Classic

Beautifully read, Very interesting voice and adapted to all the characters seamlessly. A no b*** s*** war story.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

great reading and voices. you do feel close 2 them

oh my god I don't have time to write poxy fifteen unique words yes that's true

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

absorbing

Rambling at times but also very compelling. More about human morality and nature than of war. I found it thought provoking and difficult to put down.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

5 people found this helpful

not sure why this book is so highly regarded

it has its moments but the narrators delivery of different characters made them all sound the same, so easily got lost in who was being spoken about. Also the characters were all pretty horrible and had not features that made me care about them at all.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

A bit of a slog but worth the read

This is regarded as one of the first great novels written about the Second World War. It draws on Mailer’s own experiences in the Pacific campaign to describe the battle to capture a Japanese island from the point of view of a platoon on the ground as they land ashore and undertake duties and patrols. There is a huge cast of characters and Mailer handles each at length. There are long passages of this novel spent developing the backstories and mentalities of each of these different soldiers and the way they interact with each other, the jungle, the war and their own ambitions, fears and resentments. It does mean that the actual plot often moves along at a labouring pace and you empathise with the default position of those in the book in waiting for something to happen. Some characters, such as Croft, are very well rounded while others play more minor roles and yet Mailer still dedicates long sections to their detailed backstories. I found this a little tiring as I didn’t necessarily care enough about these particular characters to feel the need to learn about their childhood. There are more than a few moments of brilliance however. The initial chapter covering the build up to landing on the island and the frantic moments on coming ashore is breathtaking. Mailer also successfully captures the depth of the soldiers’ struggle against the jungle and the landscape as much as against the Japanese army. Overall it’s a book worth reading. The journalistic style can make it hard going at times, but Mailer does manage to create an empathy with the soldiers, and the often mundane and menial ways they pass the time in war between the fighting.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

1 person found this helpful

The Pacific War

At the beginning this is a tedious listen as Mailer sets out the cast. The middle suddenly gets very very interesting as you set out on a recon with a dysfunctional company. Doubtless the story has been copied for many Vietnam films. Mailer wrote it first. Unlike many WW2 American writers. Mailer tells you a story and it is a very good story. Excellently read by his son.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!