In the tradition of Anthony Bourdain's Kitchen Confidential and Gelsey Kirkland's Dancing on My Grave, Mozart in the Jungle delves into the lives of the musicians and conductors who inhabit the insular world of classical music.
In a book that inspired the Amazon original series starring Gael Garcia Bernal and Malcolm McDowell, oboist Blair Tindall recounts her decades-long professional career as a classical musician, from the recitals and Broadway orchestra performances to the secret life of musicians who survive hand to mouth in the backbiting New York classical music scene, trading sexual favors for plum jobs and assignments in orchestras across the city. Tindall and her fellow journeymen musicians often play drunk, high, or hopelessly hungover, live in decrepit apartments, and perform in hazardous conditions. These are working-class musicians who schlep across the city between low-paying gigs, without health-care benefits or retirement plans--a stark contrast to the rarefied experiences of overpaid classical musician superstars.
An incisive, no-holds-barred account, Mozart in the Jungle is the first true, behind-the-scenes look at what goes on backstage and in the Broadway pit.
First, I discovered this book after seeing the two seasons of the Amazon TV series. This book is NOTHING like that. But more about that later.
If you are coming to this book without having seen the Amazon series, you will not be confused. The story is of a young musician, very talented it would seem, who moves to NYC, lives in a run-down apartment building, and makes her way through the world of classical music, with a side trip to Broadway orchestras.
The story is somewhat interesting, but the author shows her journalism roots (rather than entertainment) by interjecting dry statistics from newspapers, magazines, and government sources, on the state of classical music in the country.
But even the humanity of the story feels dry. Several characters appear throughout the book and we get to see their lives change. One of her friends has a very serious heart condition. The book takes us through the drama of all his operations and then decline. But there isn't any feeling to the story. We don't care.
Other characters feel just a dry. The author has a tendency to rank the quality of her friend's lives as to what kind of apartment they have, who they are married to, and what kind of music they create. The author eventually leaves the classical music field for journalism when she realizes she doesn't want to live in her apartment building after the age of 40. This is not how you create an empathetic character.
As far as the sex and drugs, they're in there, with a lot of booze on the side. I think we are supposed to be shocked that classical musicians, considered such a stiff and stuffy group, would smoke dope, snort cocaine, performed stoned, and sleep around with married people.
Sadly these are all the people the author seems to know.
But even these scandalous-sounding stories come out without any feeling. We don't care if someone plays stoned one night. Or a $10,000 flute is stolen from a restaurant. Or they do crossword puzzles in the pit of a Broadway orchestra.
The story ends with the author's cautions against sending children into music schools if they're not going to be able to get jobs in an industry that is losing employment. I agree that kids should not learn to play the oboe if they only want to do it to be a professional musician. Obviously someone as talented as the author had to leave because there wasn't enough work. But what about the joy of learning to make music? Or the discipline of learning an instrument. Or the fun of banging on the drum in a marching band.
If we listen to the author, all the music in education programs would be cancelled.
It's a shame, though, that the author stopped her story shortly after leaving classical music. A quick search on Google shows she's had quite the amazing life since then with restraining orders, fake marriage, and mental problems. Now THAT'S a story I would love to have read.
Now, for anyone who has seen the Amazon series and wants to get more about that story? Forget it! This book has as much to do with the Amazon show as a map of Texas does to the series "Dallas."
That's not to say you won't enjoy this book. It's just that they are totally different.
Same thing the other way round. If you have listened to this book, you'll be surprised at how little of it is in the series. The series has concocted characters that are not at all in this book. The characters in the series are interesting. But I'm really surprised they share the same title.
19 of 19 people found this review helpful
This might have been a better book with a different performer. She read too slowly and I just couldn't connect her with the main character. I may try just reading,it rather than listening.
9 of 11 people found this review helpful
This book wasn’t for you, but who do you think might enjoy it more?
I was really looking forward to listening to this story after watching the Series, but just couldn't make it past the narrator.
9 of 11 people found this review helpful
Blair Tindall tells all about the arts behind the scenes. I thought the narrator was very much right for the part. I had no trouble believing what Tindall says went on. In my experience, a lot more goes on than people talk about.
2 of 2 people found this review helpful
Tindall's overall effort in this book is to make the point that the classical music scene in America has changed in the last 50 years; and that schools and conservatories are turning out too many new students in relation to available jobs in the market. Excellent point. However she arrives at this at this point by way of chapters and chapters of dull and uninteresting stories and anecdotes. Tindall tries to decorate her stories with inane details such as what she was wearing or what color the sky was or what food she ordered at a restaurant, but we as the readers are left with little real substance, and also to wonder how much of the story presented as fact is really just a construct.
Tindall describes her time at a music Conservatory, how she got to New York, and her experience as a freelance musician was like. Through example after example she to explains that most of her big breaks in her music career came from sleeping with someone important, then goes on to tell the readers about how unsustainable a career in music is. She also spends an absurd amount of time talking about reed making and how bad she was at it.
As a musician I was excited to get in to this book, but was left a bit disappointed. There is a lot of filler in the book that only serves to make a few interesting experiences and a social/political observation into a something she can sell as a "book".
9 of 12 people found this review helpful
Kept my attention while doing mundane tasks and working out. It was extremely informational, which was fun and nice at times, and kind of boring at others. All and all a very well rounded book, that I'll suggest to friends interested in music.
1 of 1 people found this review helpful
This is a great book about a sexually exploited youth who uses her sexuality to advance her career and then complains there is too much sexual influence in classical music.
Let me share the Blair is a great musician and a great writer. On both counts she deserves every award and achievement. If you like music and personal stories this book will reach you. If self destructive behavior bothers you move on. She constantly complains that her reeds are not well formed or that she is being shorted opportunity. Both are directly due to her focus on building her skills and choosing to live a love free lifestyle.
On a positive side she does admit her lack of focus practice limited her performance and did lose her opportunity.
I hope Blair can see that she was gifted more than most and was blessed to have found a path to her own fulfilment. Almost all limitations along the way where due to poor choices. You the reader can decide if this was due to not being taught life skills, a rigged system or a stubborn pursuit of pleasure.
I learned that we, individually, are our own worst enemy. For me this book demonstrates that clearly.
3 of 5 people found this review helpful
While there are some truly interesting stories told in this book the narrative thread is nonexistent. I imagine that the author's experience as a newspaper and magazine article writer is what leads to the book feeling like it should have been produced as a series of articles in a publication. There are several places where it becomes difficult to place the sequence of events, what appears to be several jumps in time for tangentially related stories, and long sections of name dropping for people that do not even appear in the story.
If you are expecting to hear a more detailed story of the television show (which I was because I'm hooked on the show), you will be seriously disappointed. That being said, this was an interesting book about what could be going on in your local symphonies, and makes you think and want to question how that big business is actually run. It made me look at my tickets and attendance at performances in the amazing venues open to me in Houston, and wonder if I could and should be doing more to keep the arts alive for future generations. If you never played an instrument or do not appreciate the hard work involved in perfecting a craft, you will probably not appreciate this book in the spirit in which it was written. It is a lot of facts and figures which can get boring at times, but there is a story line in there worth searching out. Well read, as always, Ms. R!
Let me begin by saying that Blair, the adolescent oboist, is a hard character to like. She makes many, many errors (repeatedly), yet never sees the error of her ways until it’s too late. She appeals for strands of sympathy where I could give none — multiple affairs with married men, sleeping around to get jobs, blaming bad reeds, never having much foresight, etc. However, for those who understand some of the cracked veneer of the classical music scene, she does more than just take the polish off a gilded world. She beautifully critics the business behind classical music — the ride and fall of symphonies and philharmonics, the executives who work little but for large, unthinkable sums of money (far out earning the musicians). She reveals egotism, paranoia, emptiness, loneliness and the ever-abiding feeling of helplessness in the classical world.
Her writing made be difficult for some, not because of her language or grammer, but because of how often she intersects her story line with facts, figures, data and history. For a non fiction lover, I loved the format, but it can read as less of a memoir and more of a history record.
While I don’t like the character of Blair, I understand how she lived in a bubble for over 30 years, surrounded by only like minded, nearly identical people within her sphere. Without being exposed to other views, careers, or other types of people, it’s as if she was stunted at the age of 20, unable to grow or develop. And then suddenly, like cracking open a cocoon, she grows up. Whether that softens or lightens your opinion of her, is up to you. I highly recommend the book to anyone familiar with classical music, the arts or classical music non-profit organization.
Final note: while I am a huge fan of the Netflix Original Series, this is a wildly different ride from the story of Hailey, Rodrigo and NYC Symphony.