Astounded

In one word that explains how you feel after listening to this book. Clear and articulate with a flow that is almost fiction-like ... This book has both haunted and delighted me for months ... I don't honestly know where to turn but if the trends beautifully explained in this book continue unabated and unchanged then the future ahead will be a dystopian nightmare from which there is no escape!!

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Thought provoking!!

Really, really interesting, and excellently narrated by the author. Poses questions that make you consider the ethical values of commercialism: just because you can (afford to), should you?

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Compassionate economic philosophy

What did you like most about What Money Can't Buy?

Sandel is an antidote to the often dubious and heartless reasoning of mainstream economics. He uses clear language and examples from popular culture to illustrate his points.

Have you listened to any of Michael J Sandel’s other performances? How does this one compare?

Before buying this book, I had listened to Sandel's series on BBC Radio 4, 'The Public Philosopher', and his Reith Lectures. This book is in much the same vein; if you liked the Radio 4 lectures, I'd recommend this book, and vice versa.

Did you have an emotional reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?

Although this book discusses developments in our society that are quite depressing, I found it quite uplifting. It is a relief to hear someone who places compassion at the centre of his economic philosophy. Sandel always reminds me that among all the mercenaries of the world, there are a lot of genuinely decent human beings. We're not completely doomed.

Any additional comments?

One small thing: At about 3hrs 50mins, Sandel refers to a speech by 'Robertson', as if he has already discussed it. I thought I had missed something, but after checking back couldn't find any mention of it. Later in the book, Sandel does indeed discuss Dennis Robertson's speech. I think that sections of the book were moved around at the editing stage, and this non-sequitur was overlooked. If you have bought this book and have noticed this, I found this summary of the speech online:

Robertson (1954) claimed that by promoting policies that rely, whenever possible, on self-interest rather than altruism or moral considerations, the economist saves society from squandering its scarce supply of virtue. “If we economists do [our] business well,” Robertson (p. 154) concluded, “we can, I believe, contribute mightily to the economizing . . . of that scarce resource Love,” the “most precious thing in the world."

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

6 people found this helpful

I'd love to know what happens next!

Truly fascinating read. Thank you. This book might make you laugh, or despair, or perhaps like me it'll be both! Sandel is an incredible educator and philosopher. I love how impartially he presents material and provides you with all the arguments and objections on both sides so you can make your own mind up. I've listened to his Harvard Lectures on justice and political philosophy, as well as his BBC series "the Public Philosopher" and the "Global Philosopher" and would highly recommend those too for anyone who enjoys this book and wants more. I know it's not the central theme of the book but it would have been even better if Sandel would have also given all the outcomes for the legal cases he cited, afterall, the legal system is also supposed to reflect what society stands for so it would have been very interesting to know.

From the myriad of examples Sandel gives, the principles of free market economics and the delusion of the self-correcting "wisdom of the market" really has taken over what's driving our societies, almost completely overpowering social norms, human dignity and our sense of humanity. It's a real shame that what's so eloquently described and discussed in this book is certainly not the end of what we and Governments will permit to be bought and sold in future - all in the name of infinite growth, money, money and more money! Is this really who we want to be? If economists are right that humans are such rational actors, then I suppose it is... They're totally wrong though of course, ask any behavioural scientist or psychologist! All the advertising everywhere which he describes reminds me of scenes from numerous dystopian sci-fis.

I'd love to know what happens next but hopefully I'll be gone before people are literally selling their own grandmothers. Perhaps someone already took out a life insurance policy on me without my knowledge or consent, so at least my final act and legacy might be contributing to the magical economy and lining the pockets of some greed, corrupt individual or corporation. What a charming world and value system we cultivate and brainwash future generations to enjoy.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Superb analysis

For the first time someone has been able to crystallise and explain the misgivings I have felt about the commodification of everything that has occurred since the 1980s.

Michael Sandel sets out all the objections to 'market worship' in terms of the unfairness and corruption inherent in the economic view of every area of life, using a range of easy to understand examples from selling blood to viatical insurance.

I would recommend this book to everyone who feels uneasy at the idea of people having advertising slogans tattooed on their bodies, or who feel horrified at the idea of bidding to adopt a baby.

Most of all I would recommend it to anyone who really wants to understand the real meaning of "the price of everything and the value of nothing".

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Too many extreme examples

Although I understand and agree with Sandel’s point of view about the moral limits of market economy, Sandel uses too many repetitive examples, sometimes too extreme, to prove his point. This made the book hard to focus for me.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

FIRST CLASS IN ALL RESPECTS!

This should be a 'must read' for everyone who is concerned for ethics in a world that are children are going to inherit.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

Brilliant

Would you listen to What Money Can't Buy again? Why?

I've listened to this audio book a couple of times because there are so many ideas contained within it that one listen doesn't do it justice. It was good to listen and read the book at the same time. It's a real consciousness raiser.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

3 people found this helpful

A good read

Interesting book will give you new perspective to the economy driven society. The down side of the book it gives too much examples of the same idea and one can get bored. Overall, it is good book and I enjoyed it.

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!

A little slow, especially if you’re already in agreement

If you’re quite left wing, and already recognise a lot of criticisms of capitalism and neoliberalism, this book will seem quite slow. It is comprehensive and engaging if not though

You voted on this review!

You reported this review!