Wildwood
The Wildwood Chronicles, Book I
Ürünler eklenemedi
Sepete ekleme başarısız oldu.
İstek Listesine ekleme başarısız oldu.
İstek listesinden kaldırma başarısız oldu.
Kütüphaneye ekleme başarısız oldu
Podcast takip edilemedi
Podcast takibi bırakma başarısız oldu.
3 ay boyunca aylık £0,99
16,60£ karşılığında satın al
-
Seslendiren:
-
Amanda Plummer
-
Yazan:
-
Colin Meloy
NOW A MAJOR MOTION PICTURE FROM LAIKA, THE STUDIO BEHIND CORALINE
Prue McKeel is keeping out of trouble. Or trying to. Then her baby brother is abducted by crows and hauled off to the woods beyond the city. It is up to Prue to bring him back. On her mission she is plunged into the world of Wildwood and there she meets more trouble - and magic - than she ever thought possible.
©2012 Colin MeloyEleştirmen yorumları
The book itself is fairly standard fantasy fare for young kids. The Decemberists (the band the author is lead singer of) are one of my favourite bands so I had high expectations of how much poetry and beauty would be in the prose. There are points at which it felt very Colin Meloy, and others where I was bored nearly to tears. Unfortunately some of the “very Colin Meloy” moments are the use of the word “gypsy” as a weird mix of exoticisation and slur at least twice (not counting the reference to a folk song), which feels very on-brand for Colin but not something I would want my literal children to internalise.
I do think the book is really long for what it is and the world-building, while fun, isn’t up to scratch for a 15 hour kids book from 2011. It feels under-edited and a bit boring in spots, I always wonder with celebrity authors, even people like J K Rowling, whether the editor is scared to tell them “it’s too long bro”. Who knows.
Perhaps due to the saccharine narration but the children sometimes seem like naive 6 year olds and sometimes seem like teens. The protagonist’s response to her baby brother being kidnapped is to worry about whether she’s going to get grounded for longer than a week which is just unhinged for a preteen. Any ten year old would be beside themself in that situation, not because of TV rights or groundings but because their literal baby brother has been carried away from them. At one point a 12 year old boy kills multiple real human people with a cannon and is just… kinda… fine about it? I get that sometimes emotions are dampened in kids books but, again, I won’t be letting my kids read this.
The narration interacts with Colin’s sometimes-clunky sentence structure in weird ways and the narrator will often leave a pause where none is required or just completely blow through what I assume is supposed to be em-dashes? There are so many moments where I was left thinking “that’s the take you went with!?”
Can we stop the trend of getting Hollywood actors to narrate audiobooks? It’s a different job. Some can do it well but most times you are just better served getting a professional narrator on it. There were times where I thought “this feels like their first time narrating an audiobook” and maybe it was to be fair but it really could have done with a better narrator.
Awful accents and boring narration. Would not give to a child.
Bir sorun oluştu. Lütfen birkaç dakika sonra tekrar deneyin.
I felt I was for this very reason that her voice and performance matched the hipster, faux award, nerdy persona that was prevalent through the text. even the art work on and in the hard copy is a child like animation. The puposely imperfect childlike presentation in the narrative is simply, I feel, not an accidental flaw on Plummers part but a reflection on the entire body of work. I honestly don't feel like her accents were offensive (and I'm Irish!). I really loved this I've listened to it in its entirety at least 3 times and occasionally dip in and out of it when looking for a little light hearted day dreaming.. I WOULD LOVE TO SEE PART 2&3 RELEASED.
quirky and endearing.
Bir sorun oluştu. Lütfen birkaç dakika sonra tekrar deneyin.
As another reviewer said this book also skips in places.
Disappointing
Awful accents, but great story
Bir sorun oluştu. Lütfen birkaç dakika sonra tekrar deneyin.
The recording has stuttering and skips
Bir sorun oluştu. Lütfen birkaç dakika sonra tekrar deneyin.
Narnia but in America
Bir sorun oluştu. Lütfen birkaç dakika sonra tekrar deneyin.