Book 1 - Building Well, Good Listen!!

I like most am a true Trudi fan and was excited to download and listen. This was also my first time listening to one of Trudi's books rather than reading. I was pleasantly surprised, although another review has said the narrator is awful, I would have to disagree he does a good attempt at getting into the book and portraying all the emotions needed.
I was a little disappointed with the book in regards to although I realise its a trilogy nothing really happens that excites which I thought all the other Trudi books did.

But all in all I enjoyed and am currently awaiting the download of book 2.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

10 people found this helpful

Good continuation of previous trilogy but

The story is a great continuation of The Black Magician 20 yrs later. However the narrator is terrible, mispronounced namesvand poor performance from the original narrator who was good doing the magicians guilde trilogy.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Fabulous book awful narrator

Trudi Canavan is an incredible author, possibly one of my favourites, and i have regularly enjoyed listening to her previous books. I had already read this book before i purchased the audio book and have to say that the story is a fabulous continuation of the original set of books, with new characters that you love as much as the original. However the narrator for this audio book is awful, although I could forgive the slight variations in the way he pronounces the names as everyone may read them differently, the tone of the voice is wrong for the story, and is in fact very harsh and irritating at times. Because of this i am really struggling to get through the story. I am a huge fan of audio books and will remain to be one, and i am disappointed to recommend to anyone considering purchasing this audio book to stop, listen to the sample and think again. Buy the book and enjoy it in your own voice, unless they produce a new version with a new narrator (fingers crossed).

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

19 people found this helpful

It was ok

This book was fine, but it really didn't grab me, and I am not going to download book 2 right away. However, it was a good story and once you get used to the narrators voice it is well read. If you are at a loose end and after some fiction then this will do.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

8 people found this helpful

Loved all of it, Richard Aspel was fantastic!

I loved the performance and story, surprisingly enjoyed it more than Priestess of the White.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Looking forward to book two

A while since I read this. Narrator takes a bit of getting used to, but he's not bad. Story drags at times but was enjoyable and genuinely moving in places.

Looking forward to book two.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Addictive

Trudi Canavan is one of the most addictive fantasy authors. This is the third series by her I read. Read the preceding series starting with The Magicians Guild before this book. They are stand alone series, but spoilers since this is based in the same place with some same characters 20 or so years later. I recommend either buying all audio or all books because I found I pronounced people's names very different from the audio book and wasn't sure who it was talking about for the odd minor character.

The audio book includes the Glossary which seemed very strange.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Shame about the narration..

Good story. Carrys on 20 years after the last series but still could be read on its own, it would spoil a few bits though.
Unfortunately as already mentioned in several reviews the narrator didn't do the book justice.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Another Fascinating Novel

Though it stands as a story in its own right.
The Book extends this Magical Series.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Traitor Spy Trilogy, looking good!

I loved the Black Magician trilogy and so, i was really excited by the prospect of another instalment! However, though the characters from the trilogy are there, they are overshadowed by newer characters who are just as wonderful! I liked the prequel which was published on audible last year (The Magicians Apprentice) as it fleshed out the background story which i think is one of the most interesting parts of Canavan's world. This takes the story on whilst continuing to explore the history of Sachaka and its relationship with Kyralia - i am looking forward to listening to book 2 in this trilogy, i hope it answers some of the questions raised in this, the first in the new trilogy.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

16 people found this helpful