This post was originally published on Audible.com.
Note: Text has been lightly edited for clarity and does not match audio exactly.
Alanna McAuliffe: Hi, listeners. I'm Audible Editor Alanna McAuliffe, and today I have the tremendous privilege of sitting down with creative powerhouse David Byrne. Byrne is perhaps best known for his work in music, co-founding and fronting the legendary New Wave band Talking Heads, before going on to continue innovating with sound in his solo career and collaborations.
But Byrne's artistic pursuits are certainly not limited to music endeavors. He's a true multidisciplinary multihyphenate, dabbling in everything from line drawings to stage productions to the written word. To that end, we're here today to discuss his latest book, Sleeping Beauties: Why Good Ideas Go Dormant and How They Wake Up, a truly fascinating and deeply curious history of innovation and creation that examines the process of mass forgetting and the possibility of rediscovery. David, thank you so much for being here today.
David Byrne: Thank you for having me on.
It is an honor and a privilege, truly. To get started, I just wanted to give you the opportunity to flesh out the core lens of Sleeping Beauties for our listeners. In the introduction, you detail how this thesis originated with your discovery of a scientific research paper that detailed this phenomenon. Can you share a bit about the idea of what a “sleeping beauty” is and what inspired you to expand this notion to cover all disciplines?
Yeah, I stumbled on this paper quite by accident, but I loved the title, “Sleeping Beauties,” and it went on to be about something like, "Yes, how can we discover them?" I immediately realized that this was something that didn't just apply to academic science papers, where you're kind of measuring interest in the number of citations and things like that. I realized, "Oh, this applies to, well, everything. Music, literature, economics, everything you can think of."
What it is, is something that gets some attention, whether it's an artist or musician who is really popular in their lifetime, and then kind of fades from view and becomes obscure or forgotten. Maybe not entirely forgotten, but goes way down. And then years, decades, centuries later, it's rediscovered and someone finds it and goes, "That is exactly what we're interested in right now" or "Now that makes sense to us." It got maybe suppressed for various reasons, and so these things become rediscovered. I started collecting these examples when I'd stumble on them. I'd read a review of maybe an art exhibit or whatever, and there might be a sentence that said, "And Caravaggio was forgotten for 200, 300 years," or something like that. And they'd go on to describe the paintings and things, and I go, "Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. You've buried the lead.” For me, at least. What happened for those years? Why did that happen and how did he get rediscovered? That would lead me down a rabbit hole and I'd try and figure out, "Okay, how can I find out that information?" Some of the things are things that are kind of surprising. Or you might go, "No."
I definitely had that exact reaction several times listening to your book.
Yeah, and that was intentional, that I'd pick some things where you'd go, "I can't believe that was ever unpopular." Because we tend to think that what we know, what we like now is, well, it's the “we know better now.” We like to think that. But when you look at all these examples, you have to go, "Well, wait a minute. Are we doing the same thing now that people did in the past? Are there things that we have kind of pushed aside or have forgotten or made cause to be obscure?" And it has to be. There has to be things like that. So, after I started collecting these examples, a person I was working with had a suggestion, "What if you focus on the way that they were rediscovered as opposed to just how they were forgotten?"
Which is kind of ultimately how the book is organized. It unfolds over these six parts that each cover a method of reawakening, which I thought was a fascinating organizing principle.
Well, thank you. Yeah, I thought, "Oh, that's a great idea, that we want to know how to find them." The reasons why they got forgotten tend to be the same, the kind of usual suspects: racism, sexism, institutional foot dragging, or hubris, or all those kinds of things. I just thought, "Yeah, that's just a depressing part of the story." The part that might allow us to find the ones that are still missing is if we can understand the ways that they were rediscovered.
So, you landed on these six methods of rediscovery, we'll call them. Can you briefly map those out for our listeners?
One of them is accidents. Some things are rediscovered completely by accident. That's not something you can use as a tool, really. So, we'll move on from that one. Another one is champions. A lot of things, whether it's authors or artists or various other kinds of ideas, had someone who rediscovered it for themselves and then decided "No, the world needs to know about this." And sometimes it's very selfless. They themselves have nothing to gain by championing this writer or artist or whatever it might be. Sometimes they do have something to gain, but sometimes nothing. So, that's one. Another one is changing cultural mores. So, things that were difficult to accept become kind of easier to accept when the culture changes. What are the other ones?
Well, there's war and catastrophe.
Oh, catastrophe is kind of divided into war and other catastrophes. That's a good one. Sadly, but it seems to be true, often it takes a catastrophe of some sort, or a war, which is another kind of catastrophe, to give us a second look at things. Oddly, it's not always the thing that you might think of. It's not always directly related to the catastrophe. When I was reading about why was Moby-Dick and [Herman] Melville rediscovered, a lot of what I've found was that it was the result of World War I. That World War I caused a lot of people to question, "Who are we that we could do this? What's our psychological makeup? Do we have monsters inside of us?” And this was a book that was there, had been forgotten, that kind of dealt with a lot of those things, kind of what is our nature and what are we made of and how kind of crazy can we be? It suddenly had relevance because the context, the culture, had changed.
The listener has to feel that it's coming from somewhere inside, that you're actually feeling and telling them the story, whether it's song lyrics or a page from a book.
As you've already nodded to, this work is truly impressive in its scope. It covers everything from Bach to black holes to The Great Gatsby. How did you ultimately decide which examples of reawakening to include, and were there any beauties that didn't quite make the cut that you'd like to share?
How did they make the cut? There were some that I was very excited about. One was an Einstein paper that had been kind of pushed aside and poo-pooed and this and that. He had issues with quantum theory, so it was really interesting. The more I looked into it, I thought, "This would be cool if even Einstein gets forgotten at some point." But he didn't. He didn't really get forgotten. And with repeated tries to test out whether his questions were valid or not, it was eventually discovered, and this is maybe 40 years after his paper, that he was wrong. That “spooky action from a distance” does exist. And entanglement and all this kind of stuff, the things he said, "That can't be, that can't be." But it was kind of eventually proven, "Yes, it does happen. Sorry." The fact that it was disproved wasn't the reason. It was the fact that it was just not forgotten enough.
So, I couldn't include that one. There was penicillin. There was a long gap between discovery of this mold that was kind of destroying the bacteria, or whatever it was, in a petri dish, and when it actually got developed to be something that could be used as a medicine. But it was more just the time spent on research and funding and things like that. It was never really rejected or forgotten.
So, there were stories like that. I've been doing some talks recently, as one does to promote a book, and so I've been telling some stories. I did some of the research, but at the time, I thought, "I've got enough for the book. I don't need to do more. I can make my point. I have examples in the different categories.” One of them was the zero, which was known in Indian and Arabic societies for a long time, but was rejected when it was introduced to the West. It was rejected and they stuck with Roman numerals. They rejected Arabic numbers and the zero.
Yeah, it's the kind of Eurocentrism there that really reminds me of your inoculation chapter as well.
Yes.
These kind of Western sleeping beauties.
Yes. There's quite a bit of that, where one culture, sometimes in our case, the West, rejects something that's been known in another culture for quite a while. And when I've been doing talks, the last one I tell is the story of the clitoris. Again, known in certain cultures, and in other cultures it would be known, recognized, known what it does, and then forgotten. And then remembered again and rediscovered. Needless to say, half the population of the planet probably knew all about it. But of course, these are men, and so it comes and goes. So, yeah, that's a fun one.
I do have to say that what wound up in the book is intriguing all its own. You definitely got plenty of examples in there that delighted and surprised, to say the least. I never expected myself to say this, but I haven't been able to stop talking about concrete since I finished your book.
Yeah, I haven't seen John Wilson's movie [The History of Concrete].
I haven't either yet, but it seemed very fortuitous timing. Were there any particular beauties that you covered that stood out for you, for how unexpected or surprising their histories were?
There were some, like Vera Rubin, the woman who gets credit for discovering dark matter and how much of it there is in the universe. She was determined she was not going to be pushed down by all these male astronomers and things like that. There was a great story where she got the offer to work, I think it was Mount Palomar, using this telescope. It was the biggest telescope in the world at that point, so she was thrilled. This is a dream come true. She goes there and the guys say, "Well, you know, Ms. Rubin, we work at night and we don't have facilities for women." So, she took a piece of paper and cut out a little shape of a woman and stuck it on one of the bathroom doors and says, "Now you do."
There's part of her story where her breakthrough, her realization of what was happening in the cosmos, came through these drawings that she did. Rather than just looking at the numbers and all this kind of thing, she started drawing it out, making illustrations of what she was seeing. And then it was like a light bulb moment, and she goes, "Ah, now I can see it." I thought, "Oh, this is really good." Often, when someone translates something from one medium to another, the pattern gets revealed. When you turn whatever data into a drawing, you go, "Oh, now it's easy to see what's going on there." It sometimes takes that kind of transfer to allow us to see something.
Yeah, and on the topic of patterns, a kind of recurring dichotomy that I found truly compelling and really quite central to your book were these countertheories of Darwinist competition and a more cooperative symbiotic view of interdependency. It's a thought that's echoed in your acknowledgements as well, where you write, quote, "Nothing happens in a vacuum, and no one works alone." Is that spirit of collaboration something you've always so firmly believed in?
It might have been something I hoped to believe in. It seemed more hopeful than a dog-eat-dog world. And it turned out, yeah, there were various people who were in this book—Lynn Margulis talking about symbiotic relationships and symbiotic unions of different life forms that create a new life form, which was rejected because Darwin's idea, which is wonderful, said that evolution can only happen through random mutations, and the branches of the evolutionary tree can grow and expand and new species develop that way. And she was saying, "No, they can exist by joining horizontally. Something from one branch can connect with something in a completely different branch, and you get something new like that." And that didn't go down really well. But it was essentially saying, "No, how you would define a symbiotic relationship is a kind of cooperative thing where both entities benefit in some way."
Then there was the Russian anarchist Kropotkin, who said something similar. He did a lot of studies in Siberia and in other places, and he said that, “Yes, the same thing happens socially, that animals sometimes help each other when it's in a very harsh environment.” Sometimes, small groups of guilds, of businesses and artisans and things like that, kind of work together in different ways. He was also saying that sometimes cooperation is a more successful strategy than competition. Now, not always, but sometimes, yes.
Yeah, and that felt like a very significant thing to underscore, particularly in the moment that we're living in right now. Just to underscore the significance of collaboration and mutual aid was something that I found really special about this book.
Yes, it's very heartening, especially these days.
So, you mentioned Moby-Dick earlier, and literature comes up multiple times throughout Sleeping Beauties. You have a chapter on Kafka and Faulkner, and you make reference to contemporary paradigm shifters, too, like Ed Yong's wonderful An Immense World. You also mentioned that you are in a book club. In the spirit of championing art and ideas, I'm wondering if there are any books you've read or listened to recently that you'd like to recommend.
I'm in a book club with some friends and acquaintances that focuses on fiction, and I'm not a big fiction reader. A year or two ago when I ran into some of these friends, they said, "Oh, we're starting a book club on fiction." I said, "Oh, can I join?" Because it's not something I naturally gravitate to. I gravitate to nonfiction. And so I thought, "Oh, this will be good." And sometimes it is, but not always. Sometimes there's a book that is really well-known that I never read back in the day or whatever, and then I read it and I go, "I don't think this one stands the test of time. It's not working for me."
It's a pretty crazy world out there. I realized a while back that focusing on the negative is just going to get you more tightly wound and doesn't necessarily lead to a solution.
But there's other ones that have. There's one called, I think it's Half of a Yellow Sun that I read. It was about the Biafran War in Nigeria. That was really good. There were a few others that I thought, "Oh, okay, this is why I'm doing this."
I mean, our listeners would be very happy to hear your nonfiction recommendations as well, if you have any favorites that you'd like to share.
Oh, well, some of them, not all, some of them are kind of peripherally related to this book. One that I read recently is called Lost Enlightenment, and it's about Central Asia, mainly during what we would call the Middle Ages. And that was when Central Asia was the center of scientific and philosophy and all these kind of things. Greece and Rome had declined, but Central Asia picked up the ball, so to speak. All these different centers, different towns and places, that were really very active and very influential. That knowledge got passed on, and sometimes to Arabic centers and other places, and then sometimes to Europe. It was fascinating because now we think, "What happened?" Some of those areas, like Afghanistan or whatever you think, that was kind of the center of intellectual inquiry at the time. It's one of those amazing things where you would never have imagined it, but there it is. So, that was a lot of fun.
There's another one that I mentioned in the book. I think it's called The Catalogue of Shipwrecked Books, and it's about Christopher Columbus's bastard son. He'd gone on a couple of his dad's voyages, and so you get a little bit of that, and his dad sounds like a real maniac. But then he decides to stay in Seville and amass the biggest library in the world. He wants to collect everything. So, it kind of echoes the internet or AI or whatever. He sends out emissaries all over the known world at that point, and just to buy everything that was printed. He wanted to have it all, and he did, but sometimes the ships that were carrying the books back to him sank, and those ones went missing.
I read—it falls between fiction and nonfiction—I read a book called The Maniac, speaking of maniacs, which is a book about John von Neumann, the guy who was an early inventor of computers, game theory, who was involved with the atomic bomb, all kinds of stuff. It's written by this Chilean author [Benjamín Labatut] who takes real-life people, but he kind of fictionalizes it a bit. He's writing about it and you realize, "Oh, these are things that no one could have possibly known what they were feeling or what they did that day or what they had for lunch or whatever." So, it poses this really interesting question, because it feels like fact but it's fiction, so it falls in between in that way.
Interesting. Yeah, blurs the lines there. Now, just hearing the enthusiasm in your voice when you talk about those stories and how they affected you really reminded me of a quote from Kafka that you share within the book. He wrote that, quote, "A book must be the axe for the frozen sea within us." I'm wondering, in reflecting on art that has informed or moved you recently, do you agree with that sentiment? Do you think that art has a responsibility to move, affect, or challenge audiences?
Oh, absolutely. Absolutely. I mean, it doesn't have to say “everything you know is wrong,” but if it can show us a new way of looking at things, and fiction or nonfiction can do that, then that's really something incredible.
Coming back to Sleeping Beauties, among these practical tools for rediscovery that you offer in the book, you note we should, "Follow the young, the persistent, and amateurs,” underscoring that they're driven by curiosity and gifted with fresh eyes and ears. It stood out to me because you walk that walk, too, collaborating with younger artists like Hayley Williams, St. Vincent, and Olivia Rodrigo, and working with nonprofits that uplift youth voices and perspectives. What have you learned from working alongside and passing the mic to younger generations?
It's always inspiring. They're maybe not as stuck in their ways as some of my peers. Not that all my peers are stuck in their ways, but yeah, maybe they didn't come up with the same sets of assumptions. So, they're trying things or working in a slightly different way. Sometimes they're fairly open-minded, because, again, they're not set in their ways like, “This is what I do and I don't do anything else.” It's been really invigorating for me. Really, it's a lot of fun.
As a lifelong artist yourself, you've explored a wide range of media, including music, visual art, theater, filmmaking, and the written word. Does your approach differ for each format?
Yes, to some extent it'll differ for each format, but I think there's a kind of crossover and there's parallels. I think, often, the creative process is kind of similar no matter where it happens. You have this period where you're just kind of randomly fishing around and trying different things out. And then something starts to jell and you then have to follow that and go, "Okay, this is where it wants to go. It's telling me and I have to listen."
There could be periods where there's these kind of insights that point you in one direction or another, and then there's periods where it's just a kind of slog of admin work. Which is not to be discounted. In my own work, I've found that sometimes the admin work is the prep that allows the insights to happen. That once you've organized things a bit, you can go, "Oh, now I can see where this is going."
Well, adding to the list of art forms that you've mastered, you also narrated the audiobook for Sleeping Beauties, which I have to say made it all the more engaging. It's a listening experience that I've described as sitting in on a lecture series with your university's hippest, most beloved professor. It was just wonderful.
Oh, that's so good to hear, because I'm not a professional reader. There are people who are.
Oh, it was a delight, though. You can hear the curiosity really comes alive in your voice, and I think that makes it so compelling. It was wonderful.
You know we have directors when we do that. There was a young woman who was kind of my director there and was really helpful. Not just when I bungled a word pronunciation or something like that, but just kind of making sure the sense and enthusiasm came through.
Often, the solution to some problem that we're having might lie with something that somebody did in another culture, and it might have been something they did centuries ago.
Right. Well, you're obviously no stranger to a recording booth, but what was different about the process of narrating as opposed to laying down tracks for music?
There's a similarity in that you've got this kind of script, the words in front of you, or in some cases it's the song lyrics and the melody and all that. Now you have to bring it to life. It's not enough to just rote pronounce the words. The listener has to feel, and I'm not sure I succeeded in this everywhere, but the listener has to feel that it's coming from somewhere inside, that you're actually feeling and telling them the story, whether it's song lyrics or a page from a book.
Yeah, I have to say as a fan of your music and as a fan of Sleeping Beauties, I think you achieved that in both formats.
Thank you.
Absolutely. So, we touched on this a bit earlier, that we're living through this moment in time that can feel kind of overwhelming in its hopelessness for so many people. Yet, I found that your work is punctuated by this real resistance to cynicism. How do you maintain that outlook?
It's not always easy. It's a pretty crazy world out there. I realized a while back that focusing on the negative is just going to get you more tightly wound and doesn't necessarily lead to a solution. You have to recognize when something's not good or not working, but yeah, that doesn't necessarily lead to a solution. I found that a more hopeful, positive attitude and more curiosity about an openness to "Where can this go? What can I do?" Whether it's in this kind of book or I have an online kind of magazine, I guess, that I've founded called Reasons to Be Cheerful. And that runs a new news story every weekday of somebody somewhere who's found a solution to something. I thought we'd run out of material a while ago, but—tribute to the editors—they're still finding things.
On the topic of progress and positive change, something I found really resonant within Sleeping Beauties was something you mentioned earlier, this regular refrain that historically marginalized groups can be particularly subject to cycles of rebirth and rediscovery. Do you believe that social progress and an ongoing shedding of prejudice are key to keeping good ideas awake?
Yes. That often the solution to some problem that we're having at the moment might lie with something that somebody did in another culture, and it might have been something they did centuries ago, which is a little hard for us to kind of humble ourselves and go, "Ooh, they figured this out a long time ago. So, yeah, maybe that's the road we should take."
That's a hard thing to do, a hard thing for people to accept, that they can't solve everything for themselves sometimes, or that somebody else might have had the idea they're looking for but it's coming from another culture or another place.
Yeah, absolutely. What you just mentioned also reminds me of this absolutely brilliant line in Sleeping Beauties that I loved, which was, "It's the hubris of the living to believe they are better and smarter than the dead." I'm interested to hear if you have any further thoughts on what we can do to see past what you call that “blinding of contemporary consensus” to instead recognize both the subjectivity of time and the possibility that perhaps our ancestors had some pretty good ideas of their own.
Wow. I don't know if I have any specific tools for that, but in general, yes, we are biased. We tend to believe that, well, a number of things: that knowledge accumulates and therefore what we know now, what the internet knows, what we know, must be better than what people knew before. And it's just not always the case. It is sometimes, but it's not always the case. And it kind of takes an open mind and some curiosity to see, "Oh, this thing that somebody did ages ago might be better than what we're doing now." You really have to take a deep breath and humble yourself and be willing to accept that. We tend to think that we're smarter than everyone who came before us, which is a big assumption. We don't know exactly how they behaved, but I think it's been said that Neanderthals had larger brains than we do, and you have to wonder, maybe they were better at some stuff than we are?
So, it all comes down to this core, which is echoed time and again in Sleeping Beauties, which is just: remain open-minded and receptive to ideas, whether they're coming from the past or a different culture, or within your own bubble.
Oh, yes, or within another discipline, or a young person, as opposed to your peers or whatever. Someone with a more inquisitive, more open mind down the hall might have the answer that you've been looking for.
Yeah, and it all goes back to collaboration. So, if I may, I'd like to end our chat on a bit of a hypothetical. Let's say that centuries down the line, something from your own oeuvre has gone to sleep. If this interview became a time capsule for someone rediscovering David Byrne, what message would you want them to take away?
Whoa. I might say, "Here's something that maybe, as it is, is not something that's gonna be relevant and useful to you, but maybe as an allegory, thought of in a different way from a different point of view, it's going to be something that might be useful to you somewhere in the future."
Well, David, thank you so much for taking the time to be here today. It's been such an immense honor and delight chatting with you.
Thank you. Thank you. I'm glad it all worked out.
And listeners, you can get Sleeping Beauties: Why Good Ideas Go Dormant and How They Wake Up, written and read by David Byrne on Audible now.







