Robert Altman

Enthralling!

I bought this book at full price, and as the read began, felt certain I had made a huge mistake. Contrary to the very misleading description given for this item, 98% of the voices of the celebrity narrators listed-- including Robert Altman, himself --are fudged by 3-4 professional audiobook readers, NOT contributed by the actors, directors and producers themselves. The listing of narrators certainly should be changed to protect buyers.

Nevertheless, this is a great audiobook, fully captivating, throughout every one of its 18+ hours. In fact, I liked it so much, that the minute it ended, I played it again, start to finish. It is that insightful, informative and entertaining. The actual voices of Altman's wife, Kathryn, and those of his daughters and sons, along with the stunningly good portrayal of Robert Altman's voice by actor, Michael Murphy, are well worth the price of admission. If you weren't an Altman fan before, this will make you want to rent each of his movies in turn, to experience what you've missed of his extraordinary talent on screen. There will never be another like him and he is missed!

8 of 9 people found this review helpful

Better Than The Book, With An All-Star Altman Cast

The best audiobook I've listened to in a long time.

When Robert Altman died a few years ago, it put into doubt the book that he and Mitchell Zuckoff had been working on. It's hard, however, to imagine how their collaboration could be better than this. Robert Altman's discussions of his movie career are included throughout, but the observations by the other narrators make this audiobook better than the book could be.

Many participants in his movies are quoted at length. In many cases, the narration is done by the actors themselves. For example, Tim Robbins talks about the way he was hired for his starring role in the movie, The Player. Altman's wife, Kathryn, and several of their sons are the actual narrators for their sections. The result is a rich look at his life, as seen by Robert Altman and the people who knew him.

6 of 7 people found this review helpful

Where are the Pictures?

This is an interesting and informative book. However, the hard back book contains hundreds of pictures. The biggest challenge that I have with audio books do not include a document or an Adobe file to download with the pictures included in the book. This is a big drawback for me as a long time subscriber, which needs to be resolved to compete with the all the downloadable book options available to keep subscribers like myself in the future. I hope they find a resolution to this problem. I have seen these files available for very few of the books, however there are some.

Enjoyable book and some of the personal information jumps around so it is hard to follow, entertaining.

7 of 9 people found this review helpful

A Tribute to one of Hollywood’s Last Mavericks

What made the experience of listening to Robert Altman the most enjoyable?

I liked that most of his films were talked about in depth. Also, because it is packed with anecdotes from family members, actors, and crewmembers who mostly read their own accounts.

What other book might you compare Robert Altman to and why?

I've listened to and read many actor and filmmaker biographies and this is probably one of the best, if not the best. I'd compare it to David Carradine's 'Endless Highway.'

What about the narrators’s performance did you like?

I liked that many of the narrators were actually reading their own anecdotes from the book. I think this elevates the experience over reading the written version.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

Not really. It's very long and that's good. I didn't want to stop listening most of the time but to listen to the entire book in one sitting is a bit much.

Any additional comments?

I think that this audiobook is one of the best examples of having a listening experience that is greater than the written version because it is packed with anecdotes from family members, actors, and crewmembers who mostly read their own experiences. Altman was a larger-than-life figure who had appetites that matched his filmmaking talents and this is a fitting tribute to one of Hollywood’s last great mavericks. I would highly recommend this title to anyone who is interested in film or listens to biographies about filmmakers.

3 of 4 people found this review helpful

Great listen

I thought this was a wonderful book. Altman seems like a character in one of his movies. Ok, he is not a very attentive father and he has drinking problems, but he seems to have had a great time doing mostly just what he wanted. It was nice to hear the different opinions of him from the people he worked with and around. Narration is good, Not a good listen for children -- some strong language and some discussion of affairs. Now I will have to watch his movies again!

3 of 4 people found this review helpful

Disappointed

This could have been very interesting but saying who is speaking EVERT time someone said something was very annoying. I don't beleive it was the actual actors narrating it, and it didn't matter, it was disjointed.

4 of 7 people found this review helpful

A great book to read NOT listen to

Beware: this book may be based on recorded interviews BUT these interviews are not what you'll hear: you'll hear people--in most cases not the original interviewees--READING the transcripts of the interviews.

This creates a very disturbing feeling as you listen on: while the grammar is oral, the words are clearly read, not spoken. It's a disaster. Presumably retrieving and using the original interviews was not possible, but the result is that you should probably READ this book, as the experience of listening to it may be, as it was for me, unnerving.

The book itself is quite fascinating. It might be shooting in many directions sometimes, but the choice of creating a complex, multifaceted portrait through many, sometimes contradictory points of view, is great and does Altman justice.

Maybe An Hour Or So Of Good Material

Would you try another book from Mitchell Zuckoff and/or the narrators?

No from author, yes from narrator.

Has Robert Altman turned you off from other books in this genre?

No.

What three words best describe the narrators’s voice?

Like a machine.

What character would you cut from Robert Altman?

Everyone who spends HOURS saying that Robert Altman is an asshole but you have to love him, and then goes on for more HOURS telling stories of when they got drunk together, and Altman was an asshole.... it is an extremely repetitive theme throughout the book. "He was an asshole but you got used to it.... and we were drunk...."

Any additional comments?

Be Warned: When I bought this book, Audible had numerous actors like Meryl Streep and others listed as narrators. Not true! The narrator narrates their stories.

The main actor that did read and did a good job (and is the one hour or so of good material out of 18 hours) is Tim Robbins. He actually talks about movie making, the artist that was Robert Altman, etc.

Be Warned Again: Approximately 17 hours of this book is the narrator quoting people that worked with Altman that all tell the exact same story: He was an alcoholic, drug addict, asshole that you got used to if you gave him enough time to grow on you.

I could not get over how prevalent that theme was and how comparable the stories the various actors, etc that the narrator quoted told throughout the book. As soon as one actor got done, another actors story started and, to compare it to written material, it might as well have been the same story written in a different font.

I decided to tough it out to see if it got better, and Robbins material is interspersed throughout the book, so in short, to get that hour, you listen to the book.

Here is what I would recommend: Any time a story starts being told and you can tell the person is going to tell this "He's An Asshole That Grows On You" story, simply fast forward till you recognize a different voice and see what that person is discussing.

I have never returned a book to Audible, but this is one of them I would seriously consider.

1 of 2 people found this review helpful

Very Enjoyable

Once comfortable with the multiple voice narration, quickly became fond of this book. Though not a book on film making, learned much about directing and production - more so than other film bios. Many famous and infamous contributors, including family members, enliven the story. Am sad that this one ended!

1 of 2 people found this review helpful

enjoyed it very much

What made the experience of listening to Robert Altman the most enjoyable?

narration by many who knew and worked with him

Who was your favorite character and why?

Altman who else it speaks for itself

What does the narrators bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

the actual words of those who made up the book

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

all of it moved me

Any additional comments?

get it listen to it then listen to it again.. I did

1 of 2 people found this review helpful