(P)2008 Audio Book Contractors, Inc.
A good story - although not on a par with the Barchester Chronicles or Palliser Novels. Sadly, Flo Gibson's reading detracted from my enjoyment. In my opinion she was not a good choice of reader for a Trollope novel. The accent was wrong and much of the humour was lost. I would love to have heard the book read by Timothy West.
I can only agree with the above review.A good book spoilt by the narrater whose monotonous tone and lack of characterisation did not make the story come alive to the listener.
If you like Trollope read this. Reading not of standard of excellent Timothy West but good effort and story highly enjoyable.
"Claire's Two Lovers"
This gentle story goes leisurely along as if there was no reason in the world to hurry. Indeed, there doesn't even seem to be a foreordained conclusion. Trollope writes as though he had no idea what was to come next; as if he was just as surprised as the reader. The story seems to ramble almost aimlessly but what delicious aimlessness. I think despite appearances, Trollope knew exactly what would come next; the seeming ramble is careful craft, an unsurpassed talent. This is a satisfying saunter through a gentle country romance albeit somewhat awkwardly with two charming suitors. Ah, but unexpected complications, setbacks, right angle turns and forks in the road are the forte of a Trollope story and makes him as fresh today as when first published in the mid 1800's.
"Trollope writes a love story"
Trollope was himself a bit dismissive of this unassuming work , maybe, because he did not juggle several dynamic stories in The Belton Estate, as he does in most of his novels. Nevertheless, it is a very affecting portrayal of two people "made for each other". The simplicity of the tale allowed Trollope to fully develop the excruciatingly annoying behavior of the characters who stand in the way of the happiness of the lovers. Trollope is a master at portraying the ordinary pettiness that causes most of life's problems. The Belton Estate, modest, but satisfying.
"Finishing up the Trollope novels"
I have been listening to the Anthony Trollope novels, mainly narrated by Timothy West. This story is very much along the lines of what Trollope liked to write about, but the quavers and loops of Flo Gibson are very off-putting. This was narrated before Audible really existed, but it is a huge disappointment to hear a generally good story get such a quirky performance. I will certainly think twice before I download another book narrated by Flo Gibson!
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.