have made this a 4 or 5-star listening experience for you?

Puts me asleep listening to Pohl going on and on in detail describing food dishes. Or describing the decisions made by the richest people in the universe.

What was most disappointing about Frederik Pohl’s story?

Boring and uninteresting...

What didn’t you like about Oliver Wyman’s performance?

Well done and consistent.

If you could play editor, what scene or scenes would you have cut from The Boy Who Would Live Forever?

Most