©2007 Victor Brooks; (P)2009 Audible, Inc.
This is a well written and narrated account of war in the pacific following Pearl Harbour (Harbor) up to the atomic bomb. It is a balanced account highlighting US mistakes and internal politics alongside successes. Apart from the continual use of the word 'However' and many comparisons to the American civil war which seem out of place I would thoroughly recommend this book to anybody who wishes to know about war in the pacific. Fascinating.
"Great story of an important battle"
Brooks account of the various battles in the Marianas is compelling and well researched. And very readable. I highly recommend this to anyone interested in the Pacific campaigns.
"Good, but Not Great, Story of Little Known Invasio"
It was a more in-depth look at the invasions and the fact that Adm King focused on the Marianas early on in the war. It is pretty disjointed in the beginning. There is not much about the individuals involved in the fighting. The book talks about them and their situations, but not much about any one. You need stamina to get through the whole book.
He is pretty monotone in the beginning. He got better as time went on, or I got more used to it.
Yes, if you need in-depth information about these invasions, though you will be tempted to quit listening.
The pronunciation of the town and geographic names on Saipan is atrocious. I don't know if this is due to the narrator or the author. If it is from the author, he might have used a Japanese map. Its not anything you might notice unless you lived there, but it drove me nuts.
"Hell is Upon Us."
A Great story of WW ll in the Pacific. I loved this Book and would highly recommend this to anyone. The War in the Pacific was so different from Europe. It is a must to listen to.
If another book were offered by this author, I would definitely make it a point to listen to the preview in its' entirety before purchasing. I found a few of the historical facts to be incorrect, such as referring to Herman Kossler (the captain of the USS Cavalla which sunk the Japanese carrier Shokoku) as James Kossler. Mistakes like this bother me on two levels: first and foremost, this gentleman was awarded the Navy Cross for this fantastic battle action, the least we can do is get his name correct. Secondly, when I see such a glaring error that is easy to research it leads me to wonder what other inaccuracies are contained in the work.
Another aspect I did not care for was the constant comparisons of segments of this battle to the American Civil War. One or two references was sufficient; after the first dozen or so I found myself starting to laugh as yet another comparison would be made in this regard. It got to the point of enough already, I can't believe he's trying to draw this comparison again!
The tone of the narrators voice was pleasant enough, but his overall speech was so robotic it sounded like it could have been a synthesized computer voice.
I am sure that this author is a fine man, but I would submit that perhaps he could research and produce his books more carefully and that he should refrain from overly tiresome references to another war or time period.
"Glad I wasn't there..."
You could feel the stress.
The descriptions of conditions, and sites,smell, and mind set.
A good story teller with a 40's kind of way.
I like to strech it out over a couple days. I look forward to sitting back closing my eyes and let my ears fill my mind.
I wish there was a movie
Report Inappropriate Content
If you find this review inappropriate and think it should be removed from our site, let us know. This report will be reviewed by Audible and we will take appropriate action.