On October 31, 2012, 24-year-old Rebekah Gay was looking forward to spending Halloween night with her three-year-old son in Isabella County, Michigan. But in the first hours of Halloween, she vanished.

What followed was a chilling investigation that would leave her family and an entire community desperate to understand what had happened to her.

As detectives began retracing her final hours, disturbing evidence emerged. Someone had been inside her home. Someone had tried to conceal what happened there. And someone knew the truth about where Rebekah had gone.

But who? Was it someone she knew? Someone she trusted? Or someone who had been hiding a horrifying secret in plain sight?

As investigators pulled back the layers of Rebekah’s life, they would uncover a darkness far closer to home than anyone could have imagined.And the truth about what happened to Rebekah Gay on Halloween morning would be more horrifying than anyone was prepared to hear.

=============================================

Special thanks to Jessica Kwazz for her writing and research help on this episode.Also, thank you to 𝙈𝙤𝙤𝙣𝙡𝙞𝙜𝙝𝙩 𝙗𝙮 𝙗𝙖𝙨𝙩𝙞𝙖𝙣 for the amazing digitally hand-drawn illustrations to help visually support this case

=============================

DISCLAIMER - This video contains themes of violence. I do not intend to cause any disrespect to anyone I talk about in this video. This is purely a factual and educational piece that I have put together with information I have found on the internet. Rest in peace, Rebekah Gay.

=============================================

📩 For business inquiries: ellimacproductions@gmail.com

=============================================

📚 Sources for this episode:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1UrBWyBOguhLPhTUsR_vX2605937-zRMI/view?usp=share_link

On Halloween night in 1957, in Sun Valley, Los Angeles, 35-year-old Peter Fabiano had already gone to bed.

Then the doorbell rang.Peter went to answer it, expecting one last trick-or-treater.

Seconds later, a single gunshot rang out.

Whoever had been standing on his doorstep was gone, and detectives had no idea who it was, or why.

The answer would lead them to someone who had once been close to the Fabiano family… and to a woman who had never even met Peter.

=============================================

Special thanks to 𝙈𝙤𝙤𝙣𝙡𝙞𝙜𝙝𝙩 𝙗𝙮 𝙗𝙖𝙨𝙩𝙞𝙖𝙣 for the amazing digitally hand-drawn illustrations to help visually support this case

=============================

DISCLAIMER - This video contains themes of violence. I do not intend to cause any disrespect to anyone I talk about in this video. This is purely a factual and educational piece that I have put together with information I have found on the internet. Rest in peace, Peter Fabiano.

=============================================

📩 For business inquiries: ellimacproductions@gmail.com

=============================================

📚 Sources for this episode:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1E2LF89byDS95nDqIbwS2EbkKpGzz959R/view?usp=share_link

May 7th, 2017 was an ordinary Sunday in the town of Bellaire, Ohio. For the Kinney family, it was a day to run errands. David Kinney, along with his wife Cheri and her 13-year-old daughter, had to make a quick stop at his best friend, Brad McGarry’s house to drop off an electric weed trimmer for him to borrow.

But the ordinary task turned into something far more sinister when they arrived and noticed Brad’s door was suspiciously open. David stuck his head in and yelled out for Brad, but all that greeted him was a haunting silence. Struck with the fear that something could be seriously wrong in the home, the three members of the Kinney family walked in.

And their concerns grew into panic as they realized that the house had been ransacked. They kept calling for Brad, but he was seemingly nowhere to be found. David made his way through the house, and when he got to the basement, he frantically shouted to Cheri to call 911.

Brad McGarry was lying face down on the floor of his basement, with a pool of blood around him.When police arrived on the scene, officers found David and Cheri outside the house, hysterical over the loss of their beloved friend, who their kids lovingly called “Uncle Brad”.

Brad was not only a dear friend to the Kinney family, but someone who was adored by a huge network of family and friends. As the investigation began, what looked like a possible fatal home invasion soon shaped into something far more personal.

Someone who claimed to love Brad, and who may have been among the people closest to him, would ultimately be arrested for his murder.

=============================================

DISCLAIMER - This video contains themes of violence. I do not intend to cause any disrespect to anyone I talk about in this video. This is purely a factual and educational piece that I have put together with information I have found on the internet. Rest in peace, Brad McGarry.

=============================================

📩 For business inquiries: ellimacproductions@gmail.com

=============================================

📚 Sources for this episode:

https://drive.google.com/file/d/1-CChMxthPhYtUPQClv-SHzf7AvXtJmMs/view?usp=share_link