Real people with public lives

Where does Princes at War rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

This is one of the best books I have listened to.

What other book might you compare Princes at War to, and why?

Like many of the biographies of early 20th century political figures (Margot at War, about Margaret Asquith; or the story of the Mitford sisters) in dealing with people of whom we have all heard, but who are now fading into the pages of history. However, this one is exceptionally good at combining the public and private aspects of their lives. Whilst the author is humane in her approach to the individuals, she is also clear-sighted about the obsession of Edward VIII for Mrs Simpson, and Mrs Simpson's insatiable hunger for wealth, position and most of all a royal title.

Have you listened to any of Cameron Stewart’s other performances? How does this one compare?

This is the first time I have listened to Cameron Stewart, but he was an excellent narrator: clear, well-paced, a pleasant voice, that brought the book through clearly without any of the mannerisms that can sometimes distract. I liked the fact that he did NOT try to adopt a different voice for every person who was quoted, which is current fashionable. I will look forward to listening to him again.

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

Not a single moment, but rather the theme of how heavily his role as king weighed on George VI is always impressive and moving.

Any additional comments?

This book was a well-balanced combination of political history (the events leading up to the abdication, to the war, and the way the war played out) and personal history (the effects of these various events on the people involved, and the human and family interactions between them). Without ever being salacious or prying, it gave me an enhanced sense of how the public events fitted into the private lives of these individual, and how their individual gifts and personalities affected those events.

15 people found this helpful

Fascinating must read for anyone interested in modern history!

I remained gripped, throughout this book, at the honest insights into the personalities that influenced the Second World War. Highly recommended read for anyone interested in people, personal experiences and the royalty as people. Charmingly read.

5 people found this helpful

Interesting angle on a well known story

Have you listened to any of Cameron Stewart’s other performances? How does this one compare?

At the start of the book I found the narrators style rather old fashioned. But as I got used to it I found it suited the story. So much of this is set in the 1930's and 1940's and people did speak a bit differently then.
This is the only book I have listened to read by this narrator, so I don't know if his style would be different for a different book.

Any additional comments?

I have read other books covering the abdication, but I found this interesting in the way this book compared and contrasted the behaviour of the the 4 brothers during WWII. It was good to find out more about the Dukes of Kent and Gloucester. I felt the author was even-handed as he told the story and let the actions of the brothers reveal their characters. George VI, Gloucester and Kent all rose to the challenge and worked for the good of the country, accepting the sacrifices they had to make. All spent less time with their families then they would have liked. The Duke of Windsor, on the other hand put his wife first, himself second, and didn't seem to worry about anyone or anything else. I would recommend this book to anyone who has an interest in the Royal Family and especially the Duke of Windsor.

4 people found this helpful

Good read.

Very interesting stuff for anyone interested in the period and the people. Certainly things revealed in this book I had no idea about.

3 people found this helpful

Stunning Account

This book is more than just an appraisal of the personal lives of two brothers it is an excellent account of the events leading up to and during the Second World War. The author manages to combine painstaking and thorough research with a highly accessible and readable narrative. The narrator does an excellent job reading in an unobtrusive way without thank goodness trying to imitate the voices of Churchill or other leading protagonists of the time. The historical events are so dramatic in themselves that they do not need histrionic flourishes on the part of the narrator.

The description of the evacuation of British troops from Dunkirk when France fell into the hands of the Germans was one of the best I have ever read. The Battle of Britain was wonderfully described too. What the author really managed to convey was the sense of isolation when Britain found herself alone facing the seemingly overwhelming might of the Nazis.

I loved the excerpts from the war diary of “Bertie” and his self effacing bravery and courage were remarkable compared with the selfish and egotistical behaviour of his brother David.

It was no doubt in my mind a good thing for England that King Edward abdicated his throne. He never seemed to attain adult maturity and there is a limit to the power of childish charm especially in times of real crisis. The bone of contention dividing the brothers remained the status of Wallis Simpson whom the new King refused to grant the title of Royal Highness. This dispute seems so childish when considered in the light of the terrible events facing the British people at the time. The author maintains a healthy distance and neutrality in describing the relationship of the tandem Edward and Mrs Simpson. It is up to the listener to forge his own opinion from the facts presented.

A splendid book and I can highly recommend it.

6 people found this helpful

Learning about history

My father said he and his RAF colleagues supported King Edward and wanted him to remain king at the time. Thank god he did not as he would have given into Hitler at once. I can now understand our current Queen better and appreciate her as she inherited her father’s qualities.

2 people found this helpful

The Inside Story

This is a gripping account, well told, of the roles played by the four royal brothers before and during WW2. I have read many books about the abdication, but never in such enthralling detail. Excerpts from the King's diary during the conflict are especially illuminating as he agonises over the heavy losses incurred by the Armed Forces in those first harrowing years. The treasonous path chosen by his brother, the ex-king, is discussed at length. This book is an eye-opener, with heroes and villains popping up everywhere.

4 people found this helpful

History at its best

An amazing account of four brothers with so much on their shoulders during the Great War. At times I felt the sarcasm towards the Duke of Windsor was a bit too much, but overall a must listen to everyone interested in the Royal family, the UK history and WW2. Five stars for story and performance. Will probably listen to this book again.

1 person found this helpful

Highly recommended

Wonderful book. Couldn’t stop listening. A really absorbing account of the brothers and the impact of the abduction but also of WWII and it’s main timeline. Excellent excellent book, vastly exceeded my expectations. I can’t stop listening but also am dreading it ending. Favourite book in quite a long time.

1 person found this helpful

Historical fiction?

The author cannot be regarded even as a popular historian. She takes not every basic attention to historical accuracy, constantly describing 20th century monarchs as “kings of England “ rather than kings of UK. She imagines England is an island! The story is entertaining but relies heavily on speculation, gossip and conspiracy theory. It’s OK (because of the narrator) but I wouldn’t take such a sloppy author too seriously.

1 person found this helpful