Not what you think it's going to be

This has often been dubbed as a grown up Harry Potter, which I think is utter bull. This is a fantasy book with a magical school however the part that makes it unique has nothing to do with learning magic at all.

I hated the main protagonist as a person but loved him as a character (if that makes any sense). He starts out completely self absorbed but I think the books' strength lies in telling you why he's such an ass. It explores some really important things about most people's dissatisfaction with the world, no matter what they gain or achieve. If anything it uses fantasy as a setting for some really awesome character development and exploration.

I do hope audible adds the second and third books.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

The love child of Lewis and Salinger

Careful...spoilers...ish

This post modern flurry into fantasy is an enjoyable, if not a cynical look at what would happen if Narnia was invaded by this current depraved generation. Of course they never use the name, for legal reasons I expect, however anyone who is even remotely familiar with Lewis' fantasy saga will see the parallels. The protagonist, Quentin Coldwater, owes more than a little to Holden Caufield and it has the same dry, broken view of this world that Salinger so vividly created.

There are some truly wonderful sequences. The reader spends almost a full chapter as a goose and it is delicious. There is also some fantasy fulfillment in the Narnia like world that bring a grotesque and gritty version of the Lewis stories most of us have imagined at some point in our lives.


On my first reading I struggled to connect to the characters, I am not as cynical as they, however this has become one of my favorite series and Quentin lives in a deep place in my heart

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

nope ... didn't like it ...

struggled to finish ... just found it very whiney, couldn't relate to the characters and found them a little spoilt bratish 😕

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

How unique! Loved it =)

I really enjoyed this book, touched on a few adult themes that I enjoyed and most characters acted in very realistic and believable ways which I enjoyed. Quentin is a bit of a whiney b*tch sometimes but he's an interesting character. A few twists and turns that I didn't anticipate and I can't wait to listen to the next one!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

bring the speed up <br />

found the naration a little slow and the speed works better at 1.15x the speed. everything else is great

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Excellent

Definitely worth your time, an excellent series! It gave me fresh perspectives on depression which has helped me a lot.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Where are the rest?

I enjoyed this book, it's a bit Narnia/Harry Potter but where are the others from the series? I feel like I've been left hanging.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

A rather disappointing, derivative fantasy

I’ll be honest. I couldn’t bring myself to finish this book. I suspect an oft mentioned missing character is the main ‘villain’, but I don’t care enough to find out. I made it three quarters of the way, hoping that the author would move beyond a self-indulgent post-modern pastiche of CS Lewis and JK Rowling. He didn’t. The concept was interesting, the execution dull. The characters were flat and made inconsistent decisions, that served only to move the plot on, not develop them as characters. Overall, it could have been much better and I wanted to enjoy it , but it wasn’t and I didn’t. The Rotherweird books are much more interesting modern fantasy.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Good first half, rest feels rushed

I wanted to read this book series as I read it was ‘Harry Potter for adults’. I did’t find it as compelling as Harry Potter though. The first half of the book had a nice slow pace were you and the characters come to learn how the magic works, after which the final on the magic school were rushed to finish in a couple of chapters.

Then the adventure begins, but there’s a bit too much happening for my liking, including many subsequent fights and somewhat random adventures.

Nevertheless, Mark Bramhall had a nice voice and tried to make the characters sounds distinguishable.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Sooooooo GOOOOD!!

Amazing! brilliantly narrated and keeps you hooked to the very end. a must read/listen :)
.
the TV series is also brilliant.. different, but brilliant.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!