On Halloween night 2016 in Sanford, Florida, a masked intruder entered a home on Hays Drive and fatally shot brothers Joseph Smith and Roland Deloatch while their mother was inside; nearly a decade later the case remains unsolved.

This episode examines the timeline, family accounts, police efforts and how the chaotic anonymity of Halloween may have helped a killer disappear, and urges anyone with information to come forward.

July 6, 1988: twelve-year-old Sarah Cherry disappears while babysitting in rural Maine and is found days later murdered. Evidence linked to local farmer Dennis Dechaine led to his conviction, but the case is still debated because of gaps and disputes in the timeline.

This episode walks the day through chronologically—calls, sightings, physical links, and the contested minutes—asking whether the remaining time gaps leave room for reasonable doubt or if the pieces still point to a clear answer.

Picture a respectable farmwife who used personal ads to lure lonely men—and possibly murdered them for money. Belle Gunness’s life in La Porte, Indiana, is a chilling tale of recurring insurance payouts, vanished suitors, and a farmhouse fire that left a headless corpse and a hundred questions.

This episode examines Belle’s pattern of suspicious deaths, the discovery of human remains on her property, and the enduring mystery: did she perish in the 1908 blaze or fake her death and vanish? Tune in for a deep dive into one of America’s most unsettling unsolved true-crime cases.