Great narration, weak story: disappointing overall

Besotted with the Viscount is a fairly low-angst tale set in a small English village, which sees two people who don’t quite fit in discovering that they fit in with each other rather well. It’s a leisurely-paced, character-driven tale, that starts well, but drags in the middle and then resorts to a rather clichéd Big Misunderstanding in order to create some much-needed tension towards the end.

War hero Captain Lord Gideon Birch hated every moment of the naval career forced on him by his family, and wants nothing more than to live quietly somewhere as far from the sea as possible. To that end, he has purchased a property in the vicinity of a remote village in Derbyshire.

Thea Ridley is the daughter of a scholar and lived most of her life in Greece before returning to England following the deaths of her parents. She lives in a small cottage with her elderly companion and is barely making ends meet, so when the opportunity arises to work for Lord Birch, cataloguing and translating his extensive library of Greek texts, she jumps at the chance to earn enough money to be able to move our of England, where she's never felt she belonged.

It’s a nice way of getting the two together, but I couldn’t help asking myself how it was that neither of them thought it improper to be alone together so often. I suppose it could be that Gideon regarded Thea as a servant and therefore without a reputation to worry about, but that’s clearly not the case, given that they first meet at a social event. He’s immediately smitten by her beautiful face (and in fact, if anyone is besotted in this story, it’s him). But Gideon’s reputation as a rake and libertine is widely known, so Thea, who is still getting over being thrown over by the young man she’d expected to marry - is wary, of Gideon and of men in general.

This is a romance novel, so I don’t need to spell out where things are headed. Thea is equally taken with the handsome captain, but keeps reminding herself that Men Are Not To Be Trusted and remains in denial about the truth of her feelings for Gideon. Until, that is, her former love arrives back in the village accompanied by his new – pregnant - wife (whom he married for money), and promptly propositions Thea, intending to make her his mistress. She’s so furiously indignant, she goes back to Gideon’s house, figures if all men are going to think she’s a whore, she might as well be one, and jumps Gideon - much to his delight.

Things between them are fairly blissful (fortunately, Gideon has hardly any servants, so there’s nobody to witness them getting it on in all the rooms in the house) – although at no point does he, a gentleman, mention marriage – until the Big Mis kicks in near the end. Without spoilers, something happens to Thea which turns the whole village against her, and when details reach Gideon – who has had to go away for a week – he immediately believes the worst, and, on returning to Littleover, makes no attempt to see or speak to Thea to get her side of the story.

Needless to say, Gideon’s behaviour at that point is unforgiveable and I didn’t blame Thea for the decision she makes afterward. All is happily resolved, of course, but I have to say that while I generally liked Gideon, his lack of faith in Thea in the final stages of the novel left a nasty taste in my mouth.

It will come as no surprise when I say that the narration was by far the strongest part of this audiobook. Unfortunately, however, not even the velvet tones of Nicholas Boulton were enough to raise the book above the average, and actually, it’s the first time I’ve ever said that I wished he’d been given better material to work with, as so far, the authors he’s narrated for in the romance genre - Laura Kinsale, Alexis Hall, Elizabeth Kingston – are all top-notch. His performance is excellent, as usual; his interpretations of the various characters are fabulous, they’re all very clearly differentiated, and his ability to get to the emotional heart of any given scene is superb. But ultimately, the story is weak and the heroine is difficult to warm to, so in spite of Mr. Boulton’s best efforts – wonderful though they are – Besotted by the Viscount is rather a middling affair.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

More than a bit shaky on the plot

32 year old naval captain retires after 10 years in HM Navy!!!!! Never a midshipman?????? Lord Nelson joined at age 12 and was a Post-captain at 20 but the man was a genius.
A huge collection of rare and classic books as his spoils of war???? Where would these have been kept on a French man of war? It's just too absurd.
Not even Nicholas Boulton could rescue this book..

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Lovely little story

My husband had the pleasure of listening to me burst out laughing at the last chapter with: “YOU CANNOT GO TO ITALY!”

It was a tumultuous joy to listen to, bubbling with passion and miscommunication as two people fumble around in love. I know some people thought the main characters insipid... but I can’t see why! Thea is eternally infuriating and complex... Gideon is simultaneously sweet and highly predatory which makes for a very fun hero.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Great listening.

This was an enjoyable listening experience both with the author and the narrator Well Done ✔

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Shocking

Now I am a real regency romance fan and listen to this Genre a lot but have to say the heroine in this book was beyond annoying not a strong character at all and Completely insipid! The Hero wasn’t much different to be truthful. Sorry not for me do not waste money or credit! VERY DISAPPOINTED

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

2 people found this helpful

A good historical romance

A thoroughly simply historical romance, man meets woman and they eventually fall in love, but what was not simply was the delightful prose, I read/listened to a lyrical style similar to Laura Kinsale (all of whom books I delight in) and off course the wonderful Nicholas Bolton velvety tones just enhanced the story further. I look forward to reading/listening to more of Sussanna Malcolm proses hopefully in the future.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

4 people found this helpful

Loved this story

The story is very simple, man sees woman and is smitten. He engages her to sort out his library, and he falls in love but as these stories go neither actually proclaims their feelings outright. Gossip and misunderstandings but all's well that ends well. I won't tell the story as it may spoil it for others,. I loved the epilogue .

I will certainly look out for any more stories by this author.

Oh! and I loved Nicholas Boultons' voice, very easy to listen to.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!