first book

late arrival to Bob skinner this was the first in series if this was the standard then I am looking forward to the rest

2 people found this helpful

Absolutely Fantastic.

I had a funny feeling, that I was going to like the Skinner series, hence starting with the first book and boy, was I right, it was an absolute sensation.

I am really looking forward to listening to the rest of the series, I'm hoping they've all got the same narrator, he did a great job.

Quintin Jardine is an absolute master story teller.

2 people found this helpful

I'm hooked!

I was gripped from the start, loved the characterisation; it promises to be an enjoyable series.

1 person found this helpful

Started well

I was really enjoying this story, the main character - Skinner was such a nice honorable guy and the murder that happened was being investigated ........ then it slowly degenerated into over hyped political tension and crime. It really became boring, I also found the 'sweetness and light, lovey dovey' relationship he has a bit 'Mills and Boon'.

The narration by James Bryce was OK ish, but some of the voices he used were odd to say the least!

I don't think I will bother with following up on the series.

1 person found this helpful

Introduction to Skinner

What made the experience of listening to Skinner's Rules the most enjoyable?

The book gives a comprehensive introduction to the main characters in the ongoing series and has a fast paced storyline to boot. The twists and turns to the story were woven in brilliantly, just when you thought you were on the case off it would go in another direction.
Skinner and crew make understanding the job of the police much easier. Yes this is fiction but I was sucked into the story as if it was unfolding in front of me.

What did you like best about this story?

As a native of Edinburgh I could easily picture the places where the action was taking place which seemed to make the book more personal. For non Edinburghers the use of any online map would help if you are inclined to want to picture the scenes.

What about James Bryce’s performance did you like?

James tells the story brilliantly with slight changes of voice to determine which of the characters is speaking during dialogue. This allowed me to feel I was a fly on the wall listening in.

If you made a film of this book, what would be the tag line be?

Edinburgh, the underside of the tourist city.

Any additional comments?

Quintin Jardine captures me as a reader in a way Ian Rankine never has. He stays true to the city in the most part without changing area or street names which adds greatly to the enjoyment of the story.

1 person found this helpful

Very engaging

What did you like most about Skinner's Rules?

Some deviations on procedural. Is based in I guess the 1980s and reflects that in some of the technical detail.

Who was your favorite character and why?

Maggie - one of the DCs and very sympathetic

Which scene did you most enjoy?

The scene at the Edinburgh debate - believable in many ways, although the set up is somewhat obvious - bringing 'staff' in so late with a single point of failure would simply not have been done and the delay could have been dealt with by getting them to walk!

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

Listened over several journeys in the car

Any additional comments?

A good listen, although some of the more frustrating procedural moments (thinking that they could not/would not have done this turns out to be the means by which the author concludes the plot. Fun though.

2 people found this helpful

Scottish police are great

My mum's been reading QJ's books for years, so I thought I'd better give them a try. I realised I had read this on Kindle a year or so ago - but enjoyed it so much more as the audio version. I can see how the characters will grow through a series of books - and looking forward to seeing how they develop.
The story in this was good, and I liked how the two investigations meshed together. Loved the Scottish setting - although am less familiar with Edinburgh than my hometown Aberdeen from McBride's books. The performance was mostly good - rather too many gruff voice characterisations, and the Aberdonian voice performance wasn't great - a bit of a caricature. But that's picky!
Have just ordered book 2 in the series.

2 people found this helpful

They think it's all over... it's not....

Good thriller just when you think it's all over... Its not....

Very converluted but thrilling plot involving murders on Edinburgh Royal Mile and the possible links to a terror plot.

The story kept my attention, with likable characters and the narrator was also good.

Looks like I've found another good author to follow.

Reccomended.

Ponderous; Pretentious; Predictable

It was hard going, but somehow I listened all the way to the end.

gave up narrator terrible

story slow. narration awful and patronising with the worst character voices I've ever listened to. listened to 17 chapters but can't go on. dull and poorly performed.