A Historical Curiosity

Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?

The radio plays are very short, so I didn't make too much of a commitment to this, but time may be better spent on an unabridged version of the novel.

Would you be willing to try another book from Lux Radio Theatre? Why or why not?

Lux Radio Theatre productions are oddities anyway - radio versions of big films (of the time) with the original stars, complete with adverts for Lux soap and endorsements by the film's female stars. They tend to sacrifice the clarity of the story as they're so brief - more like an edited highlights than a full story. This one is odder than most, however, as it includes a number of songs, which further reduces the time available for telling the story.

Who might you have cast as narrator instead of Nelson Eddy and Basil Rathbone ?

Well, you do need a singer, so Nelson Eddy is fine in this, although his acting is very limited. Basil Rathbone is at his scenery chewing peak, which suits the production values of Lux, but one definitely would not want to spend too much time with either. And as for Christine's soprano ....

Was The Phantom of the Opera (Dramatized) worth the listening time?

Listen to this as a curiosity, read the unabridged novel.

Any additional comments?

This Lux production was produced during WW2, and has some interesting references to wartime America (Ida Lupino's advice on hairpins, for instance).

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!