Paul will do just about anything to keep Rhees from leaving the island - including making a deal he's not sure he can keep. In exchange for giving up his Coitus Club groupies, he'll lead everyone to believe she's the first girlfriend he's ever had.
He doesn't know what it is that has him in awe of this cute, naïve, and all-around good girl, but she draws him in and inspires him to make some needed changes to his lifestyle. He's not even sure anyone can really change a lifetime of habit, circumstance, and genetics. You are who you are, of that he's sure. Isn't he?
Yet, when you're going through all the motions of being an intimate couple, pretending to be together is a fine line - and the line only gets fuzzier as time goes by. But it's all just pretend...