Singer/songwriter William Hamilton disappeared 25 years ago and now two true-crime podcasters want to solve the mystery. Adam and Simon uncover a sensational new piece of evidence in the cold case and set their course for the Hamilton estate.

Adam, Simon and Lilly arrive at Wisteria to interview Gloria Hamilton, but find a woman in the throes of dementia. Their access is restricted by William’s sister Rachel and his eldest daughter Norah, until a photograph raises questions that only Gloria can answer.

With Norah on-side, Adam and Simon are granted the first interview with Gloria since her husband disappeared. A trip across the mountains solves one mystery but raises plenty of difficult questions – and then an intruder is found on the property.

Norah agrees to be interviewed about William Hamilton, unexpectedly finding a rapport with Simon that illuminates her troubled childhood. Lost in the past, Gloria lets slip a name that sets Simon on a new direction of inquiry.

Norah, Lilly, Adam and Simon hit the road in search of a woman who may hold the key to William’s disappearance. But away from the tension of Wisteria, Norah and Simon’s relationship verges into surprising new territory.

Following the revelations of Zelda Boucher, the group rush back to interview Gloria again before Rachel can stop them. As tensions boil over, somebody sets out on a desperate course of action in their search for the truth.

Decades of lies and resentment erupt in the grounds of Wisteria. A frenzied push for answers sees Norah discovering more than she’d ever hoped – but at what cost?

Months after that fateful night, Lilly Hamilton takes the reigns of the podcast to examine the intersection of truth, ambition and legacy that has shaped the story of her family.