Masterpiece

Is it only me who has been living in ignorance or is this book vastly underrated? I thought I knew of all Dickens' great young characters, but I had never come across Jenny Wren, the doll's dressmaker, and she's far more interesting and well-developed than many of the better-known ones. A great book, enhanced by an excellent reader.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

No editing

This recording has not been edited properly. Simon Vance, who is a very good reader, has corrected himself at times and both the original recording and the corrected version are left in, so that you hear both. It is interesting but annoying, and the faulty editing should have been picked up.
As to the novel, it is not one of Dickens’ best. In order to convey to the reader the real identity of his hero, he has a chapter in which the hero talks to himself about his past, which feels rather clumsy.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great story, well read

The only criticism I would make is about the editing! Sentences repeated (presumably where the reader takes a break) and very abrupt chapter endings. Otherwise, this is a great Dickens novel and well read.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Bad editing

It's a pity that the editing of this audiobook is so poor, the narrator frequently re-reads phrases and both versions are kept in - so you keep hearing double! It's sometimes entertaining to get a glimpse of the craft involved in audio narration, but mostly it distracts you from the narrative. I can't think of any other medium where this would be acceptable, imagine watching a movie where the outtakes are left in! Otherwise this is a great story, but I love Dickens in any form. I enjoyed Simon Vance's narration but found it a bit one-dimensional, he has a supercilious tone to his voice all the time which, with Dickens' long sentences, can be a bit irritating. (Anton Lesser's narration cannot be matched - please do more Mr Lesser!)

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

10 people found this helpful

Great book, well read, but sadly spoilt

Dickens is in his usual form with great characters who are recognisable in every age. Here he deals with wealth and poverty and introduces us to people of every layer of society who are greedy for money and others who are generous and kind.

He shows us that for some wealth can ruin their character whilst others thrive in relative poverty.

His text could well the "The love of money is the root of all evil."

The characters are brought to live by Simon Vance's wonderful reading of the story. Each character is distinct and clear.

Sadly the recording is ruined by dreadful editing. In pretty well every chapter, and often several times in a chapter, lines are repeated as the reader gives a second rendition of the same phrase. In one case a whole chapter is repeated.

This failing is a surprise at first, becomes a frustration and by the end of the book is a genuine annoyance.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

15 people found this helpful

Excellent Narration

I had forgotten the strong sense of social justice in Dickens's works. We can listen to Dickens today and still be moved. Simon Vance has a pleasing voice and is a superb narrator.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great Read / Listen

So enjoyed listening to this. Knew the story and the reader read the characters so well. Very funny in the places where it is meant to be funny. Recommend.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Wonderful

Such a great story to listen too, especially if you enjoy description. As always Charles Dickens is the master of description, describing people, dress, food, London, and most especially here peoples attitude to money.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Classic Dickens

If you could sum up Our Mutual Friend in three words, what would they be?

Cutting social commentary.

What other book might you compare Our Mutual Friend to, and why?

Most novels by Dickens - Dickens's books are incredibly good at examining society of the time and pointing out the flaws, inconsistencies and two-facedness of it. This does of course mean that the villains are more villainous and the heroes more heroic than one would expect in reality, but part of the novelist's role is to shine a spotlight on these things, necessarily making them stand out more brightly.I have a particular joy at Dickens's onomatopoeic character names, they're marvellous throughout his books!

What about Simon Vance’s performance did you like?

Vance is a truly admirable reader. His characterisations are brilliant, and maintained throughout (I loved his voice for Silas Wegg, so fitting!). I actually logged in to Audible just now in order to identify more books he has read!

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

No - I need sleep; it's a little long for that! However, I did manage a few long sessions with it. I believe the original was published monthly in nineteen parts. It would be interesting to know where the original breaks were, in order to attempt listening to the novel again in those same parts.

Any additional comments?

More care could have been taken with the editing. There are several places where Vance has re-read a line but the editing (or lack thereof) has left both reads in the final audio.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Well read

Good story well read, very well read, attitudes are a bit dated.
the editing is poor.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!