Listen free for 30 days
-
In the Closet of the Vatican
- Power, Homosexuality, Hypocrisy
- Narrated by: John Banks
- Length: 22 hrs and 19 mins
- Unabridged Audiobook
- Categories: History, Religious
Add to basket failed.
Add to wishlist failed.
Remove from wishlist failed.
Follow podcast failed
Unfollow podcast failed
Listen with a free trial
Buy Now for £29.99
No valid payment method on file.
We are sorry. We are not allowed to sell this product with the selected payment method
Listeners also enjoyed...
-
The Oligarchs
- Wealth and Power in the New Russia
- By: David Hoffman
- Narrated by: Steve Coulter
- Length: 22 hrs and 50 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
A brilliant investigative narrative: How six average Soviet men rose to the pinnacle of Russia's battered economy. David Hoffman, former Moscow bureau chief for
The Washington Post, sheds light onto the hidden lives of Russia's most feared power brokers: the oligarchs. Focusing on six of these ruthless men Hoffman reveals how a few players managed to take over Russia's cash-strapped economy and then divvy it up in loans-for-shares deals.
-
-
A great narrative ruined by appalling narration
- By Simon on 10-11-16
-
Egypt, Greece and Rome
- Civilizations of the Ancient Mediterranean
- By: Charles Freeman
- Narrated by: Jim Meskimen
- Length: 32 hrs and 2 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Long sources of mystery, imagination, and inspiration, the myths and history of the ancient Mediterranean have given rise to artistic, religious, cultural, and intellectual traditions that span the centuries. In this unique and comprehensive introduction to the region's three major civilizations, Egypt, Greece, and Rome draws a fascinating picture of the deep links between the cultures across the Mediterranean and explores the ways in which these civilizations continue to be influential to this day.
-
-
Great content poor choice of narrator
- By M N R on 03-01-19
-
Not Gay
- Sex Between Straight White Men
- By: Jane Ward
- Narrated by: Dara Rosenberg
- Length: 8 hrs and 6 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Not Gay thrusts deep into a world where straight guy-on-guy action is not a myth but a reality: There's fraternity and military hazing rituals, where new recruits are made to grab each other's penises and stick fingers up their fellow members' anuses; online personal ads, where straight men seek other straight men to masturbate with; and, last but not least, the long and clandestine history of straight men frequenting public restrooms for sexual encounters with other men.
-
-
Very interesting.
- By G. Morgan on 04-07-19
-
Spain
- The Centre of the World 1519-1682
- By: Robert Goodwin
- Narrated by: Jeremy Clyde
- Length: 21 hrs and 2 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
The Golden Age of the Spanish Empire would establish five centuries of Western supremacy across the globe and usher in an era of transatlantic exploration that eventually gave rise to the modern world. It was a time of discovery and adventure, of great political and social change - it was a time when Spain learned to rule the world.
-
-
Enjoyable, clever, funny - but perplexing.
- By Mr. on 10-09-15
-
17 Carnations
- The Windsors, The Nazis and The Cover-Up
- By: Andrew Morton
- Narrated by: Cameron Stewart
- Length: 11 hrs and 25 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
The story of the love affair between Wallis Simpson and King Edward VIII, and his abdication in order to marry the divorcée, has provoked fascination and discussion for decades. However, the full story of the couple's links with the German aristocracy and Hitler has until now remained untold. Meticulously researched, 17 Carnations chronicles this entanglement, starting with Hitler's early attempts to matchmake between Edward and a German noblewoman.
-
-
History narrated at its most professional.
- By Ginger on 10-04-16
-
A Pope and a President
- John Paul II, Ronald Reagan, and the Extraordinary Untold Story of the 20th Century
- By: Paul Kengor
- Narrated by: James Anderson Foster
- Length: 23 hrs and 20 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Even as historians credit Ronald Reagan and Pope John Paul II with hastening the end of the Cold War, they have failed to recognize the depth or significance of the bond that developed between the two leaders. cclaimed scholar and best-selling author Paul Kengor changes that. In this fascinating book, he reveals a singular bond - which included a spiritual connection between the Catholic pope and the Protestant president - that drove the two men to confront what they knew to be the great evil of the 20th century: Soviet communism.
-
The Oligarchs
- Wealth and Power in the New Russia
- By: David Hoffman
- Narrated by: Steve Coulter
- Length: 22 hrs and 50 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
A brilliant investigative narrative: How six average Soviet men rose to the pinnacle of Russia's battered economy. David Hoffman, former Moscow bureau chief for
The Washington Post, sheds light onto the hidden lives of Russia's most feared power brokers: the oligarchs. Focusing on six of these ruthless men Hoffman reveals how a few players managed to take over Russia's cash-strapped economy and then divvy it up in loans-for-shares deals.
-
-
A great narrative ruined by appalling narration
- By Simon on 10-11-16
-
Egypt, Greece and Rome
- Civilizations of the Ancient Mediterranean
- By: Charles Freeman
- Narrated by: Jim Meskimen
- Length: 32 hrs and 2 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Long sources of mystery, imagination, and inspiration, the myths and history of the ancient Mediterranean have given rise to artistic, religious, cultural, and intellectual traditions that span the centuries. In this unique and comprehensive introduction to the region's three major civilizations, Egypt, Greece, and Rome draws a fascinating picture of the deep links between the cultures across the Mediterranean and explores the ways in which these civilizations continue to be influential to this day.
-
-
Great content poor choice of narrator
- By M N R on 03-01-19
-
Not Gay
- Sex Between Straight White Men
- By: Jane Ward
- Narrated by: Dara Rosenberg
- Length: 8 hrs and 6 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Not Gay thrusts deep into a world where straight guy-on-guy action is not a myth but a reality: There's fraternity and military hazing rituals, where new recruits are made to grab each other's penises and stick fingers up their fellow members' anuses; online personal ads, where straight men seek other straight men to masturbate with; and, last but not least, the long and clandestine history of straight men frequenting public restrooms for sexual encounters with other men.
-
-
Very interesting.
- By G. Morgan on 04-07-19
-
Spain
- The Centre of the World 1519-1682
- By: Robert Goodwin
- Narrated by: Jeremy Clyde
- Length: 21 hrs and 2 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
The Golden Age of the Spanish Empire would establish five centuries of Western supremacy across the globe and usher in an era of transatlantic exploration that eventually gave rise to the modern world. It was a time of discovery and adventure, of great political and social change - it was a time when Spain learned to rule the world.
-
-
Enjoyable, clever, funny - but perplexing.
- By Mr. on 10-09-15
-
17 Carnations
- The Windsors, The Nazis and The Cover-Up
- By: Andrew Morton
- Narrated by: Cameron Stewart
- Length: 11 hrs and 25 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
The story of the love affair between Wallis Simpson and King Edward VIII, and his abdication in order to marry the divorcée, has provoked fascination and discussion for decades. However, the full story of the couple's links with the German aristocracy and Hitler has until now remained untold. Meticulously researched, 17 Carnations chronicles this entanglement, starting with Hitler's early attempts to matchmake between Edward and a German noblewoman.
-
-
History narrated at its most professional.
- By Ginger on 10-04-16
-
A Pope and a President
- John Paul II, Ronald Reagan, and the Extraordinary Untold Story of the 20th Century
- By: Paul Kengor
- Narrated by: James Anderson Foster
- Length: 23 hrs and 20 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Even as historians credit Ronald Reagan and Pope John Paul II with hastening the end of the Cold War, they have failed to recognize the depth or significance of the bond that developed between the two leaders. cclaimed scholar and best-selling author Paul Kengor changes that. In this fascinating book, he reveals a singular bond - which included a spiritual connection between the Catholic pope and the Protestant president - that drove the two men to confront what they knew to be the great evil of the 20th century: Soviet communism.
-
Lessons in Hope
- My Unexpected Life with St. John Paul II
- By: George Weigel
- Narrated by: Jim Meskimen
- Length: 12 hrs and 53 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
In Lessons in Hope, George Weigel tells the story of his unique friendship with St. John Paul II. As Weigel learns the pope "from inside", he also offers a firsthand account of the tumult of post-Vatican II Catholicism and the Cold War's endgame, introducing listeners to the heroes who brought down European communism. Later, he shows us the aging pope grappling with the post-9/11 world order and teaching new lessons in dignity through his own suffering.
-
The Story of the Jews: Finding the Words, 1000 BCE - 1492
- By: Simon Schama
- Narrated by: Andrew Sachs, Saul Reichlin
- Length: 21 hrs and 8 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
It is a story like no other: an epic of endurance against destruction, of creativity in oppression, joy amidst grief, the affirmation of life against the steepest of odds. It spans the millennia and the continents - from India to Andalusia and from the bazaars of Cairo to the streets of Oxford. It takes you to unimagined places: to a Jewish kingdom in the mountains of southern Arabia; a Syrian synagogue glowing with radiant wall paintings; the palm groves of the Jewish dead in the Roman catacombs.
-
-
Part of the history of the Jews.
- By Teresa Cooper on 15-01-16
-
The Story of China
- A Portrait of a Civilisation and Its People
- By: Michael Wood
- Narrated by: Michael Wood
- Length: 23 hrs and 7 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
China is the oldest living civilisation on earth, but its history is still surprisingly little known in the wider world. Michael Wood's sparkling narrative, which mingles the grand sweep with local and personal stories, woven together with the author’s own travel journals, is an enthralling account of China’s 4000-year-old tradition, taking in life stationed on the Great Wall or inside the Forbidden City.
-
-
Ruined by the narrator
- By George on 20-12-20
-
Necessary Illusions
- Thought Control in Democratic Societies
- By: Noam Chomsky
- Narrated by: Kevin Stillwell
- Length: 18 hrs and 12 mins
- Original Recording
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
In his 1988 CBC Massey Lecture, Noam Chomsky inquires into the nature of the media in a political system where the population cannot be disciplined by force and thus must be subjected to more subtle forms of ideological control. Specific cases are illustrated in detail, using the U.S. media primarily but also media in other societies.
-
-
Yawn
- By Alex on 13-01-21
-
A Failed Empire
- The Soviet Union in the Cold War from Stalin to Gorbachev
- By: Vladimir Zubok
- Narrated by: Nick Sullivan
- Length: 20 hrs and 13 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Western interpretations of the Cold War--both realist and neoconservative--have erred by exaggerating either the Kremlin's pragmatism or its aggressiveness, argues Vladislav Zubok. Explaining the interests, aspirations, illusions, fears, and misperceptions of the Kremlin leaders and Soviet elites, Zubok offers a Soviet perspective on the greatest standoff of the 20th century.
-
-
Soviet Cold War History in an understandable form.
- By Adrian on 08-01-13
-
France
- A Short History: From Gaul to de Gaulle
- By: John Julius Norwich
- Narrated by: John Julius Norwich
- Length: 15 hrs and 12 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
John Julius Norwich (at 88) has finally written the book he always wanted to write, the extremely colourful story of the country he loves best. From frowning Roman generals and belligerent Gallic chieftains to Charlemagne through Marie Antoinette and the storming of the Bastille to Vichy, the Resistance and beyond, France is packed with heroes and villains, adventures and battles, romance and revolution. Full of memorable stories and racy anecdotes, this is the country that has inspired the rest of the world to live, dress, eat - and love better.
-
-
A Love letter to France
- By Daniel Johnstone on 09-04-18
-
Rollercoaster
- Europe, 1950-2017
- By: Ian Kershaw
- Narrated by: Leighton Pugh
- Length: 26 hrs and 29 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
After the overwhelming horrors of the first half of the 20th century, described by Ian Kershaw in his previous book as having gone 'to hell and back', the years from 1950 to 2017 brought peace and relative prosperity to most of Europe. Enormous economic improvements transformed the continent. The catastrophic era of the world wars receded into an ever more distant past, though its long shadow continued to shape mentalities. Europe was now a divided continent, living under the nuclear threat in a period intermittently fraught with anxiety.
-
-
Superb history, great narration - add chapters!
- By Amazon Customer on 30-05-21
-
Stalin
- New Biography of a Dictator
- By: Oleg V. Khlevniuk, Nora Seligman Favorov - translator
- Narrated by: Peter Ganim
- Length: 18 hrs
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
This essential biography, by the author most deeply familiar with the vast archives of the Soviet era, offers an unprecedented, fine-grained portrait of Stalin, the man and dictator. Without mythologizing Stalin as either benevolent or an evil genius, Khlevniuk resolves numerous controversies about specific events in the dictator's life while assembling many hundreds of previously unknown letters, memos, reports, and diaries into a comprehensive, compelling narrative of a life that altered the course of world history.
-
-
Not bad, but...
- By Alan Myers on 11-06-19
-
Bad Religion
- How We Became a Nation of Heretics
- By: Ross Douthat
- Narrated by: Lloyd James
- Length: 13 hrs and 12 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Ross Douthat, the youngest-ever op-ed columnist for the New York Times, has emerged as one of the most provocative and influential voices of his generation. Now he offers a masterful and hard-hitting account of how American Christianity has gone off the rails - and why it threatens to take American society with it.
-
-
Fascinating and easy on the ear
- By Richard Greenaway on 17-02-22
-
Victoria
- A Life
- By: A. N. Wilson
- Narrated by: Gareth Armstrong
- Length: 19 hrs and 15 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
To many Queen Victoria was a ruler shrouded in myth and mystique, portrayed as an aging, stiff widow. But in truth Britain’s longest-reigning monarch was passionate, expressive, humorous, and unconventional. A. N. Wilson’s exhaustively researched and definitive biography includes a wealth of new material from previously unseen sources, showing us Queen Victoria as she’s never been seen before.
-
-
Riveting and entertaining?
- By Ali H on 27-06-19
-
Children of Paradise
- The Struggle for the Soul of Iran
- By: Laura Secor
- Narrated by: Mozhan Marnò
- Length: 17 hrs and 41 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
The drama that shaped today’s Iran, from the Revolution to the present day. In 1979, seemingly overnight - moving at a clip some 30 years faster than the rest of the world - Iran became the first revolutionary theocracy in modern times. Since then, the country has been largely a black box to the West, a sinister presence looming over the horizon. But inside Iran, a breathtaking drama has unfolded since then, as religious thinkers, political operatives, poets, journalists, and activists have imagined and reimagined what Iran should be.
-
Rough Crossings
- By: Simon Schama
- Narrated by: Joseph Paterson
- Length: 16 hrs and 9 mins
- Unabridged
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
Rough Crossings is the astonishing story of the struggle to freedom by thousands of African American slaves who fled the plantations to fight behind British lines in the American War of Independence. With gripping, powerfully vivid storytelling, Simon Schama follows the escaped blacks into the fires of the war and into freezing, inhospitable Nova Scotia, where many who had served the Crown were betrayed in their promises to receive land at the war's end.
Summary
In the Closet of the Vatican is a fascinating description and evaluation of financial, sexual and political misconduct throughout the Catholic Church at a time when new revelations are being uncovered each and every week. This audiobook explores the underlying causes and includes interviews with numerous Cardinals and other individuals, some of whom cannot be named.
Martel reveals financial scandals in the Vatican bank; political collusion with unsavoury regimes, including Castro’s Cuba and Pinochet’s Chile; sexual abuse and hypocrisy over homosexuality. In this explosive account, Martel goes to the heart of corruption in the Catholic Church and inside the Vatican itself.
Martel is a researcher and writer. He has a PhD in social sciences and four master's degrees in law, political science, philosophy, and social science (University La Sorbonne). He has been visiting scholar at Harvard University and taught at Sciences-Po Paris and at the HEC’s Business School MBA in Paris.
He is the author of nine books, including On Culture in America (Gallimard, 2006) and the best seller Mainstream: On the Global War on Culture and Medias (Flammarion, 2010, translated in 20 countries). He has had articles in Newsweek, the New Yorker and the New York Times.
More from the same
Author
Narrator
What listeners say about In the Closet of the Vatican
Average customer ratingsReviews - Please select the tabs below to change the source of reviews.
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Brendan Corkery
- 19-07-19
A bad book
Given the splash the publication of this book briefly made in the news, I set out to listen to it, and did so with curiosity and an open mind. To say that this book is poorly written is as polite as I can manage. The author uses a rambling and prurient style, and attempts to support an unfocused thesis with innuendo and unsubstantiated statements. Historical facts are added seemingly to support his statements but are mostly unconnected to the issue being discussed and seem intended to distract and give the (false) impression of a weighty argument. Generalisation are frequent and betray the author’s bias and clear lack of true knowledge of religion in general and in particular.
The supposed witnesses often give the impression (unintentionally I assume) if being unreliable and questionable motivation. The stories lack convincing detail and seem to be told to give the author what he wants to hear. The author is clearly and openly biased and therefore an unreliable guide. The lack of critical thinking and assessment of his supposed facts is frustrating and speaks loudly of the poor quality of this book.
The author is self-obsessed to an extreme degree. I lost track of the amount of examples where his emotions or impressions on any given situation are taken as evidence of truth that we are expected to accept without question.
13 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- caroline
- 29-05-20
Brilliant if you understand the Catholic Church
If you don’t have a interest in catholic history and some knowledge of how it works this book isn’t for you
If on the other hand you do have that interest and knowledge then this book will blow your mind
It’s a little bit hard going at the start but bear with it and it becomes mind blowing
It’s well research and based in facts the Author is honest enough to tell you if he couldn’t back up what he was telling you with multiple first hand accounts
This book is a must listen to for anyone who is catholic has a Christian faith or just has an interest in these things and a little knowledge
8 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- ross
- 28-07-19
Couldn't have been any more detailed
In depth research on such a taboo area, incredibly written and performed. Thoroughly enjoyed all the way through
6 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Mr. Jr Baker
- 26-05-19
Stunning indictment of Catholic Church
Amazing and disturbing. You will neverlook at the Catholic Church in the same way again. My one criticism is that it is too long and repetitive at times.
5 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Anonymous User
- 10-05-19
Generous, can't put down read
Well written, generous and thoroughly researched. Did well to unpack the drivers holding these closet doors closed.
6 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Krzysztof Janczuk
- 28-12-20
Part journalism part queer theories
It's interesting but could be more if the author was focused on the accusations (in the legal sense) of the Vatican throughout the whole book. Concisely it's good up the end of pontificate John Paul II. As a Polish I grew up during his pontificate (he was elected a year before I was born), and I remember that he was revered as an staunch fighter against communist regime, strong moral figure and wise man and I also remember that his last years as a Pope were very hard due to Parkinson's disease. The book didn't offer answers to key questions that mark the end of his pontificate (was he complicit, naive, unable to see or wilfully blind to the crimes Marcial Maciel and his Legion of Christ or shortcomings of Angelo Sodano). Was his fight against communist regime something that casted that big shadow that he wasn't able to see anything else or because he prioritises that task he didn't wanted to see or hear anything else or is there any other explanation. Long story short up to this point the book is good because it focuses on something that is real (as a book written in the investigative journalism manner should be). The other part of the book is to me queer insight to the Battle of Vatican or Great Gay War where gays who hate themselves (the rigid ones who hold power and want maintain status quo) fight perfumed ones (who loves themselves are very talented especially in arts but at the same time very petty, want to change the face of the Institution to something "beautiful" like Atlantis but with more sex and art). Examples: Benedict was passe because he might be gay but wasn't very showy about it, every crazy way of life as road to heaven (queer theology), gender theory in practice because of robes and that strange preoccupation with priests and their way of life with the accent that Christianity must be gay loving. The other part might be interesting from psychological perspective but didn't add journalistic value to the book.
2 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Sean Olson
- 17-05-19
Disaster
Ploughed through this time hoping to learn something. Did not. Much promised nothing new. It is badly written ,pompous and the narrator is dreadful. It is so bad that I Googled it to see if my mind was playing tricks. It’s not. Can’t believe Audible would put it out as a special. This book is dross by the yard, foot, meter or kilometer.
8 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Roseline Swain
- 05-06-21
Superb!
I've just finished this and I'm going straight back to the start. Absolutely captivating. Beautifully read with an English voice that is a delight to listen to. This didn't shake my Catholic faith at all, I just found it sad and perplexing. Just brilliant.
1 person found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- Phillip
- 17-03-21
Eye opening - The Truth hurts !!!!
Brilliantly researched by Frederic Martel, great narration by John Banks, eye opening? religion is poisonous!!!!
1 person found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story
- victoria macdonalf
- 25-03-21
Very badly written an rambling!
This is a truly terrible book! the author zig zags all over the place. One minute he is talking about the history of the Vatican, the next minute he is out having lunch with someone who has flimsy evidence of wrong doing. He has a LOT of lunches and describes the surroundings ad nauseum. He goes round and round and really gets nowhere. It's all innuendo and hearsay with no concrete evidence or facts. The main gist is that an awful lot of Catholic priests are gay and always have been and that is why the early popes banned marriage. . . WELL SURPRISE! In a world where it was a mortal sin and you could be put to death, where else would you hide? That is well known. The other main theme is that a lot of the Vatican and it's higher powers are corrupt. It is a very large operation with a lot of power, so no surprise there either. This book is saying nothing new with no real facts or proof. It is very very long and I really just wanted to to the end to see if he came up with any actual facts or relegations. Even my grandma who was a staunch Italian Catholic (born 1899) used to say that there were a lot of 'powder puffs' in the church and that a lot of corruption went on. So. . . nothing new told in a REALLY long way.
22 hours of my life that I will never get back!
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story

- L.Lovelace
- 30-10-20
Heartbreaking
This book was very well researched and if you finish it you will not be able to think of the Catholic Church the same way again. The author does a tremendous job shedding light on the Vaticans closet and it’s extreme hypocrisy. He diagnoses the problems in the Vatican from an insiders perspective. He had an unusual level of access to high ranking officials within the Holy See. He exposes rank corruption at the highest levels as well as the worst sins of Princes or “Queens” of the Church.
Sadly the author is a militant homosexual and this colors almost the entire book. Anyone who is to the right of him is an extremist or “far right”. He attempts to marginalize traditional Catholics and other Christians this way. He is a textbook bigot, in the classical sense. The sad thing is that he doesn’t see it. The sees the world through the lenses of his sexuality. He freely admits his ignorance of the Bible and for that matter the Christian faith. He idolizes sexuality and it prevents him from truly understanding the religion that built Western Civilization. He is self impoverished in the truest sense.
5 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story

- Jason
- 02-05-19
An engaging story of something not so secret!
First, the only drawback of this book is the amount of tangents and digressions. From the narrator to the interviewees, there are a lot of sequence breaks.
It may be a narration which turns to a quote. A quote that's reminiscing to a quote that they're making from someone else. That choppy flow with names (excellently pronounced) in multiple languages make this listen difficult to follow at times.
Aside from that, the book is amazing. It explains so much on how the Vatican came to be so gay. Why the contradictions with condemning homosexual acts but never punishing child molesters. It's complex and sad. And there's just so much. The absurdity to which some of these men exploited their power will have you yelling out loud.
But there are touching, humanizing points as well. The book is a emotional rollercoaster. I strongly recommend this book. Not because I'm gay or because I'm an atheist. But because it's a fascinating story about humans and their inner struggles.
10 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story

- Susan
- 26-04-19
Where was the editor?
Such a poorly edited book with whole long sections repeated and repeated. Also not particularly interested in know what the author ate in every restaurant. Expected something more factual and coherent.
9 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story

- Dr. Terence M. Dwyer
- 22-03-20
Very disappointing
Perhaps the author thought he was Voltaire but he comes across like a gossip queen gaily being a bitch about everyone he ever met in the Catholic Church. More real evidence for his grand Continental theses would have been appreciated.
2 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story

- Peter Bernard Hooper
- 25-02-20
As a Catholic myself the book has real force.
The writing style of the book is a mix of academic work, methodic and involved, and yet it steps back from being only thing by a large amount of story telling and reports of a large number of interviews If one was asked is this book primarily a psychological reflection or a sociological one, then sociology gets the tick in its box. A number of times Martel is able to point to how the story of the individual is linked to the problem and issue a whole society experiences and is required to face as a result of the telling of that individual's story. Finally there is one idea Martel offers which is noteworthy. He points to the presence of both gay people and non-gays in the Vatican but does not then argue there are two lobbies, one gay and the other straight. He observes while there are gay individuals, group formation for them, the capacity to be a political block is not there because that sexual orientation or interest can't be socially acknowledged. There is the ability for a political movement that attacks gays to be formed, and it is there in the Vatican, and it is populated by many who are homophile. There is permission for this group formation and Martel gives time to explain how this faction operates. This book is socking for some, as a Catholic the news that some in the Vatican are gay is no surprise, however the goings on, the things said and done, that can be indeed unsettling. A book which can be recommended to those who are willing to be open to what it offers.
2 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story

- Anne Sanchez
- 23-04-19
Interresting , to a point
This book could and should have been written with only half the pages ... It is 576 pages long, that's 22 hours of reading ! The author spends pages after pages giving details that are not always necessary but that are repetitive. Also you get lost in the endless list of names. You lose interest in his argument because it so long , it's a bit like when you are in a maze and you realise you've been there for too long and you get tired of it. The prologue however really impressed me : it is both illuminating and beautifully written. Some portraits he draws of some cardinals are also very striking, sometimes downright hilarious. But definetly not a book I will ever read again.
4 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story

- Amazon Customer
- 27-02-20
Rings True and Explains Much about the Church
First, about the book itself. The author is a gifted narrator and obviously did extensive research. The nature of the subject means that often he is relying on second hand information but he weighs this information and often explains why he disbelieved some accusations. Sometimes he gives elaborate descriptions of his interviewees and some may wish less detail had been given. Still his prose in English translation is excellent and worth the read. The audio performance is outstanding and the reader handles the embedded foreign words (usually explained by the author) and names flawlessly. Yes, a good portion of the book is hearsay but it rings true and matches my own observations over the years.
1 person found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story

- David
- 04-09-19
one-sided account approved by the current regime
the book gives an account of homosexuality in the Vatican that suits the needs of the closet. Martel simultaneously claims that homosexuality has nothing to do with pedophilia in the Church, and that it is result of clergy having to live in the closet. The central thesis of the book is that homophobes in the Vatican are actually gay people covering for their own homosexuality is supported in a few cases, but the stretching of it to a tautology would require much more evidence than Martel provides. He states he does not want to "out" people, but systematically outs conservatives who are gay, giving cover to the progressives. All credibility is lost at the point where he exonerated Francis from culpability when he lashed-out at the accusers of the priests and bishops in Chile. Martel jumps the shark when he implies that this wasn't an error, but a necessary move to save the entire structure of the Church in Chile from collapsing. Even if those were the stakes, the action was not justified. He claims to be progressive, but attacks the powerful intellectual Robert Sarah in the most shameful of racial terms. Speaking of Sarah living in an earthen hut with witchcraft, and utterly dismissing this man's mind, was oddly reminiscent of Reagan's views on the Tanzanian UN contingent. It shows the condescension of French progressivism that is at it's heart. The French intellectual will share with you, as it is the "White Man's Burden" as long as you behave as you should, but if you politically oppose him he will turn every stereotype against you... it's because he never stopped believing them, but he found playing as if he rejected them politically useful. The book contains useful information in many parts, and I think he is correct about the Church in Cuba, and about the escorts. The lack of objective data calls conclusions into question, the one time in the book that he called-on quantitative data--counting priests on Grinder--he was disappointed with the low sum, and trumped this objective data with reports of hearsay that better supported his conclusions. This book was allowed to be written because it protected the current Papal regime's Power-brokers at every turn, while never failing to cast Benedict XVI in a wicked light. To this end, he claims that Benedict only laicized a few dozen priests--the data was out there before the publication of this book and rapidly showed up on a Google search that he rocked 260 in 2011 and 124 in 2012. Furthermore, the lists of de-frocked clergy in the US frequently bear the phrase "laicized by Pope Benedict XVI on xx/xx/20xx", many more were laicized by Pope JP2 after 2001 when Ratzinger asked JP2 to let him deal with it. In the simplest tasks of reporting data, Martel brazenly chooses propaganda over fact. it's no wonder this was released the day of the Vatican's child abuse conference, it dove-tailed with their insistence that the scandal had nothing to do with homosexuality. And, who, I may ask benefitted? I don't know, but don't look in the closet!
4 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story

- Bob Young
- 14-04-19
"Houston, we have a problem."
As a socially conservative Democrat and a Roman Catholic I could have taken offense at the author's numerous accusations that anyone being anti-gay was automatically gay. Case in point being the numerous members of the Curia, from priest to Pope accused of being gay or assumed to be, Due to their "fake" social conservatism such as the Traditionalist Burke "the Cardinal queen." It is amazing how many members of the Curia were in fact, interviewed by this author. And even more amazing just how many of the Curia is thought to be gay or gay homophiles. It is as if the entire circle of men around the Popes (Pope Saint John XXIII to the Blessed Pope Paul VI to Pope Saint John Paul II to Pope Francis today) e.g. the entire cadre of responsible men around the Holy See and his Cardinals (and the Cardinals too) and their Bishops and priests (and the Bishops and priests too) have been nothing more than maniacal sex fiends addicted to plush surroundings and expensive accouterment. From the paintings on the office walls to the luxuriant carpets (all strewn about) to the equally luxuriant furniture. The author spent a great deal of time making the point that the Blessed Pope Paul VI was NOT gay. Why? Not until in the last paragraph of the book does the author admit being gay himself. I found this book to be self-serving on his part (in the sense that he thinks that he and everyone are gay). If clerics do not soon begin legal proceedings for libel and slander then one must assume we are reading the truth. The Roman Catholic Church is being led by degenerate homosexuals. I must say that the author is a very high-quality writer. The translator was of high-quality too. The performer was near perfect. The church lingo was perfectly brought to the ear. I must say, though, that the author is astonishingly cynical and sure of himself but well informed of history. How he obtained all the sensitive interviews remains to be seen. And the Curia was cleaned like a trout before frying. Its guts spilled out and all about. (I gave the story a two because it was gratuitous)
4 people found this helpful
-
Overall
-
Performance
-
Story

- Anonymous User
- 10-08-20
outstanding
open your eyes and see the sad truth. the church doesn't want you to know what was willingly disclosed to this man. as for those of you who say it's gossip, he has 300 pages of citations.