False Witnesses Exposed: The Torah's Stunning Chiddush on Eidim Zomemim

Failed to add items

Sorry, we are unable to add the item because your shopping cart is already at capacity.

Add to basket failed.

Please try again later

Add to wishlist failed.

Please try again later

Remove from wishlist failed.

Please try again later

Adding to library failed

Please try again

Follow podcast failed

Unfollow podcast failed

False Witnesses Exposed: The Torah's Stunning Chiddush on Eidim Zomemim

Listen for free

View show details

What happens when two witnesses testify about a murder — and then other witnesses prove they couldn't have been there? In this shiur, we dive into the fascinating halacha of Eidim Zomemim, using a vivid example: Reuven and Shimon claim they saw Jack kill Jill on top of Mount Trashmore in Evanston — but Levi and Yehuda prove they were in Atlantic City that very day. The Torah's chiddush, rooted in a pasuk in Shmos and unpacked through the Gemara's darshanim, is striking: not only is the original testimony nullified, but the witnesses themselves become pasul retroactively — disqualified as edim, not just disbelieved. Why does the Torah tell us to believe the latter witnesses over the former, even without logical reason to do so? The answer will change how you think about eidus forever.

Timestamps:
0:00 - Introduction & announcements
0:45 - Introducing the sugya: What is Eidim Zomemim?
1:30 - The Jack and Jill case: Reuven and Shimon testify in Beis Din
3:00 - Setting the scene: Mount Trashmore, August 13th, the Chicago Beis Din
4:15 - Levi and Yehuda's hazamah: "You were with us in Atlantic City"
5:30 - The core question: Are Reuven and Shimon pasul only from now, or retroactively?
6:30 - The Torah's chiddush: why we believe the latter witnesses (Gezeiras HaKasov)
8:00 - The pasuk from Shmos (23:1) — Rav Aryeh Kaplan's Living Torah translation
9:15 - The Gemara's darshan: edim convicted of sheker become pasul l'eidus entirely
10:45 - The stunning conclusion: they're not just disbelieved — they are eidei sheker
11:45 - Summary and closing thoughts

#torahlearning #jewishpodcast #talmud #halacha #eidimzomemim #hazamah #falswitnesses #jewishlaw #shiur #dafyomi #mishnahtorah #rambam #gemara #beitdin #torahwithsimcha #jewishwisdom #orthodoxjewish #parshaweek #torahclass #jewishlife

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/torah-with-simcha--4985090/support.

Torah with Simcha is produced by Kol Simcha Productions.
New episodes released regularly — exploring Torah, Jewish thought, and the wisdom that connects ancient text to everyday life.
Contact: kolsimchaproductions@outlook.com
Content is shared for educational, spiritual, and inspirational purposes. Sources are cited to the best of our ability. If you find an error or have a question about a source, please email kolsimchaproductions@outlook.com and we will look into it promptly.
Support the show — exclusive bonus content available to subscribers for just $2/month at spreaker.com/organization/kol-simcha
Not affiliated with any synagogue, rabbinical organization, or academic institution. All Torah discussion is offered in the spirit of learning — with meaning.

No reviews yet