Excellent plots and subplots.

Enjoyed David Thorpe the narrator. He has really helped me to produce a good mind picture of each character. He enhances the story. Typical intricate plot, but that is why I like it. Am able to listen to this again and again. I regularly go through the whole collection every few years.
Haven’t found anything of the same standard of writing to compare. Language use excellent and no sex scenes or bad language included. Which just goes to prove that good entertainment can be achieved without such salacious material being included.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

One of the best!!!!

One of the best Matthew Bartholomew books. Gripping story and lots of fun! Had to laugh out loud many times! Brilliant!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

I couldn't turn it off

Another fantastic book by Susanna Gregory and awesomely narrated by the talented David Thorpe! definitely time spent well listening to 'To Kill Or Cure'

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Fascinating and intricate storyline.

Susanna Gregory's books are always extremely well written and this is no exception. The characters in the story are well drawn and Brother Michael, Matthew Batholomew, Cynric, Langella, Brother William and the rest of the Fellows from St Michaels are old friends. Putting the reader/listener into life in the 14th century makes it very real. This series of books always make good listening,[David Thorpe creates each part wonderfully]

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Falling back into old ways

Im wading through the whole series and the last three were a big improvement on the early ones.....but this one falls back into the old style of the early books. 95% of the book is made up of complex detective work to uncover the killer only for the last 30 pages to reveal someone totally different (much to the shock of our two intrepid sleuths). Don't get me wrong ,I like the books, the characterisations are good and you soon grow to like the main players (even to oddballs at the university) and the research is (usually good) but you lose interest in the detective work because, if you have read others in the series, you know it's all for nothing in the end.
This story was complex and looked at some interesting aspects of life in Cambridge in the 14th cent but unusually the research was poor in this book leading the reader to believe life was easy and jolly in the 14th cent . for most, it was not,(examples that stand out are, the happy husband and his prostitute wife and their 19 thriving children, the truth is anyone in the particularly dirty town of Cambridge at that time would be well above the average if 5 of the 20 children lived into there teens, but then again the doctor who is the main man in the book seems to cure 95% of all ailments so perhaps I'm wrong).
for the most part, the books are good at informing the reader about how life worked in this period but because so much of the research (even easy things) is wrong you don't know what to believe and what to ignore . Thinking about it the life in the university is pretty much always correct and life in town very often wrong. But I like the players and the books are easy listening while working so ill be pushing on towards the last in the series.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

One of the Best

This is possibly my favourite so far, working through from the beginning. They are always better in my opinion when the motley crew at Michael House are involved and in this story much time was spent there. Fair enough Clixby and Sutton were missing but Brother William was on form with his rabid hatred of Dominicans, whom he blames for everything with such uncompromising virulence that it always makes me laugh. Plenty of twists and turns and Matthew and Michael are as slow as ever but then with Matthew's naivety and basic goodness and Michael not being able to pass the Brazen George for some nosh and ale, it is no wonder. The usual high mortality rate but our intrepid duo plod on regardless, going round in circles whilst they occasionally manage to carry out their teaching roles. Death or no these books are such fun.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

Excellent

I thoroughly enjoyed this book, especially since the original narrator, David Thorpe, has returned. I feel like old friends had returned hearing the original accents of the members in the story and the original pronunciation of names.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

New Blood

Have just listened/read this in sequence order. This is an interesting enough tale, though found I missed the performer of the two previous novels in this series (Andrew Wincott). The novel will delight dedicated Matthew Bartholomew followers. Bringing in an outsider character new to Cambridge is an effective driver for the story. Given the size of Cambridge's population at the time there needed to be new blood introduced - to be spilt or not!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

written & performed as good as ever

the ever reliable pairing of author & narrator . the only negative being poor production & very distracting editing .

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

Oh thank goodness Thorpe is back!

I love David Thorpe’s performances and I am so glad he’s back in this book!
The other narrator was fine but not great. Thorpe is great. He is so good it sometimes feels like he can’t possibly be both Brother Michael and Bartholomew the voices are so different.
I enjoy his pacing too.
Susanna Gregory’s books a great. Formulaic but great. The perfect cozy medieval mystery. And a good narrator like David Thorpe makes them really shine!
These are listens I will come back to again and again.
I’m so frustrated with the Mathilde storyline though. She did what was right for her and Bartholomew is lame not to have just talked to her about his feelings and plans.
But to just up and vanish? Girl, why?!
So basically what I’m saying is, Mathilde, girl, call me. I just want to talk.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful