Collection of Short Stories Around One Family

I just finished listening to "The Twelve Tribes of Hattie" by Ayana Mathis and the book was mostly different from what I had expected.

Expected: A novel that revolves around the family founded by Hattie and her husband.

Got: A collection of loosely connected short stories around the life of Hattie and her children, always showing a short period of time during a period of 60 years.



Maybe I should say first that I hate short stories. So still rating this audio book with four out of five stars comes as a surprise to me, some of the credit is due to Adenrele Ojo, Bahni Turpin and Adam Lazarre-White outstanding performance as readers.



By picking different points of time between the 1920s and 1980s, Ayana Mathis shows some changes in American society, some politcal events and developments, as well as how Hattie's life is going on.



The book starts with Hattie as a teenaged mother, being worried about her sick twin babies who eventually die. Hattie and her husband have many children after the twins but their life and their children's lifes remain bleak, sometimes more sometimes less so. Sometimes caused by external factors, sometimes by the characters themselves.



If Hattie's children had played more of role in all "chapters", instead of only appearing in their dedicated episode, I would have enjoyed the book much more - this is why I am taking off one star.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

Wished it was longer

Would you try another book written by Ayana Mathis or narrated by the narrators?

Yes,

Would you be willing to try another book from Ayana Mathis? Why or why not?

Yes, but I was a little disappointed in the story, each chapter was so different as it concentrated on each of Hattie's offspring. But it was impossible to get into the story as it was only a relatively short window in each of their lives. I suppose you learned about Hattie through her children but I would have actually preferred to learn a bit more about each child!

A couple of the chapters were slightly boring and unfortunately took a few rewinds before they 'caught'. Others I could have listened to for hours if they had been a whole novel.

Despite this, The book was well written, so I would try this author again.

What does the narrators bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you had only read the book?

The narrators were brilliant, I could clearly identify who was who, I could picture the characters all the more better

Did The Twelve Tribes of Hattie inspire you to do anything?

Nope, other than to search audible for another book to top me up before the next credit!

Any additional comments?

It's nice to have a book, going across decades withAfrican Americans folk as the subject. This helps open your mind on an area less publicised and for this I would recommend it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A poignant story about a woman raising her kids

I seldom date a book 5 stars. It has to imprint its flow, pace, context and characters. Intellectually challenge me and pull my emotions into balls of knots that churn, loosen and tighten as the story evolves. This book did this in abundance.

Just as others have mentioned, I was thrown after the first chapter, when I realised the next had jumped to another story. But once I adjusted my preconception of how the book should be formatted, I was fine, left to enjoy this exquisite book.

Oppression comes in many forms, the fact Hattie, her sister's and mother had left the direct, dangerous racism in the South for something more subtle, but just as sinister and oppressive in the North, intrigued me.

Each chapter is a thread of Hattie, each different, but having the commonality of originating or related to Hattie. It is a book that I'll consciously ruminate, and revel in all over again for some time to come.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!