Best Western Ever

I truly enjoyed this book. It was definitely his finest hour. I've read most of his books but this one was extra special and a longer book which I dearly love. Louie L'Amour was born in 1908 and died of pneumonia in 1988. According the publish date, he wrote it at about age 75. Absolutely excellent book and the narrator was good also. I will deginitely read this one again sometime. He and Zane Grey were definitely the epitome of our western culture of long ago. You won't be sorry you listened to this book.

14 people found this helpful

A 2 hour story squeezed into 14

I like L'Amour. I know the books are formulaic but they are fun reads about men with guts, a great work ethic and solid character. This book, however, rambles like a toddler in a nursery. The story has great bones, but the main character indulges in multiple identical soliloquies, spends %98 of the book growing up and amassing 4 significant enemies then manages to finish the entire story in 5 pages. It's like the author found out on page 400 that he wasn't being paid by the word any more.

5 people found this helpful

First download with audible

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

YES!!!!!! Louis L'amour what more can one say.

Which character – as performed by David Strathairn – was your favorite?

Mr. Feeney

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

Yes, but I do have a life, 14hrs long, need a little sleep. lol

Any additional comments?

First download with Audible, don't know what took me so long.

4 people found this helpful

The Desert and A Young Man

Where does The Lonesome Gods rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?

I am listening to this audio book again... This is a story for thinkers; those who prefer the solitude of a good story.

Who was your favorite character and why?

Johannes Verne is my favorite character. At the age of six, Johannes Verne, took the hard lessons of life as nourishment for his soul. Despite the dark and dangerous times of his early youth, Johannes Verne grew to become a good man. A man of courage.

What does David Strathairn bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

David Strathairn gave the story feeling. His style, as a reader made the story live.

Was this a book you wanted to listen to all in one sitting?

No... The book is many hours.

Any additional comments?

Great book, written by a legend, read by a man who gave the story character.

3 people found this helpful

Good, but not the best work of L'Amour

What did you like best about The Lonesome Gods? What did you like least?

I really like L'Amour for his plots, and frequently his descriptive phrases and dialogues are peerless. This book needed editing, and definitely follows his formula, but it wanders much more than what he usually wrote, and only one of the women is well written. I would still buy and listen to this again, but I can't see going back to it for a second review down the road. David Straitharn is also well, well matched to reading L'Amour and delivers again. However, if I had a limited budget, I would choose other L'Amour works like Skyliners, Treasure Mountain, or anything else in that series (the Sackett family chronicles). L'Amour got on his soapbox way too much in this novel rather than telling the story and having philosophical thoughts thrown in casually as he has done in other works.

What was one of the most memorable moments of The Lonesome Gods?

When the Russian agent suddenly realizes that not only is the escaped Russian he's targeting for return to Russia free to stay in California but also that the US Government isn't going to force her to return and, by the way, the agent himself could stay and make a new life for himself in California.

Which scene was your favorite?

When Miss Nesselrode confronts the grandfather who has been trying to have his grandson killed because the grandson is the product of a marriage his daughter made with a seaman--tainting the pure Spanish blood the overly proud grandfather prizes. Also enjoyed the tactics our hero and his crew use to overcome superior numbers each time his horses and his life are threatened.

Do you think The Lonesome Gods needs a follow-up book? Why or why not?

No, and since I didn't care for the wet blanket our hero fell in love with, I didn't want to see any more of her.

Any additional comments?

Still like L'Amour, and still liked the book, just thought this one was not one of his better ones.

3 people found this helpful

My favorite Lamor book of the west!

Not just another man becomes a man book. This is truly a great and well written book about a really young boy who overcomes great odds to beat all odds, Real suspense, great characters and a surprising twist in the end!

3 people found this helpful

Good Oater

I like a good western novel and I like a lifetime saga. While this book only spans 20 years or so, it is still a saga of a five year old boy going west, and trying to remain alive. He has an evil grandfather that wants him dead and leaves him to die in the Mojave desert. There are interesting characters and L'Amour knows how to write a book. This is the western genre though so if you do not like stories like Lonesome Dove, then this is not for you.

15 people found this helpful

Sorry, but this was not Louis best

I am a loyal Louis L'Amour fan. I have read over 120 of his novels and enjoyed over 20 of his audio books. However, I have to agree with some other reviewers who found this story boring. Another reviewer said LL was 75 when he wrote this. Perhaps that was a factor. Pass on this one. With so many excellent books under his belt I guess LL was overdue for one with a disjointed plot and a ending which screamed he was just tired of writing.

6 people found this helpful

Excellent Westrn from the modern master

The story starts out a little slow, but once you have overcome the first 10 minutes it is a great listen. The subtle imagery he uses to describe not only the charaters but the scenery is incredible, you can actually see it in your minds eye.

2 people found this helpful

Mediocre at Best..

Too much philosophy not enough action... The story drags on and the constant philosophy lessons take away from the main storyline. Boring, drawn out, just a 500 plus page book that should have been 300 pages!

1 person found this helpful