Superb!

I love murder mysteries set in the theatre of the 1930s/40s - so am a fan of Ngaio Marsh, for example. Reading books written in that period - like watching films made then - requires something of a mindshift, from present-day sensibilities to the attitudes and beliefs which prevailed at that time. However, An Expert in Murder, set in the theatreworld of the 1930s, but written very recently, combines that cosy period feel with contemporary sensibilities, which makes it much more than a nostalgic read.

Narration is simply first class, characterisation is superb and the evocation of pre-War theatrical life is wonderful. The story twists and turns and, although I actually spotted the culprit fairly early on, there were enough red herrings to keep me not entirely certain of my conclusion until - most satisfyingly - I was proved right, and celebrated the resulting smugness with a cup of tea and several biscuits.

I particularly enjoyed the fact that the story continues beyond the reveal of the villain. At first this was disconcerting - the party was over, so why couldn't we all go home? But then it suddenly seemed to work, and it was good to know what happened once the mystery was over.

Can't recommend it highly enough.

29 people found this helpful

Hard to believe this story was set in the 1930's

Whilst I did manage to make it to the end, I was dissapointed and won't be listening to any more in this series.

Perhaps I am more use to the contemporary writers of the story period as I did not fully warm to the vocabulary of either the spoken word or narrative and at times struggled with a couple of the plot elements and chosen terminology.

I had to 'rewind' the story to re-listen to a couple of more modern sayings which caught me by surprise and I am pretty sure were not in use in this time period( eg 'unmarked police car' ).

The story and performance were ok but throughout I had to keep reminding myself of when the story was supposed to be set due to the ongoing use of modern phrases and terminology.

11 people found this helpful

Absorbing and sublime

Satisfying on so many levels. From the start Upson's characters are there, fully formed. It felt like returning to a series and a world that I already knew, the middle of a conversation I was already part of; immediately absorbing. The main characters are engaging, human; flawed and likeable - testament to the skill of both the author and the narrator. I loved the whole thing. It was one of those stories that I listened to at every opportunity in my day - not just the usual journey to and from work times. Then to discover that it is a fictionalised element of the lives of a real author, some real people, a real play, an actual theatre makes it all the more intriguing. I'm now off to order the real Josephine Tey's mystery books and John Guilgood's autobiography to read. And of course, about to start listening to the next audible installment of the series. Why have you missed out number 2 Audible? It's very frustrating!

8 people found this helpful

A brilliantly creative murder mystery

If you could sum up An Expert In Muder: Josephine Tey Series, Book 1 in three words, what would they be?

Enthralling - Shocking - Inventive.

Who was your favorite character and why?

It's difficult to choose between Archie and Josephine - their relationship creates the same tensions and delights that are found between Dorothy L Sayers' Peter Wimsey and Harriet Vane.

What does Sandra Duncan bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you had only read the book?

Sandra Duncan creates an individual and instantly recognisable voice for each character, coupled with expressive and precise narration. I listened over an extended period of time, wanting to suspend reality for as long as possible! Each time I listened, I joined the characters eagerly not only to find out what happened next, but to enjoy their company.

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

Without wanting to give anything away, the murder near the beginning was unexpected and made me gasp with disbelief. Nicola Upson creates convincing, rounded characters and by the time the action begins the reader has engaged with everyone who has been introduced, and it feels as though the victim is known personally to the reader.

Any additional comments?

I have resisted buying subsequent novels by Nicola Upson in print as Sandra Duncan's reading is so compelling in recreating the world of the fictitious Josephine Tey for the audience.

14 people found this helpful

Quite a gentle period piece.

Lots of threads to the story pulled together to bring an interesting end to the story. I liked the characters and the setting.
A nice easy listening experience.

5 people found this helpful

Excellent story

What did you like most about An Expert In Murder: Josephine Tey Series, Book 1?

Some of the issues it deals with are quite dark but was dealt with in a palatable manor , especially given the time it is set in. The place involved were so descriptive you could see them in your minds eye, the characters are also different in their own way , their personalities makes you feel like you know them and care about them. Equally interesting is the fact that Josephine actually existed and I feel she writes with sensitivity and is the champion always of Tey . Great story wonderful writing.

What other book might you compare An Expert In Murder: Josephine Tey Series, Book 1 to, and why?

I would say she has her own style and weavers her story so well you have to keep turning the page which I find refreshing but Anything by Agatha Christie,P.D.James, Ruth Rendell Barbara Erskine, Sarah Walters however, I find her a very intelligent writer , usually I can know the killer very quickly but I have to work harder to figure it out. It also makes you want to find out more of the subject or people that she has drawn from. Any book that makes you want to know more is a good thing . Very imaginative writing, and the historical background well researched.

Which character – as performed by Sandra Duncan – was your favourite?

Defiantly Tay herself, she has a dry wit and doesn't know how funny she is at times, but she is calm in a crises, I like her.

Did you have an emotional reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

It certainly made me think about the lost generation in the Great War and how things socially changed between the classes specially on estates with grand houses and how tight knit some communities are. Some parts made me sad.

Any additional comments?

I have already bought the other books in the series so far as I want to see how the characters progress and Nicola Upson writes so well and the books are enjoyable to read or listen too, if you have discovered this writer then if you love murder mystery with historical fact it's a must for you.

4 people found this helpful

An expert in murder

Wow. A really good murder mystery, an excellent pace, some humour and lots of suspects and red herrings. Set between the wars, lovely period quality to the writing.

3 people found this helpful

I think Josephine Tey would have been impressed

A very well-crafted murder mystery with enough sympathetic characters to draw me in. The plot develops well, with enough clues to point you to the culprit while sprinkling the path with a few red herrings to keep you guessing. Well up to the standards of Josephine Tey herself.
The narration was excellent, but - and this is a minor criticism - I felt that her tone was occasionally a little emotionally remote.
All in all a very enjoyable and satisfying listen.

3 people found this helpful

Very well read.

This was a very enjoyable book and I was pleasantly surprised by the ability and versatility of the narrator; she brought the diverse cast of characters to life and her narration greatly enhanced the book.

The plot was interesting with lots of twists and turns and the main characters were well drawn and interesting. I'm looking forward to reading the other books in the series.

3 people found this helpful

A gripping read!

Wow, I've just finished this story and was utterly transfixed as the story unfurled, especially the last few chapters. This is not a typical gentle 'cosy' mystery but much more hard hitting, intriguing and intelligent. It requires active listening and concentration to follow the number of characters and the twists and turns in the plot.
The story explored many facets of human nature including jealousy, hatred, romance, love of many different kinds, sacrifice, loyalty and friendship.
Once I realised how it was going to unravel, I became completely engrossed in how it was going to be explained - gripping stuff!
Not a book to drift off to sleep to but a really enjoyable, gripping novel.
The narrator was excellent and I just loved Josephine Tey's soft 'borders style' accent!

2 people found this helpful