Broken Heartlands cover art

Broken Heartlands

A Journey Through Labour's Lost England

Preview
Try Premium Plus free
Pick 1 audiobook a month from our unmatched collection - including bestsellers and new releases.
Unlimited access to our all-you-can-listen catalogue of 15K+ audiobooks and podcasts
Access exclusive sales and deals.
£8.99/month after 30 days. Renews automatically.

Broken Heartlands

By: Sebastian Payne
Narrated by: Sebastian Payne
Try Premium Plus free

£8.99/month after 30 days. Renews automatically. See here for eligibility.

Buy Now for £12.99

Buy Now for £12.99

About this listen

Broken Heartlands is an essential and compelling political road-trip through ten constituencies that tell the story of Labour’s red wall, by Sebastian Payne – an award-winning journalist and Whitehall Editor for the Financial Times.

The Times Political Book of the Year
A Daily Telegraph, Guardian, Daily Mail and
FT Book of the Year
'Immensely readable' - Observer

Historically, the red wall formed the backbone of Labour’s vote in the Midlands and the North of England but, during the 2019 general election, it dramatically turned Conservative for the first time in living memory, redrawing the electoral map in the process.

Originally from the North East himself, Payne sets out to uncover the real story behind the red wall and what turned these seats blue. Beginning in Blyth Valley in the North East and ending in Burnley, with visits to constituencies across the Midlands and Yorkshire along the way, Payne gets to the heart of a key political story of our time that will have ramifications for years to come.

While Brexit and the unpopularity of opposition leader Jeremy Corbyn are factors, there is a more nuanced story explored in Broken Heartlands – of how these northern communities have fared through generational shifts, struggling public services, de-industrialization and the changing nature of work. Featuring interviews with local people, plus major political figures from both parties – including Boris Johnson and Sir Keir Starmer – Payne explores the significant role these social and economic forces, decades in the making, have played in this fundamental upheaval of the British political landscape.

'Impressive and entertaining' - Sunday Times
'A must-read for anyone who wants to understand England today' - Robert Peston

Elections & Political Process Emigration & Immigration Politics & Government Social Sciences England

Listeners also enjoyed...

The Fall of Boris Johnson cover art
Blue Murder cover art
Beyond the Red Wall cover art
One Party After Another cover art
All Out War: The Full Story of How Brexit Sank Britain’s Political Class cover art
The Abuse of Power cover art
Turning Points cover art
The Third Man: Life at the Heart of New Labour cover art
What Went Wrong with Brexit cover art
How to Run Britain cover art
Protest and Power cover art
In Denial cover art
All In: How we build a country that works cover art
There Is Nothing For You Here cover art
Politically Homeless cover art
Values, Voice and Virtue cover art

Critic reviews

Broken Heartlands is the product of rich reporting on the ground . . . Payne tells many stories of many places and people with affection and respect, to weave a picture of the changing political fabric of England (Laura Kuenssberg)
A compelling chronicle of why English politics is undergoing such fundamental change. A must-read for anyone who wants to understand England today (Robert Peston)
The political book of the year about one of the most consequential elections of my lifetime. Essential reading (Andrew Neil)
A really fascinating and surprisingly moving book. Payne takes us on a journey that feels personal as well as political and helps us better understand what the red wall really is, who its voters are, and what politics has meant to them over the past few tumultuous years (Isabel Hardman, author of Why We Get The Wrong Politicians)
A must-read for all those who want to learn the lessons of Labour's 2019 defeat (Paul Mason, author of PostCapitalism )
Sebastian Payne demolishes the clichés that smother debate about the north of England and provides a simultaneously tender and acute guide to the land that London forgot (Nick Cohen)
Part travelogue, part Question Time, Payne interviews pretty much everyone. This is a first draft of history as first drafts of history should properly be written (Tom Holland)
Immensely readable. Labour’s crisis in the red wall . . . will shape the future of English politics. This engrossing, warm and insightful work is an indispensable guide to how it came about (Observer, book of the week)
Compelling, authoritative but human . . . the book will inevitably become an important resource for historians
Reminiscent of Orwell's The Road to Wigan Pier, Payne travels around Labour's former 'red wall' to paint a stark picture of those left behind
Payne’s entertaining and insightful book is essential reading
Comprehensive and entertaining (The Times, book of the week)
One of the book’s many strengths is its precision . . . Payne’s book examines the narratives on Red Wall constituencies like the layers of an onion: starting with superficial readings, before peeling them back to reveal greater complexity (Stephen Bush, New Statesman)
Entertaining political travelogue . . . plenty of insights . . . Payne is a guide without any trace of snobbery
Payne, who grew up in Gateshead . . . has an instinctive rapport with people who feel overlooked and abandoned by Labour
First class political reportage . . . should be considered required reading for anyone interested in British politics
Nuanced take on Labour's lost strongholds. Raised in Gateshead, Payne brings intimacy and depth
Broken Heartlands digs into the fabric of the post-industrial communities that only make headlines at election time and challenges received wisdom and lazy myths
All stars
Most relevant
Payne has a tendency to choose the narratives he prefers but some illuminating contributions nonetheless

A selective picture but still worthwhile

Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.

This book analyses why Labour lost the 2019 General Election. But Payne goes further and assumes that Boris Johnson's delivery will match his rhetoric and that Brexit won't cause substantial damage in red wall constituencies. From the perspective of late December 2021 things already look very different. The Conservative's new electoral Coalition is far more flimsy than Payne suggests in this book. Despite all this I still found it an interesting anecdotal listen of many places in England that I have never visited.

Too focused on ex Labour Voters who voted Leave

Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.

its a shame stoke on trent was completely ignored. History of mining steel pottery industry all gone i would say it fits the profile the author was discussing. It's three labour seats all weighted towards brexit all voted conservative... an entire city forgotten about, maybe i missed something in the selection criteria. perhaps im just oversensitive because SOT is always shoved to the back of the queue or even out of the queue entirely. I would have liked to hear what the people of my grandparents' city had to say.

incomplete

Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.

Really interesting insight for anyone interested in this topic. I wasn't keen on the author's narration, but recommend otherwise!

Interesting listen

Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.

A charming travelogue, wittily told with a lovely lightness of touch, conceals a razor-sharp political lesson. Everyone should read this.

The most important political book of the decade

Something went wrong. Please try again in a few minutes.

See more reviews