In the scourged kingdoms of Mirrowen, little hope survives.
Rumors stir of a hidden child who can stop the devastating plagues - and the race to find her has begun. The ruthless ruler of Kenatos, the Arch-Rike, and the people pledged to stopping him will do anything to make sure they're the ones to reach her first.
Because even though young Phae may be unaware that she is the long-lost daughter of Tyrus - the Arch-Rike's rival - there is no mistaking her gift. She not only wields the dangerous fireblood, but she can also steal the memories of anyone who looks into her eyes. Both Fireblood and Dryad-born, she alone can survive the Scourgelands long enough to learn the secrets hidden within the oaks - secrets that may reveal the origins of the plagues...and how to fight them.
Now Phae must learn to accept her newfound destiny or forever fear the steadfast evil of the Arch-Rike.
©2014 Jeff Wheeler (P)2013 Brilliance Audio, all rights reserved.
The story is interesting and different from the usual sword and sorcery books which is why I put up with the execrable narrator. I was expecting her to suddenly yell 'and LASHINGS of GINGER beer' at any moment.
The cadence of the narration was awful with frequent emphasis on the wrong words and a real jumble of downright dumb accents poorly realised. The first book was narrated by a much better narrator and I am sorry that they changed for this volume.
I can only hope that they change again for the third volume or I don't think I will be able to put up with it and will never hear the end of the story, although I will probably buy it in written word because, again, the story is really good!
I suggest Ms Pitkin would make a great job of narrating the Famous Five books.
The story is good, Sue Pitkin gets the intonation wrong a lot though, making it difficult to listen to.
This would really have benefitted from the attentions of a good copy editor, or even a proof reader. Repeating words twice in a sentence & misquoting famous sayings demonstrated a lack of attention to detail.
story is great but alas like others have said in other reviews the narration in this one is not up to the usual standard
book 1 was narrated by the guy that did the gentlemen bastards books so the bar was set really high for book 2 in this series
this narrater is pitchy squeeky and seems to use angry voices for no aparent reason
the start of each chapter starts with a passage from the archivist and altho its the same archivest she narates it in diff voices for some unknown reason this makes it confusing when depending on audio
also the prince in book 1 was a levelheaded softly spoken intelligent character but in this narration he seems to say everything in a really angry way
the same for his meek adoring cousin who for some reason gets a wicked witch voice
it seems that angry voice is the default setting in this narration so it is not a good pre bedtime listen as it will not soothe you
pitchy and scratchy
i really hope this series becomes availabewith someone like the female narater of the other books by mr wheeler
she was great
yet another great series ruined by changing the narrator,not only from male to female but one who's only character voices are a soft spoken cultured voice and I high pitched wizened old cackling voice that is like fingers on a chalk board ,which not only confuses you to as who is talkin as they all sound the same,female,male ,young,old it's all the same,in general I enjoy a woman narrating but on this occasion,such a disappointment
"Great Story Horrible Narration"
I would certainly listen to another of Jeff Wheeler's books, I totally enjoy his writing style. I would never try another book narrated by Sue Pitkin. She has no ability to narrate multiple characters in any distinctive fashion.
The performance would have been better if Michael Page narrated the second book as well as the first. Sue Pitkin was simply pathetic. I was perplexed by things such as how the Quiet Kishion takes on some sort of Arnold Schwarzenegger accent. He (she) sounded ridiculous. Her narration almost ruined the book for me.
"Great story, terrible narrator"
I would go back to Michael Page as the narrator. Sue Pitkin does okay when she isn't reading dialogue, but she can't read dialogue well to save her life. I can only listen to this book for short periods of time before I have to turn it off.
I got this audiobook despite the poor reviews of the narrator because I had the ebook already and it was only $2, but I would never waste a credit or pay full price for it. The book is excellent, but Pitkin was not the right choice at all. I feel like she'd do much better with something like Jane Austen rather than epic fantasy.
I enjoy everything about this story except the performer. It's a solid follow-up to the first book.
Her speech is exaggerated, her attempts at different accents are awful, and it is clear that she didn't listen to any of the previous book. Conversations between characters are painful and unnatural. As an example, the voice she uses for the archivist's passages is stilted and overdone while Michael Page's interpretation was scholarly and thoughtful. I grit my teeth every time one of those sequences comes up when I used to enjoy them. I gave her two stars because I can at least listen to her for short periods of time, but I have to take a break after long dialogues.
Reading time, heck yeah. Listening time... Just barely, maybe? It was better than not listening to a book at all, I guess.
Please, please, please, please bring Michael Page back.
more flushed out!
when you find out who the villain in hiding is.
did not care for the voice talent. accent were not the same as the first book I think.
"Good Story, Bad Narrator"
I liked the story, but the narrator was terrible
I highly recommend the first book of the series. The narrator was fun to listen to and made the characters come alive. I don't know why this book had a different narrator, but she could not use different character voices at all, so it could confusing when two characters were talking to each other. Another thing I didn't like about her was that would be just as dramatic with some mundane description or detail as she would an action sequence or with something important. That got old pretty quick.Anyway, I will probably listen to the next book in the series when it comes out if it has a different narrator. For this book, you would be better off to read it yourself.
"Amazing Book...Terrible Narrator"
This book is so great. I would listen to it as I fall asleep, but I would find myself staying up late trying to listen to more. The narrator is awful. I eventually got used to her voice, but I really hope audible has the narrator from Fireblood read the next book in the series. Again, this book is so good!
"Couldn't stomach the Narration"
The first part of the series was great... very promising and enjoyable. This second book seemed to have the same elements but the narration was at best unpleasant, but more often actually irritating. I gave up on the book about 3/4 of the way through because I couldn't stomach the narration (the first and only time I've done that with an audiobook)
"Love the story but not the narration."
Very bad narration so bad that I had to stop listening. Please re-record with Kate Rudd or Kate Reading.
This narrator used horrible voices for the male characters and made it impossible for me to listen to.
The story was wonderful with well defined characters and interesting story line.
The story itself is very creative and imaginative.
There is a surprise twist at the Counsel of 13 that I didn't see coming.
I will be listening to Poisonwell, as it is the 3rd book in the series and I want to finish the series, otherwise no- I will not listen to any more of Sue Pitkin's performances. I found that while she was simply narrating, her voice was pleasant to listen to, but her voicing of Phae was irritatingly "meek" and her voicing of every single "evil" character was shrill, whiny, and nasal. I couldn't stand it. She does do a fantastic job at the different accents.
No, I needed to take a break from the narrator, but I did listen to it often.
Don't expect Mirrowen to be anything like Muirwood. They are vastly different, although you will encounter the Fear-Liath and Kishion overlapping in both worlds. They are both fantastic worlds, creative and imaginative, but they are very different.
"Bad choice of narrator"
Most of the characters sounded too similar and whiny. The great spirit cat sounded like she was medicated or just waking up and all the men sounded like old women. It wasn't pleasant listening to this narrator - good story, but wish it was read by a more fitting performer.
"Great story, dismal narration"
Yes. Jeff Weaver creates compelling and complex worlds and characters, and this book is no exception. Unless they re-do it with a different narrator though, do yourself a favor and just read it.
Every time she made the word 'skeletal' rhyme with 'beetle' I was so dumbfounded that I had to back up to see what I missed while shaking my head. Several of the voices she characterized were shrill, annoying and over-done. I have heard many audio books in my day, and this was among the worst narration I have ever encountered.
You might want to consider re-doing this series with a worthwhile narrator.
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.