Why the singing?

It's The Commitments, we know the story, we trust Roddy Doyle.. Why the awful singing?

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Amazing story

The story needs no introduction it's brilliant and funny in equal measure. The Narrator does a good job but the singing parts are basically him screaming at you, I skipped these parts. Worth it for the story though.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great book spoiled by narrator.

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

I would not recommend this version with Lawrence Kinlan as the narrator.

Who might you have cast as narrator instead of Laurence Kinlan?

The abridged version read by Aidan Gillan is so much better.

Any additional comments?

I bought this as I love Roddy Doyle's Barrytown trilogy and this is the unabridged version so thought I'd prefer it just as I remember reading it. However, Lawrence Kinlan spoiled it for me. A lot of the content is made up of the songs the band perform and the sounds from the instruments but Kinlan just roars out the lot. Just so over the top and he really isn't a singer by any means. I bought the abridged version narrated by Aidan Gillan and he is excellent. He lets the text speak for itself without making a meal of it and his singing and the sounds from the instruments are measured and easy to listen to.

Kinlan narrates another Roddy Doyle's book, The Guts and does a great job but that has virtually no actual songs. The one he does read is really very good and he seems to have calmed down considerably.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

F******great....

.... portrait of the life of a soul band in Dublin, last century. The film was terrific but the book is gentler, simpler, more intimate, worth visiting. You're right there, a fly on the wall, singing along. Beautifully read, recited, rhythm pulsate throughout.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Shouty, bad singing and no plot

I only listened to this to the end because it was on a Top 100 Books to Read Before You Die poster. I wish I hadn’t bothered. There seems no point to this book- there’s no story or plot and the words mostly just consist of dialogue and singing. And the singing is awful. And the swearing. Reading the actual book might be better, but do not listen to this audiobook unless you want your ears ringing with coarsely sung expletives and you don’t mind wasting 3 hours of your life.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Amazing book, truly awful singing.

I don’t understand why a narrator was chosen who sings so badly… it was very jarring and really ruined the listening experience.

I’ve watched the film many times and wanted to read the book, as I like Doyle’s other works and the book and story themselves are 5 star.

I’d hope audible re-records with an appropriate narrator.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Really didn't enjoy this

I downloaded this to help me sleep so as you can imagine it definitely didn't work, all the annoying singing was diabolical just irritating noise,id been told the van was brilliant but since its the sequel to the commitments I had to listen to this first . It's a rare occurrence for me to be happy when I come to the end of a book or in this case audible story but when this was finished I was so relieved, it was a total waste of time and im happy its finished and I definitely wouldn't recommend it

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!