Captivated by You

A Conclusion Would have been good.

It was just more of the same thing and nothing new. I wanted to like it, and while I didn't hate it, I'm left feeling annoyed that there's going to be another one. Just starting to seem more and more like money making scheme to be stretching out the story that doesn't have enough to be a huge series book, thus sort of losing the ART of novel. That's my opinion, I'm sure it was a delight to others. I'm not sure if I'm interested enough to get the next one when it comes.

25 of 26 people found this review helpful

Rollercoaster Ride

I am unsure on how to rate this book. I really liked the book but I am emotionally drained from listening to it. I was so invested in the characters and the story line and the hits kept on coming. I am trying to be objective considering the fact that it is the 4th in a 5 book series so I knew there would be no satisfaction at the end.
The books spans over a 3 week period in their relationship so it can't be resolved. If you understand the process of healing from sexual abuse you will get what she was getting at. She needed to develop that side of Gideon POV and that process is emotional and difficult to get through. Having said that, the Brett Kline thing was disappointing and I wish it would have been left out.
If you are invested in this series , you will enjoy this book but please be prepared for the roller coaster ride and understand that is purely character development and no significant advances in the storyline.
So in a direct appeal to Silvia Day. If you are at all reading your reviews. Thank you for showing the male perspective of a sexual abuse survivor and the consequences if you have not dealt with it. But please ........... for book # 5 let them both find their strength and claim their life. Finish their story line where it was worth for us to invest 3 years into this series. Skip the cookie cutter way out and span it over a few years not just weeks. If there ever was an extensive Happy Ending needed it would be in this series. Considering the time investment of the readers. I sincerely hope to see "One with you"published within a few months. Not years!!

The dual narration by Jill Redfield , Jeremy York was good. But Jill Redfield was so good with the delivery of the series I felt the added narrator was unnecessary.

72 of 79 people found this review helpful

I waited YEARS for this??? I want a refund,

Would you try another book from Sylvia Day and/or Jill Redfield and Jeremy York ?

Narrators were fine, and loved the first 2 Crossfire books,,,,then tolerated the 3rd, returning this fourth book

What do you think your next listen will be?

Not Sylvia Day

What about Jill Redfield and Jeremy York ’s performance did you like?

Jill has done a fantastic job with Ava and Gideon characters throughout series. Jeremy did a great job as well, but it was difficult to get used to his narration as Gideon when a listener has accustomed themselves to Jill's version. Jeremy is a fantastic narrator, don't get me wrong - it just changed Gideon in an unexpected way.

If you could play editor, what scene or scenes would you have cut from Captivated by You?

What a waste, So much intrigue and possibilities wasted. I would edit all but one chapter, condensing sentences from the very little new & interesting info given in this book. Im actually pissed that I waited so long for such a let down of a book to come out. I won't be waiting for the next, not worth it. Too many other author's like Kresley Cole, Karen marie Moning etc with books that actually MOVE a story forward.

Any additional comments?

Im getting a refund. I don't know if this is the authors fault or the editor trying to stretch out a story not meant for more than One book or Two. Think of all the interesting directions this book could've taken! Oh well, moving on.

25 of 27 people found this review helpful

didn't give any answers

Would you try another book from Sylvia Day and/or Jill Redfield and Jeremy York ?

Loved all the books but the last one .I waited along time to find out what was going to happen and it just didn't do it for me .having 2 different narrators didn't do it justice .If I would've known it was Going to be like that I wouldn't have spent the money so very disappointed

Would you ever listen to anything by Sylvia Day again?

Depends

You didn’t love this book... but did it have any redeeming qualities?

None

Any additional comments?

Refund

16 of 17 people found this review helpful

Happy about the addition of a male narrator

I've been procrastinating listening to this audiobook since November, but when Valentine's Day rolled around I decided that I was due for a guilty pleasure kind of title, and nothing fit the bill quite like Gideon & Ava Cross. I was also excited that this series FINALLY added a second narrator. As much as I've been enjoying Jill Redfield's performance, certain characters need that extra edge that only a male voice can bring, and I was hoping that Jeremy York would be up to the task. I wish that they'd read ALL of their respective personage's dialogues rather than just their specific chapters, but that's a common complaint of mine with dual readings. However, other than that, I had no issues with either of the narrators. My problems were with the lack of advancement on any front. Gideon & Ava are still struggling with the exact same obstacles only different versions of them, the story arc didn't really go anywhere, and the ending left me feeling like the next novel was going to be more of the same. CAPTIVATED BY YOU was like watching a dog try to catch its tail; painful and an exercise in futility.

7 of 7 people found this review helpful

FILLER....Only needed 2 pages..the rest all FILLER

Talk about needless useless details. The only parts of this story actually revelent could have only filed 2 pages Max. The rest of the book was absolute useless crap.

Way to go publishing company for taking a 3 book series and making the author stretch it to 5 books all for the sake of your greedy wallets. It absolutely shows!!! Lost yet another reader and your profits. I will not invest any more $ or time into this series.

5 of 5 people found this review helpful

I am so disapointed!!!

Would you try another book from Sylvia Day and/or Jill Redfield and Jeremy York ?

Sylvia Day - yes.... Jill Redfield - yes.... Jeremy York - no.

If you’ve listened to books by Sylvia Day before, how does this one compare?

It doesn't!!!

Who would you have cast as narrator instead of Jill Redfield and Jeremy York ?

Jill Redfield ONLY!!!!!!!

Do you think Captivated by You needs a follow-up book? Why or why not?

It needs to be re-done by only one narrator. Jill Redfield!

Any additional comments?

I wonder if the people that makes audio books listen to them? When there is a series of books KEEP THE SAME NARRATOR!!!! When there are multiple narrators it's like jumping from one book to another when the narrators change. In this case the first two books were read by Jill Redfield and she did a great job. You get use to her voice and the sound of the different charterers she uses. It's easy to follow. In the third book a second narrator was added which made the book sound completely different than the first two. It was difficult to follow because every other chapter would change narrators. With all due respect to male narrators I never buy a book read by a male narrator. To me when a male tries to do a female voice he just sounds gay. It doesn't work! In my opinion this book was totally ruined by adding a male narrator.

4 of 4 people found this review helpful

Another Great GidEva Story!

Would you consider the audio edition of Captivated by You to be better than the print version?

No, I enjoy them both. I love jumping between the audio and print versions.

What other book might you compare Captivated by You to and why?

The closest is the Breathless series by Maya Banks and of course Fifty Shades of Grey by EL James.

What about Jill Redfield and Jeremy York ’s performance did you like?

I love it when the separate genders are handled by the two separate narrators, it is more authentic and enjoyable. Especially for narrators who engage the listener in the story.

Was there a moment in the book that particularly moved you?

Yes there were several, and I will not go into great detail of them in order to avoid any spoiler alerts.

Any additional comments?

Well let me start off by saying I loved it. This was a long time wait and highly anticipated, and as is the norm I devoured it in one day. With that said.....


At first I was disappointed that there were still so many lingering issues with Eva, it was my understanding that the end of the series were going to concentrate on working through Gideon's issues. Though I am happy that the lingering issues was cleaned up nicely and quickly. Gideon's issues..... wow, there were so many but I must say the handling of Gid and his issues are progressing nicely and realistically.

And let me just say I am LOVING the new format of jumping between Eva and Gideon's POV, it is so refreshing to get the male's POV. And in such a way that the male does not come off too effeminate, which I have read more and more recently. It is very nice to get inside Gid's head.

Finally, when I finished my recent re-read of Bared, Reflected and Entwined I was officially joined in the "Cary is a douche" club, and sadly after this book I still am. Yeah he came off a little better, but no I am not feeling him and his narcissistic ways at all.

With all that said, this was WELL WORTH THE WAIT and I look forward to the conclusion of Eva and Gideon's story in One with You. Though I will not lie and say I really want it to end. Watching these two grow together has been a journey that I have loved.

8 of 9 people found this review helpful

Should have stuck to just Jill Redfield

What did you like best about Captivated by You? What did you like least?

Why in the world would they add this second narrator in the fourth book of the series. Jill Redfield did both characters best. I found the male narrator awful. Hope they do not screw up and do this for the fifth book.

What was your reaction to the ending? (No spoilers please!)

Glad there will be another book.

What did you like about the performance? What did you dislike?

Hated male narrator. Should have stuck to just Jill Redfield! She was perfect doing Gideon and Eva.

Was Captivated by You worth the listening time?

Hated male narrator.

3 of 3 people found this review helpful

What in the world

This was weird and nothing happened. I'm not sure what the point of the book was.

3 of 3 people found this review helpful